ML20128D957

Informs That Two Primary Concerns of Branch Expressed to Applicant in AEC & to GE During 740425 Telcon Remain Unresolved Re Prompt Relief Trip

ML20128D957
Person / Time
Site:	Monticello
Issue date:	05/24/1974
From:	Basdekas D US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
To:	Ippolito T US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
References
NUDOCS 9212070433
Download: ML20128D957 (2)

Text

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ --

amaws gg.76 i

i Thones A. Ippolito. Chief. Electrical. Instrumentation & Control 4

Systems Branch. L THRU D. Tondi. Section Leader. El&CS Branch. L NORTHERN STATES p0WER COMPANY. MONTICELLO NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION.

PROMPT RELIEF TRIP SYSTEM (PRT) i j The two primary concerns of the sit.CS Branch expressed to the i applicant on our April 4. 197411) letter and to General Electric during our telephone conference on April 2S,1974 remain

unresolved.

! The applicant's response of May 13,1974(2) to our letter of l April 4.1974 states that they consider the present design t satisfactory and plan no changes to:

I

a) minimize the possibility of inadvertent actuation of nore than one safety / relief valves and, 1 4

, b) provide testability of the PRT system in accordance with Regulatory Guide 1.22.

This is in contrast to the understanding we reached during a telephone conference with General Electric representatives on

! April 25.1974. During that telephone conference. Jack Bensen I of General Electric made the comitment to provide design j changes aimed at satisfying our two aforementioned concerns.

I It is recommended that the applicant be advised that we will uire l these design changes and we will expect to rtview them, along th l other pRT features, before PRT can be approved for installation in '

Honticello.

Demetrios L. Basdekas Electrical. Instrumentation &

Control Systems Branch Directorate of Licensing

References:

!' (1) Letter to L. O. Mayer. Northern States Power Company, from . ,

D. L. Ziemann. ORB-2. April 4,1974 (2) Letter to D. L. Ziemann. ORB-2 from L. O. Mayer. May 13. 1974 f

ot rica > ,,_ ._ -

4

$pnN&34$ M ..-.*~i.e pat * - . ~ . - ~~

Form AF.C.)l. (Rev. 9 54 ALCM 0240 s po - c.s to s t as e-s oso sea 9212070433 740524 PDR ADOCK 05000263 P PDR

i 4 i a-n>w w -

i .

t i

r Trumas A. Ippolito {

t cc: 5. Hanauer

, J. Hendrie A. Gla dusso i i V. Stallo R. DeYoung V. Moore )

) K. Goller

]

D. Ziemann '

D. Ross

T. Novak D. Tondi D. Basdekt.s

., J. Shea DISTRIBUTION:

Docket File L RDG v EIC Rdg i

f I

l

-l 1l >

l I I +

q l

.. ornc e * ..LIEICS S

_._gE.CS ..... L ' __.

eva a == > DLBasde as._ DTondi- TAJ._1od,_- . , _ , , , , , , , _ _ . _ , , ,,,,,,,,,,,,

! oan *

~

k2hll_- . S- 3l 74 _ 5 % -74 1 Foese AEC 318 (Rev. 9 $)) AEChi 0240 sao cas. es ciaes.e eso-saa

..w-v4e'=+v vv'-. +,,,e.,< e,,--.rm cym., w- e c. vm-.v--+.- .--w y.,.,,-- --,,,me -#-w-- .-m..-- .- -w, y- -+rw o,-., ,,9,,ye.-

-