ML20054M244

From kanterella
Revision as of 02:54, 14 November 2023 by StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot change)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Application for Issuance of Deposition Subpoenas Directed to Bp Garde,T Devine,L Clark & L Hallberg.Applicant Unable to Obtain Info Re Author Affidavits & Allegations in Affidavits Relevant to Proceeding.Certificate of Svc Encl
ML20054M244
Person / Time
Site: Midland
Issue date: 07/08/1982
From: Steptoe P
CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.), ISHAM, LINCOLN & BEALE
To:
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
ISSUANCES-OL, ISSUANCES-OM, NUDOCS 8207120159
Download: ML20054M244 (17)
v • d • e


Text

4 0

48 00 m 0 0)

USHRC UNITED STATES OF AMERICA .. -.- "

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 12 Jll-9 NO:2,,

Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing hf4cn.<ECRGAW' CE 0F 5 idalu

, DMQi

/

d I~

In the Matter of '

') ' !

) -

CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY ) Docket Nos. '50-329-OM

) 50-330-OM (Midland Plant Units 1 and 2) ) 50-329-OL

) 50-330-OL CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY'S APPLICATION FOR DEPOSITION SUBPOENAS Pursuant to 10 C.F.R. SS 2. 720 (a) , and 2.740a (a) ,

Consumers Power Company (" Applicant") hereby applies to the 1 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board (" Licensing Board")

to issue the attached deposition subpoenas to Billie P. Ga'rde, Thomas Devine, Lewis Clark and Lucy Hallberg, commanding them to appear to give their depositions at the time and place j indicated on the attached subpoenas. In support of this l

Application, Applicant states:

1. Billie P. Garde, Thomas Devine, Lewis Clark and Lucy Hallberg are associated with the Government Accountability Project (" GAP"). Acting under the auspices of GAP, these persons submitted affidavits.to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission alleging a pattern of poor work quality at Applicant's f

Midland plant. These persons have also given extensive information to the press regarding the allegations contained in the GAP affidavits. (See Attachment No. 1, articles from the June 28, 1982 edition of the Midland'Caily News).

8207120159 B20708 gDRADDCK 05000329 PDR Jg[3

'4

2. Applicant has been unable to obtain information regarding the allegations contained in the GAP affidavits or copies of the affidavits themselves from the NRC Staff or from GAP.
3. The allegations contained in the GAP affidavits and the information upon which the allegations are based are e

relevant to the proceedings now before the Licensing Board.

In her " Response to Board's Request For Reasons For Late Filing of New Contentions", Intervenor Mary Sinclair expressed her intention to file another set of new contentions based on the " extensive documentation" of quality control and safety problems which has allegedly been supplied to GAP by workers at the Midland plant. Applicant will be unable to evaluate or respond to such new contentions unless it is given access to the documentation supplied to GAP by the Midland workers.

4. The allegations contained in the GAP affidavits ,

are also relevant to the proceedings before the Licensing J Board because the Licensing Board itself stated, in the  ;

conference call of July 2, 1982, that these allegations ',

would be among the issues raised in the hearings on the Midland facility scheduled for October, 1982. Without l

access to the GAP affidavits and the information on which they are based, Applicant can neither prepare for the October

~}

hearings nor determine whether the GAP allegations are a }

proper subject for litigation.

5. Applicant is not attempting to discover the -

y~

identities of the GAP affiants. The " Schedule of Documents

~ . , , _

/~, .i,

, v. ~

  • g #

~

]

[ .7 .- ~

, Requested" attached to the' deposition subpoenas requests

[ ' " copies;of thelGAP affidavits wi~th the identities of affiants

~

U

.c - .

s snd? identifying intermation regarding them deleted. Moreover,

e

7 _Applicaat(willlnotaskforthenamesoftheaffiantsduring

' "w ,f .

ihe'requdsted' t depositions.

~

There is no need, therefore, to

,j =~ ,

. / issue afprotective order protecting ag3 inst disclosure of

the GAP affiants' identities. , .

L,_ x ^ 6. Appropriate fees will be paid to the deponents,

~~~'~inaccordancewith'IheTO'C.F.R. S 2.74.0a(h). Once the di - ~-

- /

requested subpoenas:are, issued, Isham, Lincoln & Beale will pick up the subpoenas frora Licensing Board's offices in -

Bethesda and sel.ve, the :[tibpoenas to the deponents residing ,

in Washington, D.Cb a ..

'M .,Hallber will be served in Michigan by a non-party, pursuant to 10 C.F.R. S 270.(c).

WHEREFORE, Applicant respectfully requests that its " Application for Deposib on Subpoenas" be granted and

_ .?

the the Board issue the attached deposition subpoenas to

~

l Billie.P.;O5rde, Lewis Clark, Thomas Devine and Lucy Hallberg.

o g -Respectfully submitted, 1

~

Yb tkb Ob~

[e One of tile Attornfys for" #

j Consumers Power Company

ISHAM, LINCOLN & BEALE l

Three First National Plaza Suite 5200 I Chicago, Illinois 60602

  1. ! DATED:

,4 y ll ~ )

g *

/ )

'wr " ll ./. , , .. . - -

l .

, .,,,.,3._ -

' . %- uA -

, _ . - -M P

4 I

l

- - - - ~ - . ,

s

.m

, ,. . _. u- .

. r

. _ . ~ .. ... _._ . ., .

, m.T_.w .m..,.-e . '

J a

s GAP wa.ntS i,  :

t d

! plant. .;c.w .to 2,. be . a rceF .

l i

i I

(

0 test .CaS e ' norNi 2-t l l

WD. D, *. q. Mr f.r Om l

.s w S eret.P .e f t.W hg. sa p s" h C.a_w r r F.8.PA.AI.L. th. SAD g s

.i .e .f th. Afti t .s S 0 . 'ah

- . , .Sh- n- C.h- . . e..t.N. - .

.c.

r

. r. e .y .e w '

. by .

[

' . .s. T.e.I.t,. ,

A w ass,

. a_ .G,.t.t

c. 1 r.t.h m,.49 eMi.s nm ry = &.1 -so y-l

.! , om..: tet. .

.F..,,y s. I

,w W e.r. Ib.y F

. ...T, . . m C) '

e.r.br.st l

i

. .s.' 'i 1,ry Pr

/. .:c.h.%-,W.....,.;, G.r .. nr tpf v. Th. ( r .6 1

. p; w.4 .w oC . A ad.r. .b 3.EC sa (

JM e A 6s .. .f . p. Iu Eh .

G.4 P ,r wfsa . .h. . .e 1

, ., e,,,, .m s.a,g..

n ."J.33 A . ea r. a. . la r.a . .r resg .

'a'., ,g gve - a p A. oi ~ et 9 D g_

. y i.e ca. .

w

&- -. r . . n. . .r ,

eygggh ,Jg,y g,g .e y/.* N.y.

ca, ,

, , .-. - n.C e ,

  • y e s e.a. .g ..a a rTina.s* e r... G reig J

. . - .r . - e. - -

-.4e

. Mss . ,{*[, v M., t

. a L W OAP.i ewy .

ven. ps .

.r er.

S.h ~.

". 9, c.ap

_e. - . .r r.s. .- .. .

GAPt.W.al a C f.,a re h- , i- - ~

i C, . . ,

ry. ch. .rt se i _ p, r. ,r.c pa g th. .e in. D.e Ch a

-t' r. a.m s Ch y

g .a .h a./*-e p

)

- *- ***,n.c o .. . . . .r.

i r .c . ,

u, .

.., t

. . m..r .. -

. = - -

-,.o. . or .m.

=a .

. [,

TTh,.,n C e.e.ie.st. - , rt . ,.,-.D.w .f t

A.3 _.,- h__. -

y e. 4 g

. ...c es CA.P. e as o . *. .

o

.f e e, r ca r e g a.r.J a 4

}

u,e, r_a.e8 .... =~r a.,*,.

.m. i.,. , , , .,,,,, .. air. - -

,a

,,a ., r.rr, 6.' Ca.s s Ci.a .n c~

  • =r< D.a.* n.o a.= .,,,,,r,

. . . %.,..e.......

,,,.e..._.

. .ror. . i p . - .

a~..-r....

-_ , ... . .r. .

. . . .-. . w t

. ... r.., .. i

.c.. . ..m .

~-.~.a. . ., m 1

i

. ea..C.O,. O . .

.~C,r.-- ,

I e it.

h E a. .,.e GAP e..=,,o..r..C e

.g r

,r.u. . .m.

r. -.

.e e a r

e.-

sua

= 1,

-.u.~..

-. I.I .s.ea

- r

..r i

.mr. s. .

- -_ t-i .

=

j in

~ .o.u.to-.a uvwsC. paury .m e,.

.c.. . .r r .

,-..c

~~o.~u"." -

~~

t, e

i, '

r,

,- . - , u. .c ,n

.--r. F o C. m a--.=-=,,,,,7~,

,=.;,; ,, , ,

, , n.- . .. , . , f . :. a- r-

--. e . , . . _ . ., i. -

..-. -a..

.. r . .r. _

.= .c z , r. r

,f.,

. j <. u. . ,

nw w.i st y in.

.n as

. i. . c s .

r.

i

.gg p.t a.r.ee s s 14 n .s.s q. . 8.r th t e a . g.e.g .v. g a

  • 3,

,. , C.r a.e g.,g. th Pt th.

C' u

e (Afflg. .f 1.

9.r .

(g,S,,.th ggy - _ ,. _- . _,gg . k, W ,,gg t.g., g g,,

e,g. .. _ ,

o,g , .rth.81 r. r. .r. t l. (On w

- - - - . s . -h.qt,OC. . .th. pr

. .  ?

y .p.o .. .

...u.q y g f , fr g e.g.r et. F y.4 . 43 4 h.d

. m . . . .. e a . .h . gisy.
  • M, .

1,.r.

5. .".i2"E2~~_.,'_Phd_enix' fails ' tdiisd',
  • 4 .

I i

t i _ _.. - - - - - - - - - - - - . - -

l Nuclear plan? pf. 0Dieng :fLga:  ;

a l

Related atory,pa ge 3... ,.

IN Tile- c.AFFIDAVITS. plant wprbp n whether this would be significant are i plant, he sell he 4 detailed: -+

.s- . n..u was " astoni

?- ?c .. enknown factors which By PAUL R AU '-

  • The 9 powerhouse shuffid."

I Daily News staff writer  ! technique used by workers to look busy . inve stigated byfartechnical that were esby perts..should below those set national

  • be . find
  • I believe there is a very real Cables intended to carry important - without doing 'anything. Prime con. posslbility that the operator may ha ve to societies of professionaj engineers. ' g

That person said in an affidavit. "The information nuclear platit maytonot operators of the house function properly Midland . tractor Bechtel encourages the " power. deal with stray, shuffle" because. the longer signals telling hem something is hap.

random or erroneous new specifications th are needs of a nuclear facility. Spect.

because made unauthorized by 4he plant's substitutions cable shop. a former more matersal were theyworkers use, the more take profittonotdohappenmg their jobs when and at is. the , pening when at isn't.or that something is)' Iscations for plant worker has said in an affidavit Bechtel will make under its cost plus "If the operator should' grow accus. are stricter than those tolersted by I

given Project.to the Government Accountability contract alleged. with Consumers. One worket tomed to false alarms or inaccurate Bechtel nuclear in the-plant." construction of the I

. P e

In another affidavit collected by GAP- . yo, ,,,g,,s.once cut up 8250.000 signals, it could lead to ignoring a real This person - who had top level another former worker said defective eveth of good cable snd threw it awae clan problem wrote. should one occur /f the electri. responsibihty for weldmg - said other welds can be found throughout the plant because the paperwork had gotten los't ' .

Inspectors admitted to him they had ,/ I' '

because welders were inesperienced and Bechtel feared an inspector would .

approved bad welds for years before the i and because pporly trained QuelltF ^ notice. #

, TIIE SAME PitRSON described th, , engineer showed them proper welding

  • Ilour workers learped techniques to " powerhouse shuffle." and said he once techniques.

Control (QC) inspectors approved bad . deceive QC inspectors. such as shorti spent two days measuring things for no . Ile rsid Internal '#' corrosion of s welds for years.

reason and wad , praised toe his berc peping. which Bechtel QC inspec.

A third forn.er nuclear plant worker ening bolts when there wasn't room to Industrbusness. II said shipments of defective ductwork install them properly. ,

were installed despite objections ba* s

  • Widespread drug and alcoholabu'se.' : was there any need for the measure, "is in my opIneon inescusable, and "It didn't matter what i measured. nor lors ."never took the time" to look for.

sjeeping on the. Job and an underground certainly very dangerous to the suc. fa causebuildmg fanish management the plant' was in a hurry to ,. operation in which workersments. crafted That's bell an esample of the cessfuloperationof theplant."

' powerhouse shuffle'" The electrician s

La Asked to comment on these and other buckles from stainless stegl and dicke{ said be did it becaupe there was'no work * *I allegations which will be formally made saleon plant materials and offered them (or to do on those days. Tile ENGINEER faulted Bechtel for 8 pubhc Tuesday. Consumers Power Co. the site!' I hiring inesperienced welders and in- 4 plant spokesman Norman Saarl said the 1- ,

. ( 'i' - The person said Bechtel . has "an spectors and not training them properly. -

utility cannot respond untd GAP arsen.g og ..ysa to impos, a slow p c, Ile claimed to percent of all piping in de.

the plant has been torn out and replaced 8 provides details on til e charges. "All we know is what they are channeling to the Daily News were pritten by persons who patting ,fast claimed they were fired for being $oo 'at oneworkgro withand time or another, slow said ones,TWG stir

I OF Ti

  • Bechtel's inddlerence to quality will po' has not been successful. and it's notmedia. Our communication with GAP; correct quelltf defecta at the plant. aggressiv and placing a worker where he is least allowed topass on their costs to the < S' lse this morning. we haven't tried/,*

because Saarl said, seal, they charged, despite posters pubitc.~was not interested in setb ', gr wrote,'egManagement competent.

.e The electrician "There is the When the englacer was terminated lie said the plant's prime contractor,* the site cialming otherwise.1 * . 5.6 ade

' temptation to dismisa such incidents as . earlier this year, he said he was told he 85 Bechtel Power Corp., the focus of inany of GA P's charges. alse wili not comment left Midland because it was like a soo. I e bot deliberate. flut raci incidenta are aThe t s things were done at Midland."

16d

, idll third quit f and is deferring all response to was could not tive with myself knowing that t { $ay of lie at the plant and far too . The engineer said in his affidavit.

partici t PF Consumers. ~ of worms,pating in filling that ' bucket (common to be dismissed.' On saany} "After nearly 20 years of .j**work as an .

- a term use trorkers."one former wor.d on-site by doccasions. I had been told 'la advancy engineer, t hnow a deficient weld when I GAP INTENDS to present the affidavit. ke[said in aa 'that my assignment would be torn out see one, and I know how many of these

/t See workers

  • allegations to the Nuclear .

s' o tuben t wee done." ,yp walds and other problems went unde-R egulatory Commission Tuesday, and to A former electricianiwho left the ku i

press the NRC to take action. GAP is a Midland project thlt spring said the JtpI{swork said crews som-times would bg pug tected or ignored by the men responsible 9 ode

- non government. cable shop routinely substituted control ycable-spre. at. cross purposes. 14 4 for inspecting them. Bechtel has shewn ,,p , la D C.-based group established to protect ader

  • reora. . the electriclah by its attitude that it cannot be trusted to . a Washington. cables when the correct type , wag .said. .*Ne tore out whet the day shifg perform workers who espose waste. fraud and unavailable, and espressed fear the jinstelled and tlpey tore out what' we necessary in a nuclear plant." this work of the corruption- substituted cable will nor give futyre Fl

. The Daily News read and took plant operators correct information. . Installed. After a month of this I asked . Ile said a fullinvestigation of Bechtel ,

85 {

encerpts from three of seven affidavita For esample, the electrician said a , doraand ' received se demorali a transfer because* j( would conclude thal anuch work will Ing."i GAP plans to give to the NRC after a cable design may have called for therg have to be redone before Midland can go t,s i shleided pairs of Iggauge wire, but (44

c. . + ( ' into operation. The cost of this will be . my three month investigation. GAP is not cable shop in which he worked would ung, g ypt0 tiler s . FORMER workest . a enormous. .lf it can be done at alt.

nuclear engineer with 17 years erperg. Despite the cost. I cannot stand by and Q , revealing current the identity plant workers 14 talked to, ofandthe shleiding former around and sla-stranded the entire bundle. *;

14 gauge wire with $he jace at als nuclear plants (including, act watch8 the plan the NRc has agreed to do likewise unless Consumers' Palisades plant), called the state of safety. ,- ,

. 7 the information leads to hearings by This person told G AP. "Whether one Afidland plant "the worst .

8 Congressional committees. conductor may induce a current in facility l ha ve ever seen.a nucleac. } "To do so would be to betray my another conductor within the shield end w haa h- h----"-- -* " * * " * ~ ~ "

responsibilities as a professional as sa L.

EnitED SMtES Irf ArnErim NUCLEAR REGULATORY C05BfISSION n 1 v

In the matter of: -

CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2) > DOCKET NO. 50-329-OM 50-330-OM 50-329-OL TO 50-330-OL Lewis Clark Government Accountability Project -

1901 Q Street, NW Washington, D.C. 20009 YOU ARE HEREBY CONDIANDED to appear a t,,,,t h,9,,,,o,f,f,,i c,e,,,g,(,,,J ,s,h,am f,, ,,,,.,,,,,,

...L..i.n..c..o

.. l..n.....&. ...B..e..a.l..e..,....1.2.. 2. 0....C...o n..n e c t i c u t Ave . , NW, Suite 840 in th e city o f ...W..a s..h..i..n..g.t..o..n...,....D...

. C..

on the.. 2.0.tb....... day o f......J.9 1 .Y.................. 19.. 8,2.. ..a t....... 9.1.9.0....... 0'clo ek A \f-to textify o n behalf o f . 9.9.X.95.nm.e,n t ,3,c,c,g,un,t,@ il,i,t,y,,,P rg,j,e c t,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,y,,,,,,_,

be deposed in the above entitled action and bring with you the document (s) 3r object (s) described in the attached schedule.

BY ORDER OF THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD BY ArrORNEY FOR CONSUMERS _ , , ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,j9,, , , , ,

POWER COMPANY philio P. Stentoe, Esq.

Tcham. T. i ncol n & Beale TELEP!f0NE (312) 558-7500 10 C.F.R. 2.720 (t) preadme ofpcer or. sf he ut unvaaabia. The On monon made promptly. and m any ennt Commn12xon may (1) quash or modify the sub-at or before the nme specified in the nebpoena poena sf it ts unreasonable or requnres ersdence for complianet by the person to whom rne sub- not rtievent to any matter m Lisue. or (.') con ~

poena is directed. and on nonce to the party at dinon densat of 7%e monon on just and reasonable wore m21cnce the subpoena was issued, tne term t.

t RETURN ON SERVICE Re ce ived t h is s u b p o e na a t....... ... ... . .. .. ... ........ .. .. .... . ..... .. . . .. . . ... .. ... . . . . .. .. ... .. .. ... . ... ...o n

......................................andon...........................'.st..............................................

serv ed i t o n th e wi th in n a m ed .. .. . . . .... ... .. ...... . ..... . . . .. .... .. . . ...... .. .. . .... ... ..... .... .. . . .. ..

by delivering a copy to h..... and tendering to h..... the fee for one day's s'ttendance and the mileage allowed by law.1 D a t ed . . . . . . . . . . . .. .. . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . 1 9 . . . . . . BY......................................................

Service Fees Tra vel .. .. ... . .. ... .. ........ S Servi ces..................... S To tal .. . . . . . . . ..... .. .. . . . ... S Su bseribed and swo rn to before me. a ....... ........... ........this..............................

da y o f. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 9 . . . . .. .

NOTE - Affidavit required only if senice is made bf a person other than 3 United States Marshal or his deputy.

I Fees and maiecre need not be tendertt! to the matness upon servste of 2 subt'ocru issued in behalf of the Unsted St:tes or an ofj7cer or atency thereof. :b CSC 13:3

EnitED $2Ht25 Uf A1HEriEU NUCLEAR REGULATORY COM3 FISSION v

I l

In the matter of: '

CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY (Midland plant, Units 1 and 2) 50-329-OM

> DOCKET NO.

50-330-OM 50-329-OL l TO 50-330-OL i Thomas Devine Government Accountability Project ,

1901 Q Street, NW Washington, D.C. 20009 YOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED to appear ..^.t tg,e ,,o{,fice o{,,3,s,h,am, , , , , ,, , , , , , , , ,,,,,,,.,,,,,

..Lin.9.9 An...&....B.9.aag,,,,, A1,2,0,,,,g,9,p,gg,g,t ig,u t,, A,y,e,,.,,c,,,N,,, W ,f,,, S,gi,t,9,,,,8,4,0,,,,,,,,,,,, ,, , , ,

in th e ci ty o f .. ..W#.S.h i DSA9 D.4.. .Q. . .Q.t. ... ... .. . .. . . . . .. ... . .. ..... .. .... .. . . .. ... .. .... .. . .. .. ..... .. ....... . .....

o n the.....l.9 t,h...... day o f.....Y.9. Y............ .. ...19... 8,2....a t............l.i.0. 9... 0' clock P.M.

to XMYIEK on behalf of ......G.Q.y.9xDagDA..S. . 9.9DAability...P.K.9.icGA..............:...... .

be deposed in the above entitled action and bring with you the document (s) or object (s) described in the attached schedule.

BY ORDER OF THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD BY ATTORNEY FOR _ "GNSUMERS . . , , , , ,19 ,. .. ,,,

POWER COMP % f Philio P. Stectoe, Esq.

Tsham. Lincoln & Beale TELEPHONE (312)558-7500 10 C.F.R. 2.720 (() pres, dint articer or. af he ss unvastaata, the on monon made promptly. and in any ewnt Commnssion may (1) quasn or modify the sub-at or before the nme spectfied un the 1 subpoena poena if it ss unressonable or requeret es,dence l for compliance by the person to whom tne sub- not relennt to any matter en issue, or (:l con- l poena it directed. and on nortce to tne party at dtnan densal of t*It monon on just and reasonable swsose nnstance the subpoena Mt 122ued, the terms.

r RETURN ON SERVICE Re ce ived t h is s u b p o e na a t. . ..... ... ... . .. .. ... ..... ..... .. .... . . .... ... .... . .. .... ..... ... . . ..... .. . ........ .o n

......................................andon............................'.at...............................................

served i t o n th e wi thin na m e d .. . ....... . .. . ........ . .. .. .. . .. .. . .. . ... . . ...... . ... . .... . . .... . ..... . . . ... .

by delivering a copy to h..... and tendering to h..... the fee for one day's attendance and the mileage allowed by law.I D a t ed . . . . . . . .. . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 1 9 . . . .. . BY......................................................

Service Fees Tra vel .. .. ... . ... ..... ........ S Services..... . ............. S To ta l.. . .. . . ...... . . .. .. ..... S Subsc ibed and sw o rn to befo re m e, a ................ ...........this....... . ...... ............

da y o f. . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 9. . . . .. .

NOTE - Affidavit required only if service is made bp a person other than a United States Marshal or his deputy.

I Fres and .micate need not be renderer! ro tne sutness upon seersce of a :ubrocna ss:ued in be*salf of the Unsted St:tes or en officer or spener thereof. :b CSC !!:2

Enitch States of America NUCLEAR REGULATORY C0515 FISSION v

In the rnatter of: -

CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2) >- DOCKET NO. 50-329-OM 50-330-OM 50-329-OL TO Lucy Hallberg 50-330-OL 3819 Chestnut Hill Midland, Michigan 48640 '

YOU ARE HERESY COhihiANDED to appear At,,,,th,9,,,,C,9,n,suggg,s,,,Rg,y,eg..,,,,,,.,,,,,,

...C..o..m. P.a. .n.. X. . .M..i.d..l..a.n. .d.... .S. .e. r. .v. .i..c. .e. ...C..e..n. ..t e. .r. . . . . . .. . .. .. . . . . .. . . . . .

in th e ci ty o f ...M. .i d.. .l. .a. .n..d.. .,....M..i.c...h. .i. 2 a..n. .. . . .. .. .. .. . . . . .. ...... ..... . . .... .. . . ..... . .. .. .. . .. .. .. .... . .... . . ... .

on the....1J.s.t..... day a f............J.u,1y........... 19,.3.2......a t...... ......l.i.9.0... 0'clo ck P 3{,

to texttfy on behalf of . 9. .X.*.rnmg,nt Accogg,tabi1ity,,,Prg,pg,t,,,, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ,

be deposed in the above entitled action and bring with you the document (s) or object (s) described in the attached schedule.

1 l

l l

l BY ORDER OF THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD BY l

ATTOR.NEY FOR CONSUMERS , , , , , , , , ,j 9 POWER COMPANY philin p. Stectee. Ega, l

Tcham- T.i n cn i n c_ nm16 TE!.EPHONE (312) 558-7500 10 C.F.R. 2.720 (i) prendsnt oft 1cer or. si he ss unvastacle. the On monon made proonptly, and in any ewnt Commsssson may (1) quasn or modsfy the sub-at Qr before the 'me specsfied an the nsbpoena poena if it is unreasonable or requsres ersdence for camcliance by the person to mnom tne sub- not relevant to any *. natter un issue, or (.') con-poena is dirreted, s nd an nonce t3 the party at danon Jensal of t*te monon on just and reasonable m* sore snrtance the ubpoene . 4' %ed, the term t.

RETURN ON SERVICE Re ce ived t h is s u b p o e na a t.. .. ..... . ... . . . .. ... . ....... .. ...... . ..... .. . ... . . ...... . .. . ... . ..... . . ... .... ...o n

.......................................andon............................'.at.............................................

served i t o n th e w i thin na m e d .. .. . . . ... .. . .. .... .. . ...... . .... ... . ... . ...... . . . . . .... . . . .. .. . ...... . . ....

by delivering a copy to h..... and tenderin to h..... the fee for one day's attendance and the mileage allowed by law.1 D a t ed . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . .. . . 1 9. . . . . . BY....................................................

Service Fees Tra vel .. .. . . . .. .. .. .. . .... . ... S Senices.. .... .............. S To ta l.. . .. . .. . . . .. . . . .. . . . .. . S Su bseribed a nd sw o rn to before me, a . ..........................this..... ........... .... .......

da y a f. . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 9 . . . . . . .

NOTE - Affidasit required only if senice is made bf a person other than a United States Marshal or his deputy.

I Fus and mascere need not be tendevert to the mseness upon sensce of a stabi'osrus issteed in behalf of the Cnste9 States Er On @ffleGr 69 5 ten @t there@]f. :s C:C !!:3

Enitch Ea::es n" America NUCLEAR REGUI.ATORY C0515 FISSION

-o-In the matter of: -

CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2) >. DOCKET NO. 50-329-OM 50-330-OM 50-329-OL TO Billie P. Garde 50-330-OL Government Accountability Project 1901 Q Street, NW '

Washington, D.C. 20009 YOU ARE HEREBY COM51ANDED to appear ....At..the..R.f.fic.c..o.f...Lsham.c. Lincoln a, n d.,,p. e,a,1 e ,,,,,1,1,,2,g,,,C,ggysg,t i,c,g,t,, ,Aye,:, ,,,, NW, f,,, S,u,i,,t e,,,8,,q Q,,,,,,,,,,, , , ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

in th e c i ty o f ..W ..s h,i, gg,t,g g,g ,,,Df ,,C, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ,,, ,,,,,, ,,,,,,,,,,,, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

on the...l.9.th....... day of.......J.V.lv 19. 8,,2......a t....... 9.i.9.9........ 0'clo ek A 51.

to liiOUhX on behalf o f .G.9.Y.c.Knav.01..A.gc,g,y,g, tab,i,1,i,t,y,, P,r,gie,g,t,g,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,;,,,,,,_,

be deposeu in the above entitled action and bring with you the document (s) or object (s) described in the attached schedule.

BY ORDER OF THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD BY s

l ATTOR.NEY FOR ] CONSUMERS ,, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,3 9 ,, ,, ,,,, ,,,

l POWER COPANY Philin p. Stentoe, Esq.

Tcham. i.incoln & Beale TEl.EPHONE 10 C.F.R. 2.720 (f) pressesnt officer or. sf he is unvailable. the on monon made promptly, and sn any own! Commissson may (1) qua,tn or modify the tub-at or before the nme specified In the stebpoena poena if it Lt unreasonable or requeret evndence for compliance by the person to whom the sub- not relevant to env matter un issue. or (.') con-poena 22 directed, and on nonce to the party at dsnan Jensat of tone monon on putt and reasonable wnote Intrance the tubcorne was it,tued the terms.

T RETURN ON SERVICE Re ceiv ed this s u b p o e na a t.... ... .. . . .. ... .. ............. .. ..... ..... ... . ... .... ... .. .. .... .. ... .. .. .. .. ... .. .o n

......................................andon.............................at...............................................

serv ed i t a n th e w i th in na m ed .. . .. . . ... . ... .. ...... . ..... . .... . ... ... . . ....... ... ..... . . . ..... . ..... .. . ....

by delivering a copy to h..... and tendering to h..... the fee for one day's

~

attendance and the mileage allowed by law.1 D a t ed . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . .. 1 9 . . . .. . BY......................................................

Service Fees Tra vel .. .. . .. . . .. .. ....... .... S Services..... ............... S To tal . . . . . . . ... .... . .. .. .. . S Su bseribed and sw o rn to before me, a ....... ... .... ...........this................. ....... ....

da y o f. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . ,1 9 . . .. .

NOTE - Affidavit required only if service is made bp a person other than a United States Marshal or his deputy.

I Fees and maccre need not be tenderett to rne wurness upon senser of a subt'ocna issued on behalf of the Unsted States or en efacer er anener enorreff, :s CSC 13:3

o

,.? .

SCHEDULE OF DOCUMENTS REQUESTED f

i I. Definitions

1. " Communication" means and includes, but is not limited to, all discussions, conversations (personal, telephonic or by any other medium), inquiries, negotiations,
meetings, understandings, notes, drafts, agreements, letters, I

telegrams, " telex", or other forms of oral or written inter-change.

2. " Document" means the original, any copies when an original is unavailable and any non-identical copies (whether different from the original because of notes made
on such copies or otherwise), regardless of origin or location, of any handwritten, typewritten, printed, recorded, transcribed, punched, taped, photocopied, photostatic, " telexed", filmed, microfilmed or otherwise prepared matter, however produced

! or reproduced, including, but not limited to, all papers, letters, correspondence, telegrams, telexes, cables, memoranda or minutes of meetings or conversations (personal or tele-phonic), desk pads, calendars, diaries, telephone pads, travel and expense records, reports, summaries, surveys, analyses, ledgers, journals, and other formal or informal i books of records or accounts, bulletins, instructions, agreements, legal documents, billing records, drafts, note-books, worksheets, time records, vouchers, and writing of i every description, including drawings, charts, photographs, f i.1. ins , recordings, computer tapes and printouts and other i

i

. - - , - . . . _ - .- , ~ , - - - . . . - , - ~ . . - . - , . . . . , .

~,

}

data or compilations from which information can be obtained and translated, if necessary, by deponent into reasonable usable form.

II. Documents Requested

1. All statements and affidavits supplied to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission by the Government Accountability Proj ect (" GAP"), relating to work or conditions at Consumers Power Company 's Midland plant, with the affiant's name and any information which would disclose the affiant's identity deleted.
2. All documents relating to GAP's investigation of the Midland project, including but not limited to all documents provided to GAP by affiants, all statements of present or former employees of Consumers Power Company at the Midland plant taken by GAP which were not supplied to the NRC and all drafts of statements given to GAP by present or former employees of Consumers Power Company at the Midland Plant.
3. All communications between Barbara Stamiris or Mary Sinclair on one hand and GAP, representatives of CAP, Billie P. Garde, Lewis Clark, Lucy Hallberg or Thomas Devine on the other.

.o UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of ) Docket Nos. 50-329 OM

) 50-330 OM CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY )

) Docket Nos. 50-329 OL (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2) ) 50-330 OL CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY'S APPLICATION FOR DEPOSITION SUBPOENAS were hand delivered to Charles Bechhoeffer, Jerry Harbour, and William D. Patton were served on the other person's listed below by deposit in the United States Mail, First Class Postge Pre-Paid, this 8th day of July 1982.

b OA;

/ /

/

Joseph Gallo

e

  • e SERVICE LIST Frank J. Kelley, Esq. Steve Gadler, Esq.

Attorney General of the 2120 Carter Avenue State of Michigan St. Paul, Minnesota 55108 Carole Steinberg, Esq.

Assistant Attorney General Atomic Safety & Licensing Environmental Protection Div. Appeal Panel 720 Law Building U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm.

Lansing, Michigan 48913 Washington, D.C. 20555 Myron M. Cherry, Esq. Mr. C. R. Stephens One IBM Plaza Chief, Docketing & Services Suite 4501 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm.

Chicago, Illinois 60611 office of the Secretary Washington, D.C. 20555 Mr. Wendell H. Marsahll RFD 10 Ms. Mary Sinclair Midland, Michigan 48640 5711 Summerset Street Midland, Michigan 48640 Charles Bechhoefer, Esq.

Atomic Safety & Licensing William D. Paton, Esq.

! Board Panel Counsel for the'NRC Staff U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm.

Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555 Dr. Frederick P. Cowan Atomic Safety & Licensing 6152 N. Verde Trail Board Panel Apt. B-125 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm.

Boca Raton, Florida 33433 Washington, D.C. 20555 Admin. Judge Ralph S. Decker Barbara Stamiris Route No. 4, Box 190D 5795 North River Road Cambridge, Maryland 21613 Route 3 Freeland, Michigan 48623 Carroll E. Mahaney Babcock & Wilcox Jerry Harbour P.O. Box 1260 Atomic Safety & Licensing Lynchburg, Virginia 24505 Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm.

James E. Brunner, Esq. Washington, D.C. 20555 Consumers Power Company 212 West Michigan Avenue Jackson, Michlgan 49201

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20054M244&oldid=3639166"