Text

Partially Withheld Memo Forwarding List of Alleger Feedback Action Items for Review.Schedule for Closeout Should Be Submitted by 850412
	ML20199G343
Person / Time
Site:	Comanche Peak, 05000000
Issue date:	04/03/1985
From:	Noonan V; NRC - COMANCHE PEAK PROJECT (TECHNICAL REVIEW TEAM)
To:	Livermore H; NRC - COMANCHE PEAK PROJECT (TECHNICAL REVIEW TEAM)
Shared Package
ML20197J178	List: IR 05000445/1985009; ML20197J173; ML20197J273; ML20197J296; ML20199G064; ML20199G070; ML20199G083; ML20199G092; ML20199G099; ML20199G107; ML20199G116; ML20199G119; ML20199G124; ML20199G133; ML20199G146; ML20199G154; ML20199G163; ML20199G179; ML20199G212; ML20199G284; ML20199G292; ML20199G298; ML20199G306; ML20199G318; ML20199G331; ML20199G343; ML20199G352; ML20199G363; ML20199G383; ML20199G391; ML20199G402; ML20199G420; ML20199G432; ML20199G442; ML20199G453; ML20199G464; ML20199G575; ML20199G614; ML20199G620; ML20199G624; ML20199G630; ML20199G635; ML20199G641; ML20199G645; ML20199G649; ML20199G655; ML20199G661; ML20199G670; ML20199G675; ML20199G681; ... further results
References
	FOIA-85-59 NUDOCS 8606250184
	Download: ML20199G343 (17)
	v • d • e

{{#Wiki_filter:/ ,'.

r

     .s          8
                  /        g   o
                                            ,                              Witut:LGMJutcr NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION                                     .

WASHINGTON, D. C. 20355

   . g.a ..
                  %.....*                                             APR         3 1926 NEMORANDUM FOR:              Herbert H. Livermore QA/QC Group Leader Comanche Peak Technical Review Team FROM:

Yincent S. Noonan, Director Comanche Peak Project

SUBJECT:

ALLEGER FEEDBACK ACTION ITEMS I have reviewed the items you identified in the December 10, meeting transcript,in response to your March 22 memorandum. Based on this review, I

. feel that some of these items can be closed out after the QA/QC SSERs are issued, however, others may require imediate follow-up, resolution, and even additional feedback to allegers before SSER publishing.

Please review the attached listing of these items and provide your schedule [ for clcse-out to me by c.o.b., April 12, 1985. c . x w.. I s Cg oo an I ' AETtct Ph1TS IN L6 (Lose CL wrautLuJ ui& 4k6 AtascMs on 36< lo, /f f V.. -

                                             .@.Lsd SCAD Hits Anneltco Se
                                              .rmPA cT or) SSCRs Ato i                                    I
                                                                                                  &co (Ack-n AccestWI
                                                                                  .         a ces eso63%y-9                 gor gees
                                          .i-'...          _ . _ . , . .        .__           .                  .

,                    /k C f/0Al l               ^! C l'I      L/5/    '/? S ff g 3 e!& , ur                     J
                      / 2. lc- $// [~Ec3 EA [h'. ///TER V / E' W WIW
                      ~A L L EG ER E b - l, A - 3, '9 .6 ! A~b~Y
    *       ~'

m

                                                       ~-                                                                                   ,

afy Po o,z 2 5) h c -/7j doein/, swr are je;<g used nirx' sb'v yrs ,s: ,

                                . . .      ... % . Ds & & ndes/ 8e.~ der.                 ..
                                                                                ~

s2s,a du fiam,s #s. o/s n. d' o r3 we ye j e i<.y a s e. f n o J.> ;

                     }7                       do a//ep, NTRT~ /u.) not ren sda M se sims
   ,p.j Uf                                    Auriq 8eie investly.u%n o f da -/T.

p9 lah-w d.ded a-e mig ys 6 /c dMa /so r a .' W iW.ce o,% sis y.c d .:cee. a>Ad , i;9eslus:

                                                                                                                                     .N'o.
          .,                                 ne. aw g e& snt s,{ /sssi<y at /Aem. Ofn,s s DIQ 0 C 3, ? 8, 97,                 306, f ) B C 7 w ere ))dlrfe) clariny f%. rQedM iriuvieu )
. /Lp 59             A a-m            - see sha-c.

A// eyer ,q-s nhJ if NRc Ti2T~ iosd z'en f.%. b rm-ewr4 i /;ss <>:n 4 euw, wer e exe a ,..; a J w J ;, a

wkJ t'irm. fr. . ZL wA &f M .cen

                                            **                           " " " " #         "           *"~*              ' ' "

04 'i

            /                               t a es. He skid *So w e V/ 'si> e usa                '       rW    iwm Aer: JJ ik : & ~ -c.,

we w h eft 2A jg &yl3M 'r.* h/AA;f C/:d

b.& 'h l.. ts) l$k f 50 jndir/Mc YAd% 4 ec,.] ws,se.;,/, sn w!/s.

9

                                                     ~                        o         6          ,       Ofe<Yb            f  aa  Y

p / s dr /n/ry ad puud'rCLds,7s:.wl Cer6'5'66 'n= .

g kae-two g lC'< 8 * /L.:

                                         -              Sil 14 e S $c*    $ Ytd-4 ,GeoSb2       S/        $   ^W    Y b-*lk fJ '

ftD g $$h$h, k hN k h ?w'_v.V i ,85 .- i a$h f h,. ?hYh k'$f/n B '~~~ S.li ' I d<ld-uA,, i bla A d /s ea Ic 70L O e.- IE [ l

      'f l ei,uL) locak Me ~, s~l r '&                            s     in divld"J - w e ee .wl!!/~j b zk)? 6 DE y 65en, a> e u s al c e r t.. in. /;. A*c b ta t,e b d ie ,>;.

~

,c.. . . ~ - ...... .; .. . .. . . n . .ir. . .a ' i .-AGc55 - rar- .avi.r seinics ' s tact

                                                 , 0 C - lt3.:pe<$srs hs/(y /n ,,cl_a c.ame_Q/on gp l7y; cr Df f 2, 93,                                                                                              .                        .. m.

Noon ~ jszacs , ,,,m);b) n-7-76A : s ,<,e.6,, & A g . ,,,,n e Naa. ///2& SLc79 S f s s/ Hor; sn whe?Wut Q.stainic.ss sey!sp c, 4 7-u 9 0 c/ b'h er,g. at' bede & $s ~6 "eee sadf re/~ted s f zG(h ar ~e r- da l,p \p Aloons.,~. ,orsmisel dop'er o r- vto &. A//ye.,s . A- /, if-3, i9 -f and. A 5*f wAen ;c Je- } ?' pbit I s n i M /c.. ... o T , t . {,- - ,

                                          ..m...                                         .
~ fn 91 : A n-ss - se d,,e.
        .V A//e7er A-/ .hyaestaJ per/s/u/or b &//ec NWLE6 ypr:-

Y&cks for tw/ Le. extra-ch S m va.v-joes J H.w?.E6 ~ r :s ett).

                                                                                                                                  .                 /

Oncerniy spe.,2 hel po./ linbr: g refirred-S th s-Vece

a. s Usp-t.. A eI aad.ll7h & 'd a 'skl rWen 6 /Voone

u. e .i si,,,,,iy a r can. "

                                                                                                                                                  .i/s na ~

6 yesse

             .aM            UA ifn                             '& u. rW inab,/as 4 Aim; Ae w4 sui it b & riyt p.y/c..                                                                                        -

7

                                                                                                                .        p. W+ 9'~ ~
                                                                                                . Oil ~
                                                                                                  /

8

l -. ; ..~.,

'~

9 y . jo2, j js.3, . , t aar ///c,a.ts, 0-72 /o/,; AG-5. /z. /31 Iy ist2 /IG sff.7e</ ;4f.a .ena.4,, a./ '

   ~
                                                        >yy<a42 -Nr~- .>n                      a b' 4.r~hvip[.Is4

n/M wavaJ ase em o, (Z/nn).

y o f Jniee,fr %

                                       ;        Alleger A-s ss&d                                ,p ess/an. as w;1L O;y. 14. .,

g b

  *~'q               ,.          ss d1J P3 6e J th -M tLt a, eye.: din;r uia s 4,:e L                                           t/>!ro~ it         wa.s nst on de corkrs/ dee.ame d nse zu.< :

to an HCR mez6d u.sel i6 sisu) 24'.<A zWis sua s doc e f . 4tl in wifa.& pauh'% ,,, _ .

                      ~
                                                                   - A J--

Jh. TXT, snisirleyen) Mt conies-o, s J y'iw' ae,

                                ...            Co d d no t.a , s wee t!i: p <.t;r.

sh$g } . Allyev A-r asia.1 if hr rewed r%. McR% Lt O anesd & ccs/ 'sta Ji~ In & .in=tta i o u-w .-> ;r. codin fM n s e,v, ! - 9pa- s */ r,u de, >:: ' en a ey uw n s sa c,.s ee.r <d,
&p Tn.7 i
l do &,si q.cjul air esssa~t A -s d: 0 wn~61 & h ~ u/w .7,z r data.i 6 da</,ty His diwe: n? a&. /h6 ie,e
slid ne t- pas a>. Nso nw s..s,e

.d % -PM sur a 's:
iL Ncp'n ? " A'An:~ re>ynt d: d "y e s *. e t
w
,,) ,
5 Pnc itt-n4; /1a </o ; . con-ty..z%-L'dy J de.d wa,:. .
~ ,& /bbsw.ss2h/ Way & Hz- he.<z'na& f,Dag .aA $ q coJr,I. " n/Aye< A-5 paesb'snul 0Do yan xnow whe~ t'm m A d/L 2 f
determindim .7 * /?aksn did and- ww. EL sd k
wi// /alu. %.f- AM & toe. witi 6'n) od w/M,N/s wo Am.
Ye'{lga b & b z% Aeyinnih.~
.A-/ ast.eJ "Is it neeessq /r m.1ist6th? & & i/,y, sn w:/./
filler ins.te Os) on r2an ASt>fE //ner o r w e /ds ? * /M8me < - A tw sve5 t L t it e dr on 7%.,,sro cek ,eou 'r-e er/np on s/re. .
/9-/ skW M- ies 7 % 4.n i Gocuso z h w ies s )Jr was bs9/f suf 62 quaDRed wd.Aws ~s t- d. L w o e.,. .
b'w. /s >wHiay o % welds a J z%. stal,uless sfeel dhers 2LL rep aires mAris/ bue - abl/lbj. 2ah == Smim.) ; Eat //-/ was ton a, a ) s.1 & we:) YoA tru. Ll)Ny on 'weldig a M s,od Se/ po./ s J capihy
~
f liher. /%bn.sen. ;.sfak) N zH.L,procek would hone. -{o be ' exa,ntned. Aar1rf acaal- M d -h e cl. o d (s h . p# f 'k ' 5[g '
-, = _, w. , . . . , *e m -ev.- * -....--ee.. -.. .w.,.- -.e.. e-
ve:~. ~- m , ...
~
. it . . r . . (f4" /2/-I;-3; A62-77 And :7fl Uticerniy s>w% Sdr/&~ d.
N ri u . & / y L.s g s n : ~ C p a r t : Sagl a.r e y a j o / h - A .f g
~
[
. ..Ne.w fo st af:'ee recey in.yeedhn, d. ss.1G t -
y I. re/M pares were ir L in i % F L ' 5 4.,, , a y: . a y T*S'Icsd!cn instrudhn: -
. 0-~ sn eye bo/b % /ost- [or- a. veNbe su,y%' eof /!u, . , .
Utey (Crdh hu.n) tusa).) tc29. !. neckc A on e.ie bat .,,&.?'%y . F.a % , w.? i
.f.s.4 J n.s Sho2 n:~ ' ~
u 6 e::6it'd/o sn9 do mssian> a s a esa:n e R::, =- w-p5 y% a st
.ZL ma a-s w -
a ma,;M- a.,4.mr -
.:qs3 4% s A n eye 6th ad ,c, mre /.JJ. ((s%$sai./ * ~ ' '
0.oD . shou) 7x7~ some sn .[/ed'm 8(,0. g
. ' ' ' '~ ~
s .
. ..i'.
we .e, . e.. k 9 4
s. .

. . , n .
lU)g ursa O.- 1l Q) alleyes '3,b R p es neem kwe resultOln., L.: . ~ . . ;V4labi n
fp< c des L- &~d yeview, Asms-kcumedadim, ,rnsnipa/ din of safely -rekted doca-
~
nie4~ati.m. . TR7' csub u& Rd a y <a re wlaa 4 doca,ne,Mio,, tuas beinf ynanipd4ad. Fourfee.~,pn eek.c dddew
. Yevised. Al19 ex A -f . s.sked whd z% >tu4 e es w e < e-g -Px %. Y evise) .clo ca m eas; Ti~m 0vy y d'dtwt A m w .
L o ff bd .bu)~ G bid de U ?Wd~ Jr N< Era.Os rr /,, };s y wate: so m ukuu. Z ku % szk. b A dt d' we '# .
.Y*D . g e f /dz dscamed h A err 0< d't. a//yevc.
01Y1 J 0 . 9 t 9 9 9 e e
,r , - _ - , - - - , - - - - - - , , - - . , - .e r- - - . _ . - ,
fans /s.s-Act //o-80; coneeLs decic-ses .4'einy .rw<d A sn _
..1~2% rs.thes z%.o .//cR%. - 7%is was a peser/c /kra<- . r e.'. wa- wed 6 h a . e CorJibisns' zLk as/d be vyaired u.ary ewsGy ,. . .froceh.uu1.. ZY Ne refair reguires an en;rkee </r-j e v.cl u M sn o{ f/zyPshk,~, s n /VCR ens & A'e.
USed. *
~ ~ - Allue< A-/ s&.tedWdad o-n .r2 wM a Sry .sipshuu euded zS y/re- .
to rer ak R &ir:ts;Mod &c rt eodains s siu-ur 2hl v k synel l& o RC Z z L s6 des / h wsasi y a.
}A & n<r..s (II-il-eY) anJpic/c k up. % $nry s M J PA t- Pg,%s c L !se IR ' . <ya,es
. &n'ey 4 .some. frdiny sf sJs: in .Z~2 L. AHyer A-5
+- ..
asaad sL2 d& tLk,omeda.u--- w 14o effeen. Laryy did..n.o?- k oa) tL' proadu~. /srae. Ate.
.2 uls.is f romised b On[sut 6L. Israe. a'.a%.
e 4 9 [
-g. -,. - , _
p w ~
' ', P w i, - a;bn L,0 :.r r v @# ;y g ;- _ , 7c g\; * ~
V $.; - tO u m m u,o m voc : v. o %& E sd P.ad, e. % at b
. . .. . . - .h .
1I; Vf@ M .' . . $ Y.'. N i WW O V1i ) & ,L bM 2! L . _ _ . _ . . . . .. _ . _ . . . _ _ . . . . . . I M %M.L.T l h4;E6t(L. Ytt.b'F.MM A C10b) I T 1 M .s
R1PumNcu: wrracauuur s , u.rrut.-H.t - .
. Yo \)i docw:ui. , 3 / Lt. E' , S 0 0.-t t c T ; LT+FF c.c M .*t i T x t.wt s, h . .
5 7 ATNkt.er.u ~ W rn.v v. >Uo % No .k b etVu er , 4
./.1) %u 0 +'t c-r . A atst.rt
(.gwy s maw 3
. n ue. m u n w. m nu lty .
r .) .. .. _ . ... . -. .. g . . . . .. -. r \ . 4- . e.c -t . Yes.c b [ $ . d e x h a.. D -aA& . ; J m .1 F .a'GA sf. %- P+/9e fmp w ~
- #m 1
( x 0 7Xc i Eds/-14:ba%rka.4 1 .. A c - i.co k f d~zL m-% p.u w . 1 j .. QR/ a' ~pc 7L rar : dhu. myu .ak d. l}\
~~ a$4 A ct 1j f'dh.m ML . ,af' u .. , . M t j.{ ; dx elu.u /1-;d-t um/ de/~~
f. .
ndMerw ndzh</ Ndf we Au./&&u (np-m). aw d ga 9 - -w i%
. a 4,.4 3 L C. -
K h A 4' ' ' % g aa n p.
~ ,- w w m ,a w &ee 9 6.w p& W \ sssw.9 m 4 A . J ~ J Q
n ~a nd.4 al da -Je dd.f
; & J .t M--!!i 21 ..
y& a ~~t C - W
I l
& Ok a
4 :.do edm %qc -6//n d
% a c A t t - k . J L m w &s g- / ~~ .
YL
& Ms~r ,#f A ~ 4 E M 4/ l Of ; I k Mt n d5dL 9F/M -f Aduf M py& . ws& a- - 5 , d e /. A J f&
!l .
..........+,....s-... . . . . . . . . . . . _ . .. -. -
7, r/c_ n- - L y e
.e % d & ,. wae-- -
TL_. ce +/9e A-7 A d J-/ M stf h.:~LL d/M: b.J- ? . [I
.a -t a Ld -
tl " L d ce L V~
'S.fl N '~"
l -7 g 4g d. ~
~ 3 / >Ue A4o
r" P-' g ud.
4
~
i j. j (D A ._M& q^S"- '6 N ma/m
,{
{ - Q [S% TILT 10 o b+uw I L ~ elW hl c?kq c l. Cy ' w y .
~
g) any G .4 p a anc-l w xc ma.
);
A M g p nu +4 s 1%wg Aa- 4 ~q{,e. ge scoy .
# A /.WW G -~ s=; ar L-g ypup~
5 m s ao~, 15 dd pa ti Ob
s,=d g e'#/m*c [ht% % 4-
} _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
C [li( h G hk<\ y
^
f)a/, w .1.ul _~ i.s u - 1 q S. WJ \ V a -atz l u . (O A J/.. m. 4 W - 2~~ A ' &
~
f. <
M Y L m .- EuNJ 1' 7L. go e e - u.L i . 4 r = Mdec/ ~ / du w wY u do
-n nu , .2:~- su M&n64 f t .utQ .A aa puy&yf //
p w LT
& q.de -f k . %5 Lit /-
AQ f s Aum n_- .+ - u ,
. -p wp .
f L a' w-
'p JG,M '
f E - 4 -#d< ad t ~e/ w } 3 #A@Js ed M 4Mh hM
~
j.f 7rr~ g 2 tk*
~ #t 1,
1
@&vac-m J n J J d' ~LC g~ ( a& -G%.J4 ln }k au- mluf . n.dui >a mqqe e, .
c 4 4% u/
1 .. 4 J 4
&f 7' d
\ .
, JL m _ , i cladyad % _Af A 2 ) ?! - & pe/ge JA & n .CMZ m & WWb Tu 2C -
n+ f
& As 0 [ ~c &
n .u x. h + ner d&A t
~ '
A 7L o 6 & x/g>6 fa2' p s .
& + 9 9 9' 6 p gx- J &
dan- 4 J~ & n y~dd- ~ A -%
-nrm phd & Ny4 ~
p d. sam A &L x,,J y' d - 4 Ja A
- axw& ~~~1;&ffaL ~
vp J a/ { & ddb M . r r / w p/e p p A ws X"-LX '1 1 w ar hm '
% '_ m'd -. Jg ,, i [ F_ ' )
w =ed A5 ,4 .mAM4h afM ^Y
-C-- - , . _ ----=
_ _ _~=_ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
e m s k ---,a---m a - - - - - , + 9 9 h ' [,; - c l :~ j ',, , Y '& I['
& 4.s+sdi p o.LJ p:
c. W & NJ dodr4 S'q glqc. 3 ug am ;-
,4lA._ m m, ;e , &%i au ~ . /% # A l, f - A a sy+d , s$17. AlaL/ - ?-
fik di Ap sy & cJ
\
Di~ 'Y^~nnyyh{ j.L9;
...rl ! ;. y ; %
j 5, ~ '.:., <;i ' 7;; . ,- h .,,
,# W ,
4E AJ wr n w!P%lE r bh/df,Ma/&.m?y$5Q ai n ,w
%fh gg O?k fl Ss%lL M977 s d4mst & T Jn.c w & J J ., /a -,-~'c~
y ra ,ma A- ~d dyl4 K au n v yp uafw da 4 -ax - m s A& n/f f ducfn . 7L -- ~a- !? Y M u W Mf sy n atg y pe9/
& & / ~ ; + u %,.-.
y,$N w a /, T S
+p c / :: ~
udd.Aud _ % 6 W 9 9 9 s~/- m(/4-f5 U '
^
,g .. - -_ >
c. 7 h .. N [^ -- __ _
#^- $$1k k Aa A tL O A -
1 9ffi13 b t i "1 N gw-_n,sx . . te -L -A m s - s ,.,u . s l IJir k&- d d hL;, % . g& JJ 7 w. l Y d )~ _rda a / M ."h rwve - -d L i A _ By s uTrt;+ n a N w. s 2f a n~_p- /
~
y . s trL:ye-Aq n fA .d & ' Aw-s el d' d i . d f .
1
) & '4 ?- ~CE? @ Ml % AD aqqw ms .L,/s. A c 1 % E & J A g far- L em, O h6 g A,// % Ad #
ddJl%
"f L d']y ccA
sr A-dm Tnr g-/.
N" f $g! eab9Wf['ti ' ~ 4 - o g . 7L. (B) && M %&J - ~Kg /x xM ? p d e ~ ogf ZD -J~/M. a 39 m &/ ci 0- PP -/v, 6
. If d f f-/D - V Y . >h h &h TitrSf[ .f d 4 . _ _ . - . .. ..
[ * ,
=
9 g... I I g, T
}
L%.- L) L= v tm 4 ty- h { A:A-a 4 r5
-Ack- m W
4 fn Ad Per g t v7 nd+ ; n s . P y Mi ,qdi
; ~ A -
Ad ~ . . v.
-p (i .
k _ %\.2 % f %0 V
i<cr ' qwlq e. L eelct .
4 b, I f i t a aae . i . _7 di k 6~ . . .--. . . . . . . . . . . . - . ~ . . - - . . - . . . -
N i MAR 2 21985
. MEMORANDUM FOR: V. Noonan, Director I Comanche Peak Project 't i FROM: , H. H. Livermore, QA/QC Group Leader
SUBJECT:
l' OPEN TRT STAFF COMMITMENTS In the exit meeting with allegers conducted at the Granbury Inn on Dec.10, 1984, you and Mr. Zudans made commitments to perform additional work of an 2 investigatory nature. Most of the verbal commitments were made while
! discussing the QA/QC group allegations (AQ) and therefore may possibly .
Iy delay final release of the SSERs. These items are detailed in the transcript i on pages 23, 30, 81, 82, 83, 94, 98, 101, 102, 103, 107, 111-114, 121-123, 157,
, 158, 163-165. ,
Please advise as to your or Mr. Zudans' follow-up or disposition of these items. cA c<.eer %- H. H. Livemore, TRT QA/QC Group Leader i
, cc: J. Zudans i
C. Poslusny l A. Viett.i . [ 4 I
; DISTRIBUTION:
L. Shao
; H. Livermore 4
i t l U eh TRT QA/QC CP l H. Livermore i 3/ /85 5 Q{i,(dI(
- v v :.. & ) ) $..
V P- l ... [-VX.) . . - - - - - . . - - --
.}}

ML20199G343

Text

SUBJECT:

SUBJECT:

Navigation menu

Search