ML20154M247
| ML20154M247 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Rancho Seco |
| Issue date: | 12/31/1985 |
| From: | Eagle R, Noshkin V, Wong K LAWRENCE LIVERMORE NATIONAL LABORATORY |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20154M246 | List: |
| References | |
| UCID-20641-PT-I, NUDOCS 8603130432 | |
| Download: ML20154M247 (43) | |
Text
-
hi. '
UCID- 20641 Part I i l
Environmental Radiological Studies i Downstream from the Ranch Seco i
! Nuclear Power Generating Station - 1985. '
l l
. V.E. Noshkin i K.M. Wong ,
{ R.J. Eagle !
J.L. Brunk l
l T. A. Jokela ,
I i
i l
i i February 6, 1986 i
i I
e6
'k.
, c ^)k 1' . , [+ < ,h , . ,-
@ k i
v q.
This is an informal report intended primarily for internal or limited enternal distribution. The opinions and conclusions stated are those of the author and ,,,5._--
, may or may not be those of the Laboratory. .
l Work performed under the auspices of the U.S. Department of Energy by the >
f Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory under Contract WJ405-Eng-48. '~9 ..
l
- 5 I
- ~;~j 1
k I
i l
i l
l 8603130432 060228 2 PDR ADOCK 050 R
1 l
l
/
e -s ,
l UCID 20641 Part I
{
ENVIRONMENTAL RADIOLOGICAL STUDIES DOWNSTREAM FROM THE RANCHO SECO NUCLEAR POWER GENERATING STATION - 1985.
V.E. Nosnkin K.M. Wong R.J. Eagle J.L. Brunk -
T. A. Jokela J
- 64 TABLE OF CONTENTS PART I I^ , l 2
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Sample Collection, Processing, and Analysis .............' .
3 4
General Comments . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 4 Aquatic Organisms Sampling and Processing . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Sediment and Soil Sampling .................. 6 Water Sampling ano Processing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 Gamma Spectrometry Analysis and Data Reduction . . . . . ... . 8 Results and Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 Aquatic Organisms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 Concentrations of Raoionuclides in Sediment and Soil Samples . 20 Concentrations of Radienuclides in Water Samples . . . . .. . . 23
'e a) Groundwater Samples ................ 23
/ b) Creek Water Samples. . . . . . . ... . . . . . . . . 23 Concentrations of Radionuclides in Parts of Water Hyacinth
~
.. 28 Concentrations of Radionuclides in Beef Samples ....... 28 Conclusions ............................. 30 Recommenoations for Future Studies ................. 32 Acknowledgment . . . . .................... 34 References . . . . . . .................... 35 e
e b_ -J
l TABLE OF CONTENTS Part II Appendix I Concentrations of Radionuclides in Fish ........ 1 Appendix 11 Concentrations of Radionuclides in Frog Legs . . . . . . 71 Appendix III Concentrations of Radionuclides in Crayfish ...... 74 Appendix IV Concentrations of Radionuclides in Sediments . . . . . . 76 Creek Sediments .......... ........ 77 Retention Basin Sediments ..... ........ 79 Appendix V Concentrations of Radionuclides in Soil Samples .... 80 Appendix VI Concentrations of Radionuclides in Water Samples ..................... 82 Concentrations of Radionuclides in Ground Water Samples ..................... 83 Concentrations of Radionuclides in Creek Water Samples 1984 and 1985 .............. 84 Concentrations of Radionuclides in Retention Basin Water Samples .................. 86 Concentrations of Radionuclides in Regenerate Holo-Up Tanks Sampled . . . . ............. 87 Appendix VII Concentrations of Radionuclides in Parts of Water Hyacinth . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 88 Appendix VIII Concentrations of Radionuclides in Beef Samples .... 90 f
L s
8 b' ABSTRACT In this report are summarized the information compiled.in 1985'while assessing the environmental impact of radionuclides previously discharged with aqueous releases from the Rancho Seco Nuclear Power Generating Plant. In October 1984, the quantities of gamma-emitting radionuclides in water discharged to Clay Creek from the plant were reduced below operationally defined detection limits for liquid effluents. However, radionuclides previously discharged persist in the downstream environment and are found in 134 137 many aquatic dietary components. Cs and Cs are the primary gamma-emitting radionuclides detected in the edible flesh of different fish, crayfish, and frogs. Concentrations of 137 Cs in fish from downstream regions began to decrease at the time the decision was made and implemented to minimize the amount of cesium radionuclides in aqueous discharges. The mean concentration of 137 Cs in the flesh of all species of fish during October 1985 was, on the average, 28% of the mean concentration measured in fish caught during October 1984 from comparable downstream locations.
Concentrations in the flesh of fish decreased with both time and distance from the plant in 1985. Ccefficients for exponential equations are generated, from a least square analysis, that relate the change in concentration of 137 Cs in fish to distance downstream and time between March and October 1985.
Concentrations of 137 Cs in surface creek sediments also decreased in the downstream direction much in the same manner as concentrations decreased in fish. However, there was no'significant difference in the radiocesium concentrations in surface sediments collected from comparable locations during both 1984 and 1985. It was expected to observe the same fractional decrease in concentration with time in both fish and creek sediment. This does not 134 appear to be the case. The concentration of Cs during the year was I37 3525% of the concentration of Cs in fish. If the concent.ations of 137 Cs continue to decline with the effective half-lives of 205 d and 85 d, determined for bluegill and bass, respectively, by the end of 1986 concentrations of I37 Cs in fish from any downstream location should be less than 1 pCi/g.
2190t 1 1/28/86 a
- A ,
INTRODUCTION The Rancho Seco Nuclear Power Generating Station, operated by the Sacramento Municipal Utility District (SMUD), is located in Sacramento County near the town of Clay, California.
Steam-generator leaks, which occurred at the plant in May 1981, November 1982, September 1983, and July 1984, contributed low-level quantities of some fission and activation products to wastewaters that were collected in holdup tanks located on-site. The type and quantity of radionuclides in the liquid waste contained in each holdup tank were determined by SMUD prior to releasing the material to on-site retention basins.
Periodically the contents, or fractions of the contents, in the basins were diluted and discharged to Clay Creek. The water in this stream flows to the site-boundary fence. 0.6 km from the point of discharge, and continues until it intersects Hadselville Creek, 3.0 km downstream from the plant.
Water from Hadselville Creek intersects Laguna Creek 6.5 km downstream from the plant. Laguna Creek water drains into the Cosumnes River at a point near Twin Cities Road between Interstate Highway 5 and State Highway 99.
A change in processing procedures at the plant in late October 1984 reduced the amounts of the principal gamma-emitting radionuclides in the liquid wastes to quantities below the operationally defined detection limits for liquid effluents at Rancho Seco (1).
In the spring of 1984, we initiated a program to obtain site-specific analytical information regartling the concentrations and fate of the gamma-emitting radionuclides discharged with liquid wastes from Rancho Seco.
A major priority, for off-site dose assessments, was to determine the levels 134 137 Cs, associated with the i of radionuclides, in particular Cs and edible parts of organisms in the aquatic food pathway to man.
As the study progressed during 1984, we were requested to expand the l program to provide radiological information that could be used by SMUD in dose estimates for the surrounding population from other pathways, including terrestrial pathways, not covered in the original program. The reason for including terrestrial pathways stemmed, in part, from the analytical results obtained from analyses in 1984 of the downstream sediments. Only 21". of the l
cesium isotopes released from Rancho Seco could be accounted for in stream sediments sampled to a distance of 27 km from the plant. Approximately l
l l 2190t 2 1/28/86 L
l i a 300 mci of 137 Cs were discharged between the months of April and September during 1981-1984; this amount represented 60% of the total 137 Cs released since aqueous discharges began in 1981. Many local ranchers use water from the creeks during the spring and summer to irrigate a variety of crops; I 134 therefore, a substantial amount of Cs and Cs released from the plant during this period of each year could have been transferred to the nearby irrigated ranchlands.
The results from the scientific studies conducted during 1984 are summarizea in reports (2,3,4,5) published in late 1984 and ea ly 1985.
We believe that during the short tenure of this program there have been some notable scientific contributions to better understand the distribution, fate, and accumulation by aquatic and terrestrial organisms of the different gamma-emitting radionuclides previously discharged with the wastewater. There still, however, remains substantial gaps in our understanding of the fate of the residual levels of radioactivity in the environment.
Releases of I34 Cs and 137 Cs (the two radionuclides contributing the major fraction of the estimated dose to individuals) and other gamma-emitting r radionuclides from Rancho Seco stopped in mid-October 1984. However, continued studies in the local environment was warranted to provide reasonable assurance to the local population, government agencies, and other interested parties that no individual in the future will receive an annual dose to the whole body from radioactivity previously discharged that exceeds the EPA guideline of 25 mrem. The creek was postec with no fishing signs in December 1984. Any future dose from the aquatic organism consumption pathway will be zero to individuals abiding with this restriction. However, this restriction cannot continue indefinitely.
There have been no adequate studies to assess contamination of food products or the biological availability of radiocesium when components in stream-bed sediments are the source of radionuclides. This is the current situation (a sedimentary source term) in the aquatic environmental downstream of Rancho Seco, providing no further releases occur from the plant. An objective of high priority in 1985 was then to determine the rate at which the 137 134 Cs and Cs concentrations change in fish and other organisms from the creek so that reasonable decisions could be made to either lift or continue fishing restrictions or to consider other remedial actions that may involve cleanup or isolation of the radioactivities previously discharged.
2190t 3 1/28/86 a
, p Additional downstream sampling stations were added in 1985 to better define relationships developed in 1984 between concentrations in fish and downstream distance. In 1985, a major effort was devoted to obtain samples of crayfish and frogs, identified as food products during the land and aquatic use survey in 1984 (2), for which there was no radiological information in 1984. In this report are presented a summary and discussion of the analytical results generated from the environmental samples collected during 1985. Some of the studies represent continuations of efforts initiated in 1984 while others developed from recommendations (5) made after an assessment of our results from the first year of effort.
SAMPLE COLLECTION, PROCESSING, AND ANALYSIS General Commentl In Table 1 are shown the types and number of samples collected for analysis during 1985. Locations of the downstream sampling stations referenced in this report are shown in Fig. 1. Detailed discussions of the collection methods, sample processing, and analysis can be found in previously published reports (3,4,5). The following are abbreviated versions of these discussions.
Aquatic Organism Sampling and Processing All personnel involved with sample collections had valid Scientific Collector's Permits for 1985. Fish collections were made using fishing gear with either bait or artificial lures. This method was adopted over other authorized fishing methods, or other methods such as chemical immobilization or electric shock, because it best mimicked the method used by local fishermen. Thus, the fish sampled would be more representative of the species normally caught from the creeks for consumption and would not be an indiscriminate collection of different species indigenous to California streams. A total of 701 fish were collected for analyses from 8 cownstream locations in 1985. Of this total, 375, 144, and 182 were, bluegill, bnss, and catfish, respectively. In addition, a selection of market samples were also analyzed for the assessment of fallout background levels in fish. The 2190t 4 1/28/86 s
l
, . o i
I
! Figure 1. Location of sampling stations.
I 2190t 5 1/28/86
_J
e- -
n tS
/ NWILLARD ELK f GilOVE ?
O gI
\ /b' .!, ,
/ a ,
a
=
1 : S'
/c #
/+
f 2 3 k 3,
5 U a es t
"'ds, wine C" n 3s or --
Q RANCHO SECO l
/. *85'1 n 23. '? .
..**..O l C3
' ,, .. r r s as tr:0
- l n a,' ' -n so.
Q ' CYI C^ -
\lg --
t# l I a es
- CLAY nne - t 2s l _ _h___533 1 n er . n 52 rs32 L _
1 Retmtion i Valensin Road J. Point of
- , Dischaiga Basins
, ,g y -
a .
=
n zo "l*l, l $7eks ~n g
Q /l n it SAMPLING STATIONS
'" j n9 Highway 104 Twin Cities Road O llERALD NORTil 2
9~'" ] 7 9 9-GALT "*""'
O k
E
. .o land and aquatic use survey (2) indicated that bluegill, bass, and catfish were the species normally. caught for consumption by the local residents. This
, fact justified the choice of the fish sampled for analysis.
Crayfish were captured in commercial traps using cat food for bait.
Frogs were speared at night from downstream locations on the creeks. We are indebted to Mr. Roy Marciel of the staff at Rancho Seco for assisting with the frog collections.
Samples were kept on ice and returned to Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL), where the organisms were frozen until processed. Standard length, sex, and fresh whole-body weight of each fish were recorded, and the fish were dissected to separate the edible flesh for analysis. The primary mode of accumulation of cesium by freshwater fishes has been shown to be via absorption from food or ingested sediments, rather than by direct uptake from water (6). Thus, samples from the gastrointestinal tract (GIT) were taken from fish caught at several locations to determine the nature of the food eaten and the radionuclides associated with the ingested material. The flesh and GIT contents from fish of the same species, collected from the same sampling site, were sometimes pooled for analysis. The judgment to analyze single or pooled samples of fish was based on anticipated concentrations at the samp'ing sites. Each sample was dried in ovens at 90*C to constant dry weight, homogenized, and transferred to aluminum or plastic container for analysis by gamma spectrometry.
Frog legs were separated from the body, skinned, and deboned to provide samples of edible flesh. The flesh from small frogs were of ten pooled for analysis. The edible portion of the crayfish was separated from several individuals and pooled for analysis.
Sampling and processing the tt.rrestrial animal and vegetation samples have been previously described (5).
Sediment and Soil Samoling The same devices used to collect sediment and soil camples in 1984 were used to obtain samples in 1985. Sediment to a depth of 12 cm was collected from the creeks using a stainless steel hand corer; the entire 12-cm section was dried, ball-milled, sieved (to remove large rocks), and analyzea as a single sample.
2190t 6 1/28/86 L- ;
a Table 1. Types of environmental samples collected and analyzed for gamma-emitting radionuclides in 1985.
No. of samples No. of subsamples Sample type collected analyzed Fish tiluegill 375 110 Bass 144 99 Catfish 182 98 Other aquatic samples Frog 88 33 Crayfish 48 9 Water hyacinth 10 20 Stream sediment 53 48 Stream water 46 92 Terrestrial samples Cow (and background sample) 5 9 Grass, pasture 2 2 Silage i i Soil 12 12.
Well water 20 20 Honey 1 1 TOTAL i 987 554 I
2190t 7 1/28/86
_a
)
. o Water Samoling and Processing Fifty-liter water samples were usually obtained at stations in conjunction with the fish collections. Water was pumped through 1-pm (pore size) cartridge filters into 15-gal polyethylene containers and was returned to LLf4L for processing. Cesium isotopes were first concentrated on ammonium molybdophosphate (AMP), the AMP was separated from the water by filtration, and the cesium was then separated from the AMP and prepared as solid samples for analysis on Ge(Li) detectors. The 1-um filters containing the particulate material were ashed at 450*C, and concantrations of radionuclides in the particulate material were determined by gama spectrometry.
Unfiltered ground water was sampled for analysis from a number of domestic fresh-water wells located in the vicinity of Rancho Seco. Fifty liter samples were obtained at each of the locations shown in Fig. 2. The samples were processed as described above for Cs and U7 Cs. Tritium measurements were made on aliquots from the same samples.
Gama-Spectrometry Analysis and Data Reduction Gama-spectrometry measurements were made on all sampics at LLiiL using a variety of Ge(Li)-diode detector systems. Counting times were usually 1000 min or longer for each sample. A general purpose computer program, called GAMAfiAL (7), was used for the data reduction of all gama-ray spectra.
In GAMAtlAL, the observed photopean in the measured spectra is compared to that in a library of photopeaks of gama-ray fission and activation products and naturally occurring radionuclides to identify the radionuclides in the sample. The program then applied correction factors for sample size, density, counting time, counting geometry, and decay to convert the measured counting rate to pCi/g of sample on the reference date sampled. All radionuclides routinely released to the waterway from the plant are included in the library. The program also generated an upoer-limit amount of specific radionuclides based on those spectra regions where signals would be seen if the radionuclide were present in detectable quantities. Our mean minimal detectable concentrations (based on a counting time of 1000 min) for each of the principal longer-lived gama-emitting radionuclides previously discharged to Clay Creek are shown in Table 2. These values are averages for the 2190t 8 1/28/86
[; . .
b f
i l
l 1
Figure 2. Location of domestic grounawater wells sampled.
2190t 9 1/28/86
WELL SAMPLING STATIONS
/
/
3 E
sto*
- ege**
.h a
[ Hadselville Creek
[ 2 7-RANCHO SECO 1
86 g% ( ,i Clay Creek
,f 7
9 9 ;~] r r
- e L
- # 11 3
- '.4 I NORTH h*
3 4 5 0 1 2_
Kilometers -
4 4
" * ~ ~ ~ .
t'.
{
Table 2. .Mean detection limits of selected gamma-emitting radionuclides
. released in liquiu effluents from Rancho Seco (pCi/ sample).a l
Radionuclide 58Co 60Co 54Mn 110 mag _ 137Cs I34Cs 125Sb 131 1 Detection limit 1 1 1 1 1 1 3 2 j
(pCi/ sample)
- Based on a counting time of 1000 min.
1 I
r l
l t
l l
i l
l l
i l
i l
i l
l l
2190t 10 1/28/86 l
l l
different sample configurations (geometries) used and are independent of sample weight. Samples prepared for analysis ranged in weight from a fraction of a gram, for dry stomach contents of fish, to over 300 g .for dry soil.
Detection limits based on a per-gram basis are therefore different for samples of different weights.
Quality cf data has always been an important aspect of our analytical measurements. As a standard practice, 5 to 10% of our time is devoted to quality-assurance work in all projects involving analytical measurements.
This quality-assurance work includes:
Analysis of background samples and blanks.
Instrument calibration.
Duplicate sampling and analysis.
National and international interlaboratory standardization.
Replicate measurements.
- Analysis and calibration traceable to National Bureau of Standards (NBS) samples.
Appropriate statistical analysis of the results.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION All individual sample results appear in a separate volume, UCID-20641 Part II (Appendices), of this report.
Acuatic Organisms Concentrations of the radionuclides measured in the muscle-tissue and stomach-content samples of the fish from the different stations sampled in 1985 are given in Appendix I. All results have been decay corrected to the date of collection. Data in the Appendix are arranged to show concentrations in the samples of fish from the downstream station sampled in chronological order. The concentrations are listed relative to fresh wet weight but the dry / wet weight ratios provided may te applied to convert concentrations to a 4 137 cry weight basis. Other than CS and Cs, no gamma-emitting radionuclides from plant discharges were above detection limits in the flesh of the fish.
Evaluation of the concentrations of 90 Sr in the flesh of fish was made after radiochemically separating strontium from a selected number of flesh samples from fish collected during 1984, 0.5 km downstream of Rancho 2190t 11 1/28/86
l Seco. The concentrations of 90 Sr (Table 3) were below detection limits in all samples processed for analysis. Concentrations of 137 Cs measured in the respective samples previously reported (3,5) are also shown in Table 3 for comparison. Tne concentrations of I37 Cs in the flesh of these fish are at
- least 3 to 4 orders of magnitude larger than that of 90 37 ,
Representative fish from the July 1985 collections at station RS-17 were dissected to provide samples of muscle tissue, bone, skin, stomach contents, viscera that includes heart, kidney and GIT (stomach lining, intestinal lining, and spleen), liver, and gonad for analysis. The percentage the organ or tissue was of the whole body fresh weight was also determined for bluegill, bass, and catfish and is given in Table 4 along with the concentrations of 134 I37 Cs measured in the tissues and organs. All previous dose Cs and estimates computed by SMUD for the aquatic food consumption pathway have been based only on the concentrations of I34Cs and 13 Cs associated with edible flesh of fish and other aquatic organisms. If this procedure is questioned or challenged, based on new or other dietary information, the data in Table 4, along with the radionuclide concentrations associated with the respective tissues, can be used to construct mean concentrations in any assemolage of fish tissue. However, it is evident from the data in Table 4 that the concentrations of I34 Cs or I37 Cs in flesh only, will exceed the level for the reconstructed whole body of these 3 species of fish.
A weighted mean concentration for both I Cs and 1
Cs in the flesh of fish during the month collected is computed using equation I from the sum of the product of the concentration (C g), number of fish in the sample (ng), ano the whole body fresh weight (wg ). This sum is divided by the sum of the product of the uhnle body fresh weight and number of fish in the respective sample.
C (pCi/g wet) = IC w n4 j g / Iw ngj (1)
Mean concentraticas of I3I Cs and I34 Cs in the flesh of bluegill, bass, and catfish collected at downstream stations during 1985 are shown in Tables 5-7. Also shown for comparison are the mean concentration of Cs and I37 CS in fish from the respective stations collected in 1984 (3,5).
Reading across these tables, left to right, shows the change in the concentration of I34 Cs and II Cs in the flesh of the respective fish with distance downstream from Rancho Seco. Reading the tables from top to bottom shows the trend for the change in concentration with time.
2190t 12 1/28/86
F
' Table 3. Concentrations'of 90 Sr and 137 Cs in the flesh of fish caught between July and October 1984. 0.5 km from the plant outfall.
Mean pCi/g wet wta Sample Common wt whole 10 name fish (g) 90S r 33ics J140 81ueg111 48 <0.04 7.6 (1)
J138 81uegill 67 <0.01 8.8 (2)
J208 Bluegill 71 <0.01 10.9 (1)
J210 Bluegill 77 <0.01 13.6 (1)
J206 Bluegill 80 <0.01 10.4 (1)
J399 Largemouth bass 121 <0.01 14.3 (2)
J393 Largemouth bass 141 <0.01 8.2 (2)
J391 Largemouth bass 203 <0.004 9.0 (1)
J389 Largemouth bass 556 <0.002 14.5 (1) a Detection limit for 90 r Sis 0.4 pC1/ sample. 137Cs values are shown for comparison.
2190t 13 1/28/86
1
. 2 Tan 13 4. Concentrations of I38 Cs and III Cs in tissues and organs of fish caught at station RS.17 on Jaly 10 1985, and the percentage the tissue or organ is of the whole body weight of the fish.
Concentrations of 13'Cs and 137CS pCl/9 wet wta Percentage of whole fish weight d Tissue or organ 81ueol11 Bass Catfish Blue 1111 Bass Catffsh 134 Cs I3I Cs I34 Cs I3I Cs I3 Cs I3 CS Muscle 1.77(2) 5.20(1) 0.82(4) 2.40(2) 0.83(3) 2.44(2) 52.0 62.0 $6.0 b 8.4 1.5 4.5 G!C 0.66('.2) 1.68(5) 1.l(16) 3.17(5) 1.47(6) 4.54(6)
Skin 0.85(6) 2.41(3) 0.46(16) 1.56(5) 0.4?(15) 1.41(5) 7.7 7.4 4.6 Viscera' O.6(14) 1.78(5) bd bd 0.60(18) 4(11) 5.4 6.1 5.9 Liver 0.8(22) 2.3(9) bd 0.6(44) bd 1.1(16) 0.4 .3 3.6 Sone 0.12(20) 0.23(13) 0.13(39) 0.18(22) bd 0.08(30) 11.0 9.3 9.4 Gonad 0.8(25) 2.5(9) bd bd bd bd 1.3 C.5 0.9 Fins NA NA NA 2.0 1.5 1.5 tres &
Brain 'NA NA NA 1.3 1.3 0.7 Gill.
' 2.3 0.9 2.5 filaments NA NA NA Heart f f f 0.7 1.0 0.7 Kidney f f f 0.9 1.2 1.2 Remains
- f f f 19 3.7 11.0 Gli f f f 3.8 3.9 4.0 a Number in parenthesis is the to counting error espressed as 1 of the value listed.
b Contents of GI tract.
C Viscera sample includes heart, kidney, and Gli (stomach lining, intestinal lining. Spleen).
d Mean 5 from the dissection of 2 fish.
- Consllts of pieces of flesh, connective tissue, skin fragments, etc.
f Components of viscera sample described above.
bd below detection.
NA no analysis because of small sample site.
14
_ - - - _ _ _ _ _ _ __ w
e a Table 5. Mean concentration of 137Cs and I34 Cs in flesh of bluegill collected from downstream locations during 1984 and 1985a, Downstream RS-17 T-1 R-5 T-2 T-3 R-8 T-4 R-11 location distance (km)b 0.5 3.0 4.6 7.5 10.2 12.6 17.2 19.5 137C s (pCi/g wet)
Date sampled 4-26-84 11.1 5-18-84 10.4 7-18-84 8.9 5.8 0.57 0.15 8-14-84 13.1 4.5 0.54 0.10 10-18-84 15.2 3.1 0.43 3-19-85 9.3 4.6 2.6 0.97 0.36 0.18 0.14 0.08 4-26-85 4.1 5.2 4.7 0.84 0.33 0.18 0.10 0.05 5-23-85 6.1 2.7 2.5 0.58 0.18 0.18 0.08 0.06 7-11-85 5.2 2.4 2.2 0.32 0.22 0.11 0.07 bd 8-30-85 2.7 2.4 1.04 0.27 0.20 0.10 0.05 bd 10-16-85 2.2 1.4 1.7 0.33 0.15 0.09 0.05 bd 134Cs(pCl/9 wet) 4-26-84 5.7 5-18-84 5.1 7-18-84 4.1 2.8 0.28 0.07 8-14-84 5.7 2.1 0.26 0.05 10-18-84 6.4 1.3 0.27 3-19-85 3.5 1.7 1.0 0.36 0.16 0.08 bd bd 4-26-85 1.5 1.8 1.8 0.33 0.13 0.07 0.04 bd 5-23-85 2. l' l.0 0.92 0.20 0.07 0.06 bd bd 7-11-85 1.8 0.87 0.73 0.16 0.07 0.05 0.03 bd 8-30-85 0.86 0.75 0.33 0.08 0.08 0.03 bd bd 10-16-85 0.76 0.44 0.56 0.09 bd bd bd bd a
1984 data from reference 4 and 5.
b Downstream distance from Rancho Seco.
bd below detection.
2190t 15 1/28/86
w 137 I34 Cs in flesh of large mouth Table 6. Mean concentration of Cs and bass collected from downstream locations during 1984 and 19858 .
Downstream RS-17 T-1 R-5 T-2 T-3 R-8 T-4 R-11
. location distance (km)b 0.5 3.0 4.6 7.5 10.2 12.6 17.2 19.5 137C s (pCl/g wet)
-. Date sampled 4-26-84 7.0 5-18-84 7-18-84 2.8 0.57 0.06 8-14-84 4.4 2.8 0.57 0.14 10-18-84 11.8 0.46 3-19-85 8.0 7.6 0.88 1.3 5.1 0.26 0.15 4-26-85 10.4 7.7 1.0 0.29 bd 5-23-85 1.8 4.5- 1.3 0.83 1.16 0.10 7-11-85 2.4 1.1 1.2 0.62 bd 0.17 0.15 bd 8-30-85 0.90 1.2 0.90 0.24 0.17- 0.11 0.10 10-16-85 1.4 0.37 0.27 0.04 bd 134Cs (pCi/9 wet) 4-26-84 3.3 5-18-84
, 7-18-84 1.3 0.25 bd 8-14-84 1.9 1.2 0.26 0.07 10-18-84 5.0 0.20 3-19-85 3.0 2.8 0.34 0.51 1.8 0.10 0.07 4-26-85 3.7 2.8 0.37 0.12 bd 5-23-85 0. 7' 1.5 0.49 0.30 0.07 0.03 7-11-85 0.8 0.36 0.36 0.23 bd bd 0.06 bd 8-30-85 0.30 0.39 0.30 bd 0.06 0.04 0.04 10-16-85 0.45 -
0.13 0.08 bd bd a
1984 data from reference 4 and 5.
b Downstream distance from Rancho Seco.
bd below detection.
2190t 16 1/28/86 J
Table 7. Mean concentration of 137 Cs and I34 Cs in flesh of catfish collected from downstream locations during 1984 and 1985a Downstream .RS-17 T-1 R-5 R-52 T-2 T-3 R-8 T-4 R-11 location distance (km)b 0.5 3.0 4.6 7.5 10.2 12.6 17.2 19.5 137C s (pCi/g wet)
Date sampled 7-18-84 0.08 10-17-84 5.1 2-7-85 11.4 3-19-85 6.3 4.5 4.9 1.6 2.0 4-26-85 6.7 5.1 4.5 2.0 5-23-85 2.6 3.8 2.6 2.0 0.38 0.32 0.04 7-10-85 2.4 1.2 2.2 0.97 0.35 0.18 4-30-85 2.1 1.5 0.44 0.20 bd 10-15-85 0.86 1.04 0.10 134Cs (pCi/g wet) 7-18-84 0.03 10-17-84 2.2 2-7-85 4.5 3-19-85 2.3 1.7 1.9 0.56 0.75 4-26-85 2.4 1.9 1.6 0.71 5-23-85 0.93 1.4 0.91 0.72 0.14 0.14 bd 7-10-85 0.83 0.41 0.77 0.34 0.11 0.07 8-30-85 0.69 0.49 0.14 0.07 bd 10-15-85 0.34 0.33 bd a
1984 data from ref. 4 and 5.
b Downstream dist1nce from Rancho Seco.
bd below detection.
4 2190t 17 1/28/86 a
O .
The mean concentration of I3 Cs in the flesh of bluegill decreased between March and October 1985 more or less uniformily with both downstream distance and time (Table 5). This trend is also seen in the results shown in Tables 6 and 7 for bass and catfish but with some anomalies that will be discussed. Levels of 134 Cs in the fish, during the year, were 35 + 5% of ,
137 the Cs concentration.
.8y October 1985, the mean concentration of I37Cs in the flesh of the three species of fish had fallen to 28% of the concentration measured in the respective fish collected from comparable stations during this period in 1984.
The values given in Table 5 were used to develop a relationship between mean bluegill flesh concentration, downstream distance, and time. This relationship is described by:
C(pC1/g wet) = 7.8 e-(0.2550 + 0.00338t) (2) where 0 is the distance in km of the station (given in Table 5) downstream from the plant and t is the time in days af ter March 19, 1985. The coefficients for 0 and t were obtained from a least-square analyses of the
, data. The concentrations of 137 Cs in the flesh of bluegill decreased during the period with an effective half life of 205 days. By the end of 1986, the calculated levels of I37 Cs in the flesh of bluegill from any location I downstream of Rancho Seco will be less than 1 pCi/g providing the concentrations continue to decrease at the present rate. Concentrations of 134 Cs in bluegill will decrease somewhat more rapidly than 137 Cs because of its shorter radiological half-life.
Changes in the mean concentration of I3I Cs insthe flesh of bass and catfish with distance and time during 1985 were not as uniform as the changes noted in bluegill (Tables 6 and 7). For example, the mean concentrations of 137 I34 Cs) in bass caught at station R-8 (12.6 km downstream) in Cs (and March 1985 and at T-2 (7.5 km downstream) in May are higher than those in fish caught at stations closer to the plant on the respective sampling dates. The higher body burdens of these fish were probably derived from more contaminated locations nearer the plant outfall. It appears that the bass, possibly in search of food, may have swam downstream shortly before being caught. This suggests that bass may be somewhat more migratory in the local creeks than I '
previously assumed (5). However, by neglecting these two data points a 4
2190t 18 1/28/86
-__ _ _ _ _ a
reasonably good exponential relationship can also be developed that relates concentrations of I37 Cs in the flesh of bass (and also in catfish) with downstream distance and time.
C(pC1/g wet bass flesh) = 11 e- (0.190 + 0.0081t)
C(pCi/g wet catfish flesh ) = 9 e- @.M0 + 0.00824 (4)
The definition and units of D and t are those described with equation 2. The values of the regression coefficient of 0.26, 0.19 and 0.19, relating the change in concentration in bluegill, bass, and catfish with downstream distance, are essentially identical to the values determined for these fish from an assessment of the results generated in 1984 (3,5).
There are certain differences between the results from last year and this I year for which reasonable interpretations cannot yet be made. In 1984 (see reference 5 or compare values in Tables 5, 6, and 7) the mean concentration of I37 Cs in the flesh of bluegill was always greater than (or at least equivalent to) the concentration in the flesh of bass and catfish collected on the same date at downstream locations. For this reason we concentrated on bluegill collections in 1985 because these earlier findings confirmed the usefulness of bluegill as indicators of maximum flesh concentrations (8) among edible fish collected from the creeks. This year, most notably in the spring and early summer, the mean concentrations of I3I Cs in the flesh of bass and catfish (compare data in Tables 5, 6, and 7) were greater than the levels in bluegill at many of the downstream stations sampled. Examination of the gut contents revealed there was no obvious differences in the monthly diets between the two year collections. The trend developed from the 1984 data was not repeated in 1985, and we presently lack an explanation for this change.
In Appendix II and III are presented measured concentrations of I37 Cs and I34 Cs in edible frog legs and flesh of crayfish collected from downstream locations during 1985. No other gamma-emitting radionuclide associated with the releases from Rancho Seco was detected in the edible flesh of these organisms. From the data presented in Table 8, comparisons can be made of the concentration of I37 Cs in the flesh of frogs and crayfish to that in bluegill flesh from the stations sampled durin different periods of 1985. With very few exceptions, the concentration of 37 Cs in bluegill flesn was either equivalent to or greater than the concentration in flesh of 2190t 19 1/28/86
frogs or crayfish from the respective station. In the absence of downstream site specific data for concentrations in frogs or crayfish, the levels in bluegill may be substituted with some certainty to estimate conservative i values for mean concentrations during 1985 in these organisms from any downstream location.
Concentrations of Radionuclides in Sediment and Soil Samoles Concentrations of radionuclides determined in creek sediment and in selected soil sampled during 1985 are given in Appendices IV and V. From the l data presented in Figure 3, a comparison can be made of the concentrations for I37 Cs measured in the 0-12 cm surface sediment sections collected in 1984 and 1985 from different downstream regions of Clay Hadselville, and Laguna creeks. Concentrations associated with the bed sediments decrease more or less uniformly with increasing distance downstream of Rancho Seco, and there is no obvious difference in the downstream distribution observed over the 2 y. There has been no substantial net addition or loss of I37 Cs in the sediments from any downstream region over the two-year period. The change in concentration is best expressed by equation 5 where D is the distance in km i downstream of Rancho Seco.
I37Cs (pC1/g 0-12 cm) = 22 e-0.280 (5)
There was also little change in the concentrations of the longer lived radionuclides measured in the retention basin sediments that were collected in August 1984 (see reference 4) and July 1985. However, the concentration ratto of 58 Co/60Co, for example, in sediments collected in July 1985 did not relate to the quantities measured in 1984. The mean 1985 ratio of 58Co/60C0 in the sediments was 0.022 while the measured value in August 1984 was 0.056. The half life of 6 Co is 70.8 d and 11 months elapsed between the two collections of sediment. Between August 1984 and July 1985, the rati3 should have decreased from 0.056 to 0.003 by radioactive decay.
Hence, there must have been some additional source of Co to the basin sediments to account for a concentration ratio ten times the expected value.
2190t 20 1/28/86
1 O
- Table 8. Comparison of the mean concentrations of I37 Cs in flesh of bluegill, frogs, and crayfish collected from downstream locations in 1985a, 137C s (pCi/g wet) ate Station Downstream Bluegill Frogs Grayfisn sampled ID distance (km) 3/19-21/85 RS-30b 0.5 5.4 4.9 R-5 4.6 2.6 2.5 T-2 7.5 0.97 0.64 bo 4/24-26/85 R-5 4.6 4.7 3.5 T-2 7.5 0.84 0.73 R-8 12.6 0.18 0.09 5/22-23/85 RS-17 0.5 6.1 1.5 R-5 4.6 2.5 3.1 1.8 R-8 12.6 0.18 bd 7/10/85 RS-17 0.5 5.2 0.71 R-5 4.6 2.6 3.1 R-8 12.6 0.11 0.09 8/28-30/85 RS-17 0.5 2.7 2.6 3.1 R-5 4.6 1.04 1.08 0.8 T-2 7.5 0.27 0.16 bd R-8 12.6 0.10 bd a
Mean values computed from equation 1.
bd below detection.
2190t 21 1/28/86
- _ _ - _ _ _ _ - _ _ - - _ _ -__ _a
I ,
l l
e i
f I
I Figure 3. Concentrations of I37 Cs in creek surface sediments collected in
! 1984 and 1985.
L 2190t 22 1/28/86 l
..--_-__--_-_-_______---_-__--_______-___--________-___________--___-__--__----_______-__-A
e e Xl I I I I I I I I I I I o
XX o X XO X X XX xx X x X X*X x 10.0 a -
o x g x
K
- oa ao X
5 E *
- b8 = 22e-0.28D (D = km downstroom) 8 x X - 1984 data o - 1985 dam h X*
- I XX X X
!!' o g1.0 -
X -
a h X 0 8
X x
X o X x
6 X
X X x
o X 0.1
! ' ' ' ' ' ' I I ' '
N O 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 (km)
Distance downsteam from Rancho Seco
_.o
, s.
' Soils were collected at locations near irrigation pumps or fishing sites used by local ranchers. It is reconsnended that the measured concentrations be used with appropriate usage factors (time spent in the region) to compute the i
radiological dose to individuals from shore-line exposure at the downstream locations sampled.
L Concentrations of Radionuclides in Different Water Samples i
l.
l Appendix VI contains tables of concentrations for different radionuclides measured in various samples of water collected during 1984 and 1985.
- a. Groundwater Samples Several local ranchers requested that SMUD assess the concentrations of any man-made radionuclides in domestic groundwater samples. We fulfilled I these requests by analyzing 15 gal of unfiltered water from the well locations f shown in Fig. 2 and described in Appendix VI. Cesium radionuclides and 3H l
were below our detection limits in all the samples that we analyzed. It appears that no measureable radionuclides discharged by Rancho Seco have migrated to the local groundwater reservoirs.
- b. Creek Water Samples Concentrations of I3#Cs and I37 Cs in filtered creek water samples and in the separated particulate material from downstream locations are shown in Appendix VI. During February 1985, the amount of particulate material was measured in the water both before and after a heavy rain. These measurements were made tc assess the magnitude of the distribution coefficient (K d
) for' Cs.
The quantities of filtered particles in the water and computed Xd values are shown in Table 9. Note that the amount of filtered particles (along with 134 I37 Cs) moving with the water during the heavy rain, associated Cs and increased at all downstream locations by 1 to 2 orders of magnitude above the l ambient amounts measured prior to the rainstorm. Transport of contaminated '
sediment downstream, especially in the rainy season, may increase the chance of
[
L exposing fish to higner concentrations of I37 Cs at the more remote downstream l locations.
l l
l 2190t 23 1/28/86
b
' Table 9. Amount of suspended particles in water sampled and dK values for I37 Cs.
I37
-Station Suspended particles Cs K d ID- Data sampled concentration g dry /l values 4
RS-17 ~ 4-26-84 0.0052 3.7 x 10 RS-17 2-7-85 0.0084 6.0 x 10" RS-17 b
2-8-85 0.138 4.3 x 10 4 R-5 2-7-85 0.0062 9.4 x 104 D 4 R-5 2-8-85 0.404 5.1 x 10 R-8 2-715 8 0.0029 '
10.6 x 10 4 R-8 D
2-8-85 0.223 1.6 x 10 4 R-ll 2-7-85 0.0087 17.8 x 10 4 4
mean 7.3 2 5.1 x 10 Kd = pCi/L prefilter x 1000 pGi/L water x g/L particles
- Respective values for pCi/L prefilter and pCi/L water for 137C s shown in Appendix VI.
b; Samples collected after a heavy rain.
. i 2190t 24 1/28/86
_a
I I37
' Table 10. Median value for concentration factors (CF) for Cs in bluegill, bass, and catfish and stable potassium concentration in creek water.
Clay Creek Hadselville Creek t.aguna Creek Number Median CF Number Median CF Number. Median CF Bluegill 10 11.4 x 10 3 10 3.0 x 10 3 17 1.3 x 10 3
. Bass 10 5.7 x 10 3 5 2.5 x 10 3 17 2.7 x 10 3 Catfish 5 11.2 x 10 3 6 5.3 x 10 3 6 1.1 x 10 3 Potassium" 1 0.9 1 1.1 2 6.7 (ppm) a Potassium measured on October 10, 1985.
l i
l l
l l
2190t 25 1/28/86 l-.
During February 1985, the computed K d values were not constant but were variable and increased in value with downstream distance. This could be r caused by one of many complex factors that govern the uptake of radionuclides by. suspended material including differences in water quality that may exist between Clay, Hadselville, and Laguna Creeks. This latter possibility will be discussed in more detail in a subsequent section.
137 All downstream concentrations of Cs, both in solution and associated with particles, were greater tnan the global fallout background levels (0.008-0.012 pCi/L) measured in the Mokelumne River and Rancho Seco Lake. The concentrations of I37 Cs measured in solution during the periods sampled in 1985 (during periods of no reported releases) generally increased between the plant outfall and station R-5 (4.8 km downstream) and then decreased exponentially to near fallout background concentrations at station R-il, which is 19.5 km from the plant. The mean concentration of 134Cs was 3623% of the 137 Cs concentration. Still unexplained is the difference consistently 134 I37 Cs activity ratios in found in 1984 (5) and 1985 between the Cs/
filtered water and in the particulate material. The activity ratio of the cesium isotopes in solution has been consistently less than the ratio of the isotopes associated with the material filtered from water at all stations downstream of the plant.
We performed a regression analysis to show that during 1985 the change in the concentration of soluble 137 Cs with distance (km) downstream of station R-5 is best represented with a mean regression coefficient of -0.1320.02.
Concentrations in the water at some stations also appeared to be decreasing with time during 1985. Not evident in the sediment results, discussed in the preceeding section, the water concentration data show there must be some net loss of 137 Cs from upstream sediment with subsequent adsorption onto material at downstream locations. No difference would be observed in the concentration of dissolved 137 Cs with distance downstream if there were no interactions between dissolved 137 Cs and sedimentary material. Because discharges of radioactivity stopped in the fall of 1984, it was unexpected to find 137 Cs in solution everywhere downstream, our first assumption was that the quantities measured represented the amounts mobilized or leached from the bottom sediments of the creek. However, we were unable to account for all of 137 the Cs moving past station RS-17 (0.5 km downstream from Rancho Seco) by remobilization alone. The mean concentration of 137 Cs moving past station 2190t 26 1/28/86 J
r RS-17 between October 1984 and October 1985 was 0.66 pCi/L in solution and 0.48 pCi/L with particles. Flow rates measured at RS-17 were in agreement with the rates measured at the station outfall. Monthly flow rates were 137 available from SMUD. It is estimated that from 8-13 mci of Cs flowed past station RS-17 between October 1984 and October 1985 from the concentration and flow rate data. However, this amount of 137 Cs is slightly greater than the total inventory measured in the sediments (including the on-site retention basin sediment) upstream of RS-17. The total upstream -
inventory was not mobilized during the year. Recall from the previous section that the amount of 137 Cs in the retention basin sedime'nts measured in 1985 was equivalent to the amount measured in 1984. Therefore, possibly another non-sedimentary source was contributing to the radioactivity moving past RS-17 during 1985.
137 The last 2 tables in Appendix VI show concentrations of CS and other radionuclides in wate[ samples collected in October 1985 from the on-site retention basins'and regenerate hold-up tanks. Levels of I37 Cs were below the SMUD operational detection limits that are required to comply with USflRC regulations. There may have been small levels of I37 Cs (and other radionuclides) in the retention basin water (below the SMUD detection limit) released to Clay Creek over the year that contributed to the inventory estimated passing station RS-17.
One other purpose for the continuous collection of water samples is to strengthen our data base on concentration factors for I Cs in the species of fish from the creek. Last year it was determined that the concentration I37 Cs in the flesh of fish caught nearest the plant were larger factors for than the concentration factors measured further downstream (5). The concentration factor is the ratio of radionuclide concentration in the organism or tissue to that in the water. Concentration factors were computed I7 CS in fish muscle given in Tables 5, 6, frem the mean concentrations of and 7 and the appropriate filtered water concentration measured in 1985 at the stations shown in Appendix VI. Median concentration factors were computed for 137 Cs for fish from Clay, Hadselville, and Laguna Creek. There are clearly significant differences in the median value of the concentration factor, especially between Clay and Laguna Creeks.
- Vanderploeg{et.al.(6)had3{influence previously reported that the concentration factor for 13 the stable potassium in water, that highest values were found in lake waters having a potassium concentration of 1 ppm or less, and that concentration 2190t 27 1/28/86 j J
E ,
factors decreased with increasing levels of potassium. During October 1985,
' water samples were collected for the analysis of stable potassium. The levels of potassium in Clay and Hadselville Creeks, shown in Table 10, are signfficantly lower than the mean concentration in Laguna Creek. These results were unexpected but clearly show that the levels of potassium in the water from the creeks are variable and may change during different growing seasons of_the year. This could result from natural causes or changes in water quality caused by runoff from downstream fields where high potassium fertilizers were applied. Whatever the reason, it is possible that variations in the potassium content of the water may be one reason for the differences in the concentration factors for I Cs.
Concentrations of Radionuclides in parts of Water Hyacinth Collections of water hyacinth (Eichhornia crassipies) were initiated in 1985 to evaluate the usefulness of the plant as an indicator species for future monitoring of the waterway. Concentrations of the radionuclides detected by gamma spectrometry in the roots and stem-leaf sections of the plants collected from different downstream stations are shown in Appendix VII. The-data indicate that these plants may obtain a significant fraction of the measured radionuclides by root uptake from interstitial water of bottom sediments. There are no clear trends noted for the changes in concentrations with distance or time. In August, for example, the concentration of I37 Cs was highest in the leaf-stem sample from station R-5, 4.6 km downstream, but in October the highest concentration in the plant leaf was from station T-3, I37Cs in the plant do not appear to 10.2 km downstream. The levels of follow the changes in concentration measured in both fish and sediment.
Although the plant accumulates most radionuclides found in past releases from Rancho Seco, its general usefulness as a reliable indicator species has yet to be adequately demonstrated.
Concentration of Radionuclide in Beef Samples During the year, requests were made (1) to evaluate the levels of Cs and I37 Cs in the flesh of beef cattle from a ranch downstream of Ranch Seco. In Appendix VIII are listed the concentrations measured in samples of beef obtained from slaughtered ranch animals and from local markets.
2190t 28 1/28/86 a
. o In March 1985, two cows were slaughtered for analy' sis. The cows had grazed on pasture grass irrigated with water from Clay Creek but were removed to a feed lot several months prior to slaughter. The concentrations of 137 Cs in the flesh were no greater than the fallout background levels in the 134 market samples. Any Cs and 137 Cs accumulated by the cows while feeding in the pasture was eliminated with a biological half life of about 30 d during the months at the feed lot.
In June 1985,.two additional cows, which were taken directly from a downstream pasture, were slaughtered for analysis. The concentrations of 134 137 Cs and Cs in samples from the hindquarter of each cow are shown in Appendix VIII. The mean concentration of 137 Cs in the flesh was not significantly different from the average value of 0.066 pCi/g measured in sirloin and hamburger samples from a cow sampled from, the grazing area on November 1, 1984 (5). Based on an annual consumption rate of 95 kg/y for beef and a mean concentration of 63 pCi/kg, we calculated the average daily intake 137 rate of Cs from consumption of meat from these grazing cows would be 16 pCi/d. This intake rate of 137 Cs is within the range of 137 Cs daily intake from a survey of California diets in 1971,1972, and 1973 conducted by the Radiological Health Section, California State Department of Health (9).
It is stated in this report "that levels of radioactivity were observed to be far below those levels for which consideration should be given to protective health action."
2190t 29 1/28/86 m
CONCLUSIONS I 137 Since mid-October 1984, the levels of Cs and Cs (the two radionuclides contributing the major fraction of the estimated dose to individuals in 1983 and 1984) and other gamma-emitting radionuclidet in water discharged to Clay Creek from Rancho Seco have been reduced belov detectable quantities (1). However, results from our sampling program in 1985 indicate that radionuclides previously released persist in the downstream environment and are present in many of the aquatic dietary components. As with the results generated in 1984 (3,5), 134Cs and I37Cs were the primary gamma-emitting radionuclides detected in the edible flesh of different fish, crayfish, and frog legs sampled for analysis in 1985. Nu O Sr was detected in the flesh of fish caught downstream of Rancho Seco. Concentrations of 137 Cs in' fish from downstream regions began to decrease at the time the decision was made and implemented to minimize the amount of cesium radionuclides in aqueous discharges. The mean concentration of I37Cs in bluegill, for example, caught 0.5 km from the plant was 15.2 pCi/g in October 1984 arid 9.3 pCi/g in March 1985. The mean concentration of I37 Cs in the flesh of all fish during October 1985 was, on the average, 28% of the concentration measured in fish during October 1984 from comparable downstream I37Cs in locations. No such decrease was evident in the concentration of the surface sediments collected from comparable locations during 1984 and 1985. Because the sediments are now the principal source of radioactivity, it is presently difficult to explain these conflicting results. One might have expected to observe the same fractional decrease in concentration with time in botn fish and sediment. This does not appear to be the case.
Concentrations in the flesh of fish decreased with both time and distance from the plant outfall in 1985. These changes in concentrations were described by exponential equations, the coefficients of which were obtained from the least square analysis of the data obtained between March and October 134 1985. The concentration of Cs during this period was 35:5% of the concentration of 137 Cs in fish from any downstream location. During this period the effective biological half-life (the time for the measured concentration to be reduced to one-half its original value) of I37 Cs was 205 d in bluegill and 85 d in bass and catfish. If the concentrations in fish continue to decline at these rates, concentrations of 137 Cs in all species will be less than 1 pCi/g by the end of 1986. Changes in the concentration 2190t 30 1/28/86 i
of I37 Cs in crayfish and frogs closely follow the changes in concentration
, measured in the flesh of bluegill.
Stable potassium levels in the water sampled from different downstream creeks are not the same. Levels are lowest in the water of Clay Creek and highest in Laguna Creek. This could result from natural causes or from changes in water quality caused by runoff from downstream fields where high potassium fertilizers were applied. The values computed for the 137 Cs concentration factors are highest for fish from Clay Creek and lowest for fish from Laguna Creek. This trend was also evioent in the 1984 data (5). The stable potassium level in the water may play a role in regulating both the 137 Cs concentration factor for the different species of magnitude of the fish found in the creeks and Kd values between the particles ano the creak water. Concentrations of dis' solved 137Cs were measurable in all water samples collected from downstream locations in 1985. Some of the levels result from mobilization of radiocesium at the sediment-water interface.
However, there may have been small amounts of I37Cs and other radionuclides released to the creek from the retention basins during the year; this would explain the levels measured in the downstream water samples.
137Cs, I34Cs, and3 H were below detection limits in all downstream domestic groundwater samples collected in 1985. No activity was found in samples of honey from hives 0.5 km from the plant, and the levels of I37 Cs in the flesh samples of cattle taken directly from pasture in 1985 were comparable to the levels detected in the flesh of beef collected in 1984 (5).
Y 2190t 31 1/28/86
~
o o RECOMMENDATIONS FOR FUTURE STUDIES This was the second year of study of the aquatic and terrestrial environment downstream of Rancho Seco Nuclear Power Generating Station. Based on our studies conducted during 1984, a number of recommendations for future studies in 1985 were developed and described (5). Many of these studies have been accomplished and the results presented in this report. We are now recommending a further scientific study through the end of 1986 to better understand the distribution and fate of radionuclides in the ecosystem to insure that no major environmental factors related to the radionuclides previously discharged in aqueous releases from Rancho Seco are overlooked.
Because the releases of 137 Cs and I34 Cs to the aquatic environment were significantly reduced in October 1984, the levels of radionuclides in the edible aquatic organisms from all downstream areas have generally decreased well below the levels observed in 1984. Between the spring and fall of 1985, 137 the levels of Cs decreased in bluegill with an effective biological half-life of 205 d. Concentrations in bass and catfish decreased with an effective biological half-life of 85 d. However, there was no difference in 137 Cs in downstream surface sediments from comparable the concentration of locations sampled in 1984 and 1985. One might have expecteo the same decrease in concentration with time in both fish and sediment. This does not appear to be the case. Because the sediments now appear to be the principal source of radioactivity, further study will be required to explain these conflicting results.
If the concentrations of I7 Cs continue to decline in fishes at the above rates, by the end of 1986 the levels of 137 Cs in the flesh of fish from any location downstream of Rancho Seco will be less than 1 pCi/g. At these low concentrations, serious consideration should then be given to lifting all fishing restrictions on the creeks.
Before the models describing the change in fish concentrations with time can be used with confidence, they should be validated during 1986 with additional field data. The lack of corresponding changes in sediment concentrations over the year is cause for concern. Originally it appeared, from the 1984 data, that sediment and fish concentrations decreased in a 2190t 32 1/28/86 a
similar manner with downstream' distance from the station. The observed
. behavior may be attributed to the cesium associated with the creek sediments becoming more firmly fixed and less biological available with time. Changes brought about in the major chemical composition of the discharged water and/or alterations in downstream agricultural practices may influence the chemical-biochemical behavior of cesium radionuclides. We find some evidence for this effect in the variations of Cs concentration factors and K d values. An assessment of the biological availability of radiocesium associated with bottom sediments and the factors affecting the availability should be key elements for study in the 1986 aquatic program.
2190t 33 1/28/86
r-ACKNOWLEDGMENT We wish to thank Mr. Jack Dawson and Mr. Gary Floyd for assisting in the sample collection and processing phases of this program. This work was performed under the auspices of the U.S Department of Energy by the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory under contract number W-7405-ENG-48, with support from the Sacramento Municipal Utility District under contract A087.
.2190t 34 1/28/86 a
r- 1
.- o REFERENCES 1). E.W. Bradley, Sacramento Municipal Utility District, Sacramento, CA.,
privatecommunication(1985).
2). R.J. Eagle, K.M. Wong, and V.E. Noshkin, Ranch Seco Liquid Effluent Pathway--Aquatic and Terrestrial Dietary Survey Report, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore,_CA, UCID-20267 (1984).
3). V.E. Noshkin, R.J. Eagle, J.M. Dawson, J.L. Brunk, and K.M. Wong, Concentration of Radionuclides in Fresh Water Fish Downstream of Rancho Seco Nuclear Power Generating Plant, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory,CA,UCID-20295(1984).
i 4). K.M. Wong, R.J. Eagle, J.M. Dawson, J.L. Brunk, and V.E. Noshkin, Radionuclides in Sediments Collecteo Downstream from the Rancho Seco Nuclear Power Generating Station Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore, CA, UCID-20298 (1985).
S.) V.E. Noshkin, K.M. Wong, R.J. Eagle, J.W. Dawson, J.L. Brunk, T.A.
Jokela, Environmental Radiological Studies Downstream from Rancho Seco Nuclear Power Generating Station, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore,CA,UCID-20367(1985).
6.) H.A. Vanderploeg, D.C.Parzyak, W.H. Wilcox, J.R. Kercher, and S.V. Kaye, Bioaccumulation Factors for Radionuclides in Freshwater Biota, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, TN, ORNL-5002 (1975).
7.) R. Gunnik and J.B. Niday, Computer Quantitative Analysis by Gamma-Ray Spectrometry, Vol. 1 Description of the General Program, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore, CA, UCRL-51061 (1972).
8.) R.S. Harvey, " Uptake of Radionuclides by Fresh Water Algae and Fish,"
Health Phys. 10, 243-247 (1964).
9.) Radiation Data Reports, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Radiation Programs, R00RA 4, 15 (2) (1974).
2190t 35 1/28/86
! e '*
DISCLAl%1ER This document was prepared as an account of work sponsored by an agency of the United Sesees Go.ernment.
Neither the United States Government not the University of California not any of their employees. makes any marranty. espress or implied, or amounces any legal liability or responubility for the accuracy, com-pieneness. or usefulness of any information, apparatus. product or process disclowd, or reprewnes that its use would not infringe pritstely owned rights. Reference herein to any specific commercial products, preceu, or service by trade name, trademark, manufacturer or otherwise. does not necessarily toastitute or imply its endorsement, recommenJetion, or faioring by the United States Gooernment or the Univerway of California.
The views and opensons of authors espreued herein do not necewarily state or reflect those of the United States Goserament thereof, and shall not be used for advertising or product endorsement purposes.
rn.wd . ene t. ed seaw.e# 4merwe needebee from
%esee.e4 rechews4 $seetmet.ee netowe U S. Derseemene of commeece s:ss two a...a no 4 src er.est ts :216:
r,we- rn.we coe s 4 u.c m. sa se Domestic Domestic Page Rante Price Pate Rance Price 001 025 5 7.00 326-150 5 26.50 026-050 S.50 351 175 25.00 051 075 10.00 376-400 29.50 076-100 !!.50 401 426 31.00 101 125 13.00 427-450 32.50 126-150 14.30 451 475 34.00 151 175 16.00 476 500 35.50 176-200 ' 17.50 501 325 37.00 201 225 , 19.00 $26 550 38.50 226 250 20.50 551-575 40.00 231 275 22.00 576-600 41.50 276 300 23.50 601 up' 301 325 25.00
' Add 1.30 for each additional 25 page increment, or portion thereof from 601 pa6es up.
I