ML19329D333

Notifies That 710220 Filing by Applicant Fully Answered Living in Finer Environ Challenge to 10CFR20.No Addl Reply Will Be Filed

ML19329D333
Person / Time
Site:	Davis Besse
Issue date:	03/02/1971
From:	Charnoff G SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE
To:	Jordan W, Skallerup W, Winters C AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED, Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel, OAK RIDGE NATIONAL LABORATORY
References
NUDOCS 8003050904
Download: ML19329D333 (2)

Text

, .

.. - .- .- c- , a~. + a.- 3+m{

yT. .- .

.}c . >- g .n n p ..y .

y -

/ . -

m3 ,};p .f.g.;Gyf. ;.n.gn.M q% pQ

. l -, . ,

2: -

N. '

~N N NC8 ^ h %.h SHAW, PITTMAN, PoTTS,TRoWBRIDGE & MADDEN [, ,_

.....m,~.

. C . L. , . . .

... m ,. . ,. .. .. - . C.. m ., _ . w-WAS HIN GTO N, D. C. 2 000 6 ' TE L.x: .4o s.,

N.".va n't . 77 .=

a

........,1,.

e -

~: .y ,3

..m.LO C M.RNOF, .

puitu ,o..o.rwica

p. ft pe.,MT M.N LOM N

//

' '_ ?

4 C.W..NC MU8.T.R \ q.,

J. .a,meCm Mac..Y '

.. e . s a.* 0, .

.muC. W. CMURCMcLL 4..Lt. .. DelCMOL.O.d. J R. r March 2, 1971 h.

1. 49 -

i+

N.mTIN D. ER.LL " ' .

' ' , c-

+w

.. C . . . s. . . .. u.

A

- ~

' 6

s. ....L....

A.f'g- .

r . ..

..anyu.swo ,

.~

p.0,. .td .T.L.aRNO

• s'f y , jr, . _. o Walter T. Skallerup, Jr., Esq. Dr. Walter H. Jordan .

l y; 1

~

Chairman -

Oak Ridge National ,

. A ' %,12.q4 )-

Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Laboratory J.

, 1155 Crest Lane P. O. Box X V W.G l

McLean, Virginia 22101 Dr. Charles E. Winters

, Oak Ridge, Tenness e 37830

.]f.

v.-

M., .., " g r ,.

8800 Fernwood Road -

. ". R Bethesda, Maryland 20034

} . #*.as87

• > }.b;.; f ,

y2 l-In the Matter of The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, ec[j .pyh j

Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station t. ivc4 QQQ m '

Docket No. 50-346 -,

V l

• O. w . @m w..; g Gentlemen: -

s

"~ ' '

'S h

- n' d m N ?.r m

~

~

1. 1 -

.Q,g l*y's t.t l_- .

4 The Applicant has received and reviewed the Brief: ~ # ~;6 Regarding Challenge to 10 CFR Part 20 and Proposed Findings , , ; ,$% .,

i of Fact and Conclusions of Law filed in the captioned pro-  ? #. T ceeding by.Living In A Finer Environment and William E. .

'. $ ~ .~ .E#

Re'ny a (hereinafter collectively called LIFE). <

. 3. f ;3.". p . ,94&.,

'b qQ:.g On February 20, 1971,. the Applicant filed Proposed inQ.W Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law. That filing included' N findings and conclusions relating to LIFU s challenge to the LhM validity of 10 CFR Part 20. Those findings and conclusions 3.{yf.

fully consider.the matter presented by LIFE in its brief and M:

in its Proposed Findings.of Fact and Conclusions e,f Law. Sb:.m Accordingly, the Applicant will not file any additional reply A%

!^ to LIFE's brief and proposed findings relating to its challen6e /-Ch '

1 . to 10 CFR Part 20.. _. A!:ci.:

, ,. m  : .~

c .,

S cerely WM A, q- '

n.sm

,.;c N Q:'1

~

Qe  ;,- ~.'. Ad. >

j . J.

GC/ mis -

~-

t. .

. h. , Gerald Charnoff / ~ ,.:. Qp $Ph@

'% Courrsel for The Toledo EdisonMgM

, , [ [ 'J.j .

.k. ,. .

p .. Company.

. ,,gg

. / -n

~

. , s.

.~.7 7

"~ , C.

~ ;;,.

p:

.;'.~, .~ , ',. ;*.' , . f .*L':QT W

~ ~ ~ L y z fgg;.

,  ;:.. .i _ ,,

w ,s ~ .

. _. .~

_. , c b  :.'r _ _. l.,. ,J .; . ,@;& 0._0 $.0

..%. il.1.#si $ , .f,n

. 1._.M, .a'<' ,. .%

• ~ '

.. ,. .s m

~. r"; m; l %% %. ,

• g W '%s . . . ' ; C ;~ " .~.. . . , :. T . A hr 'S i em*H ,:e; ewer ~ ;Sl *<Wv+% ,.tyf'e.4 -'sf W' V' .n l

[ tz . . ,, _

. , ,2 , , , -

.& v i

mMmW:2:w_

^ _ . ,  :. .. , > . . - -

"a *

. .; -z, m.-. - n  ;;. g.-

t; , 3 .

~1 ., 9 q d x :::.> ..

y  ;..o -..,y. xn.f,.<,Gy,. c.+km.ou ye c n.

n...n . .

. , .v x. . c

, .c. c . .. ,.. . s .w. .

.. 5 y

,.; - .

,; .. hjY, f ., .7 b; lk Walter T. Skallerup, Jr.,'Esq. -

~

s r %" g4>.

m Dr. Walter.H. Jordan :A Dr. Charles E. Winters

". @4

., March 2, 1971 '

't Page Two

. s W~ .,A. .

.: < A~ ,v. -

.i . -

-4 ym m: .escn ,sx.tM, s A,.

.. l

, Jr. ,..'N.

e?w%n'6  %

Mr. Thomas F. Engelhardt

' 'u '.'

' J; s M. ,

Mr. Roger B. Williams '

'3 i E. W. Arnold, M. D. ' MMNa

! Mr. Harry R. Johnson-

.j.%%

Russell Z. Baron, Esq. o ry, SfM Beatrice K. Bleicher~ '

3.4?R~s n

.'". NNs Mr. Glenn H. Lau

. ,W g

g in:.e

.[M s .'t.= *d. b..,V g".

s . . . v; * '

+

. - . (r , i y'-- * .j C .* M. "l> - V+ .,,

, , . , - . , _ e .

-g.. is fg4 g.

.r., .

. ' , . .~ . W:

+ .% n.

.- v..*w., n w~ ~ .+. . ,

.< f 1 ' W s i. - W. 9.p'g ,w ejm-

- . w.

a, W

- j,< 4 s

5

~

- , ,4 t,-

' ,p"ae,flf{~$Q/;

} ~

y ~. 2 y . ,-

e g.

,t ;

n 3.. , _ ,

~.; .

.; ... ..yy .c r -

. 3. r .sm.s a.syyrg,.

p > -

.-est,s:,_. .r g:%.. i c

.e Css 7 b i' c.,,,

n -= ' ' ,i_ r}..

s 1

6 ,

9  %

-3 d.s/gW.1.%

3

• .w. = -

- o t

. "'.,yH%*- [4, f> 5.e,

,4

-w ,

>* f*

s. . i

• fG n -

, .n,.4

~

ww

= 3'tcM., w

, , e .:.%. .m.P*'

, ' ~

• l,

. ;&g:

s

,e n

. . .~,' - ~ > . 4, * ., - '

, . , p 0, .

.t-,

• ,,: m f.w;$**' - ..

_- +, * > $. d -

• 4, 4 *'

Q *( /* g; N&^

,y.

J '#

n.',-J.4g v ,

- ~.

,. . w e

.A  %

. .,, g: . .-~ .. .

h ~ ' '

(*.

~

' .< w ;' [*J~ f}-

L <:y'm.,'; t,Y

, s -

• • + g

.. .4 y*y s

[-

$-. .ss' . *

n.  %. ,

,,,\ j g_ . - #, ,

E.

q* n 4 e ,

.[-. *7 y

P' " h .*

s ,

=

(t ,; %

'y

• b f; -),i Ay 4

.s. ,r. ~ % t ' I

,e e,

[9 z. 5W'4 n <w.

d

-s*

. .' , < ' ,p~ t ' '

t -

s .,,

. . - ;

. , a,s% 5 y F-

'.,,~-?* ., ,

t

> + , , , ~ + -

,-4'.

• s , .  ; 6% *

, . ..- ..: n , l*j'

,4 ' '

.-

_ . - w : f.. f -

f.. s

,+

.m

. . , '~

.;i G.-

q f ~y. ~.,;f.g.;J; , , \

f_.

~ ~ 1

, . y' ' %

^

,;.'; . ; 7,N , ,

,.~ m .e -..Q 3Q.f 4 .'  ; r,; , "

. -, 4.. -

. ', ;. ; -s.

Q.}: ;,

ep3 )

b' ...' . , . *,

,4 . /".  % .

, M. P . - .

y

. , . . [-

., ,e . 3 ,e.m M

.,.v. ,

.,j ^ . '

• u At' (p*$(

, ., X ,,(, .. i , -

j

% 3 e . , - 1 . . Es E' . - * ;- '

q

• l ,

t

1. #, _ :n.p N .;st.a n.2 a t . ,,, x

.s

<- + .

,c/

y -

- , .. x m w

,a .

._. f. . mg AweAna 2 a;.

• a. * , ,, ,

<  ;..

, . * , n.n. =. +, ,3 , , .s; . .. W =. v g.w.,

<p .,A ~s .ay. .gy a .

?Qf ,f. . < ,4 s.=. wea,v'...yc : . e, 4 i 7.. .n

. , < .; . ., r; %' , 1.,y. M,. '

, ./ ,. gimf.- . . .+. a e g-W p a; i ,3 3; "

, , p.% 4 *>- ,1.,.~f g ,.,..._as.: +8.

s

.[2 . ' * .' . ,, -[ N -

, . y g. .,; .

.e- , u$

J{ - .,y h'-#,,5 '[* ' o,,]{ . . hbb>h 7 h.'1 "'

6

• . J . " 4 ' t{ G'p *{[j';' l ww 5

. aa , _ =. n . , m .w - - .- - - - -~ -=, -