ML21264A172: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(StriderTol Bot change)
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
Line 2: Line 2:
| number = ML21264A172
| number = ML21264A172
| issue date = 09/21/2021
| issue date = 09/21/2021
| title = History 101: Radium Part II Trying to Close Pandora'S Box
| title = History 101: Radium Part II Trying to Close Pandoras Box
| author name = Wellock T
| author name = Wellock T
| author affiliation = NRC/OPA, NRC/SECY
| author affiliation = NRC/OPA, NRC/SECY
Line 15: Line 15:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:Radium Part II: Trying to Close Pandoras Box Until 1945, radium was the best-known radioactive material. It was widely found in consumer and medical products. And, as we saw in Part I of this series, it became notorious for fatally sickening radium watch-dial painters in the 1920s. With few exceptions, oversight of public and workplace safety for radium was mostly a state responsibility, and the federal governments role was limited to such issues as preventing false advertising and regulating mail shipments.
{{#Wiki_filter:Radium Part II: Try ing to Close Pandoras Box
At that time, radioisotopes came from just two limited sources. They were painstakingly isolated from natural ores, as was radium, or created in small batches in particle accelerators. These accelerators fire beams of electrons, protons and other particles at elements to create radioactive isotopes. Today the products of these two processes are called NARMshort for Naturally-Occurring and Accelerator-Produced Radioactive Material.
Scientists working on fission and the Manhattan Project discovered new radioactive isotopes with interesting properties. They soon became widely available to scientists, who found many uses for these products, from medical to basic research. They were under federal control and soon eclipsed the small amounts of radium and other NARM that existed before the war. Cold-War security concerns demanded federal control of nuclear technology and this new radioactive material.
Still, the 1946 Atomic Energy Act avoided intruding on state authority over NARM. It focused the Atomic Energy Commissions oversight on fissionable material such as uranium and thorium and reactor-produced isotopes. The AEC controlled the vast majority of radioactive material.
This division of power didnt disturb existing state authority but made little technical sense. An isotope produced in a reactor would be identical to one found in nature or produced in an accelerator.
Moreover, state oversight was uneven.
Radium had lost its luster and fallen into disuse. Safer reactor-produced isotopes and sources with shorter half-lives mostly replaced radium for medical uses. Radium consumer products disappeared from stores by the 1970s. But products made with radium during its heyday (see Part I) retain their hazard for a long time.
So, from time to time, reports would emerge of products found in someones attic or office, or contamination found in a building. This prompted the Public Health Service to launch a program to collect and safely dispose of old radium sources.
Beginning in the late 1960s, state radiation control officers called for legislation to give the AEC and later the NRC the power to regulate radium and other NARM. In 1985 the NRC asked to be given authority over NARM waste disposal, but Congress took no action. The status quo remained, in part due to difficulties Congress had deciding on the federal agency best suited to regulate radium and oversee cleanup.


Little changed until the 1990s when terrorism provided a new dimension of concern. Experts worried that untracked or stolen radioactive sources, including radium, could be used in dirty bombs. Between 1998 and 2003, as part of the U.S. delegation to the International Atomic Energy Agency, the NRC worked with member nations on a code of conduct for radioactive sources. To limit the potential for malicious acts, the code appealed to each country to develop a national system of regulation for a list of radioactive sources  radium among them.
U nt il 1 9 4 5, r a dium w a s t he be s t-know n r a dioa c t ive ma t e r ia l. I t w a s w ide ly found in c ons ume r a nd me dic a l pr oduc t s. A nd, a s w e s a w in Pa r t I of t his s e r ie s, it be c a me not or ious for fa t a lly s ic ke ning r a dium w a t c h-dia l pa int e r s in t he 1920s. Wit h fe w e x c e pt ions, ove r s ig ht of public a nd workplace safety for radium was mostly a state r e s pons ibilit y, a nd t he fe de r a l g ove r nme nt s r ole w a s limit e d t o s uc h is s ue s a s pr e ve nt ing fa ls e a dve r t is ing a nd r e g ula t ing ma il s hipme nt s.
In the wake of 9/11, support for the IAEA code gained momentum. Congress included a provision in the 2005 Energy Policy Act giving NRC oversight of radium and other sources of NARM. A consensus for federal regulation emerged only when national security issues joined long-standing health concerns.
 
By Thomas Wellock, NRC Historian}}
A t t ha t t ime, r a diois ot ope s c a me fr om jus t t w o limit e d s our c e s. T he y w e r e pa ins t a king ly is ola t e d fr om natural ores, as was radium, or created in s mall batches in particle accelerators. Thes e accelerators fire be a m s of e le c t r ons, pr ot ons a nd ot her pa rt icles a t element s t o crea t e ra dioa ct ive is ot opes. Toda y t he pr oduc t s of t he s e t w o pr oc e s s e s a r e c a lle d N A R M s hort for Nat urally-Oc c ur r ing a nd A c c e le r a t or-Pr oduc e d R a dioa c t ive M a t e r ia l.
 
Sc ie nt is t s w or king on fis s ion a nd t he M a nha t t a n Pr oje c t disc ove r e d ne w r a dioa c t ive is ot ope s w it h int e r e s t ing pr ope r t ie s. T he y s oon be c a me w ide ly a va ila ble t o s c ie nt is t s, w ho found ma ny us e s for t he s e pr oduc t s, fr om me dic a l t o ba s ic r e s e a r c h. T he y w e r e unde r fe de r a l c ont r ol a nd s oon e c lips e d t he s ma ll a m ount s of r adium a nd ot he r N A R M t ha t e x is t e d be for e t he w a r. C old-Wa r s e c ur it y c onc e r ns de ma nde d fe de r a l c ont r ol of nuc le a r t e c hnolog y a nd t his ne w r a dioa c t ive ma t e r ia l.
 
St ill, t he 1946 At omic E ne r g y Ac t a voide d int r uding on s t a t e a ut hor it y ove r N AR M. I t foc us e d t he At omic E ne r g y C ommis s ion s ove r s ig ht on fis s iona ble ma t e r ia l s uc h a s ur a nium a nd t hor ium a nd r e a c t or-pr oduc e d is ot ope s. T he A E C c ont r olle d t he va s t ma jor it y of r a dioa c t ive ma t e r ia l.
 
T his divis ion of pow e r didn t dis t ur b e x is t ing s t a t e a ut hor it y but ma de litt le t e c hnic a l s e ns e. A n is ot ope pr oduc e d in a r e a c t or w ould be ide nt ic a l t o one found in na t ur e or pr oduc e d in a n a c c e le r a t or.
Moreover, s t a t e overs ig ht wa s uneven.
 
R a dium ha d los t it s lus t e r a nd fa lle n int o dis us e. Sa fe r r e a c t or-pr oduc e d is ot ope s a nd s our c e s w it h s hor t e r ha lf-live s mos t ly r e pla c e d r a dium for me dic a l us e s. R a dium c ons ume r pr oduc t s dis a ppe a r e d fr om s t or e s by t he 1970s. B ut pr oduc t s ma de w it h r a dium dur ing it s he yda y (s e e Pa r t I ) r e t a in t he ir ha z a r d for a long t ime.
 
So, fr om t ime t o t ime, r epor t s w ould e me r g e of pr oduc t s found in s ome one s a t t ic or offic e, or c ont a mina t ion found in a building. T his pr ompt e d t he Public H e a lt h Se r vic e t o la unc h a pr og r a m t o c olle c t a nd s a fe ly dis pos e of old r a dium s our c e s.
 
B e g inning in t he la t e 1 9 6 0 s, s t a t e r a dia t ion c ont r ol offic e r s c a lle d for le g is la t ion t o g ive t he AE C a nd la t e r t he N R C t he pow e r t o r e g ula t e r a dium a nd ot he r N AR M. I n 1985 t he N R C a s ke d t o be g ive n a ut hor it y ove r N A R M w a s t e dis pos a l, but C ong r e s s t ook no a c t ion. T he s t a t us quo r e ma ine d, in pa rt due t o diffic ult ie s C ong r e s s ha d de c iding on t he fe de r a l a g e nc y be s t s uit e d t o r e g ula t e r a dium a nd ove r s e e c le a nup.
L it t le c ha ng e d unt il t he 1990s w he n t e r r or is m pr ovide d a ne w dime ns ion of c onc e r n. E x pe r t s w or r ie d t ha t unt r a c ke d or s t ole n r a dioa c t ive s our c e s, inc luding r a dium, c ould be us e d in dir t y bombs. B e t w e e n 1998 a nd 2003, a s pa r t of t he U. S. de le g a t ion t o t he I nt e r na t iona l At omic E ne r g y Ag e nc y, t he N R C w or ke d w it h me mbe r na t ions on a c ode of c onduc t for r a dioa c t ive s our c e s. T o limit t he pot e nt ial for ma lic ious a c t s, t he c ode a ppe a le d t o e a c h c ount r y t o de ve lop a na t iona l s ys t e m of r e g ula t ion for a lis t of r a dioa c t ive s our c e s r a dium a mong t he m.
 
I n t he w a ke of 9/11, s uppor t for t he I AE A c ode g a ine d mome nt um. C ong r e s s inc lude d a pr ovis ion in t he 2 0 0 5 E ne r g y Polic y A c t g iving N R C ove r s ig ht of r a dium a nd ot he r s our c e s of N A R M. A c ons e ns us for fe de r a l r e g ula t ion e me r g e d only w he n na t iona l s e c ur it y is s ue s joine d long-s t a nding he a lt h c onc e r ns.
 
B y Thoma s We lloc k, NR C H is t or ia n}}

Latest revision as of 20:40, 19 November 2024

History 101: Radium Part II Trying to Close Pandoras Box
ML21264A172
Person / Time
Issue date: 09/21/2021
From: Thomas Wellock
Office of Public Affairs, NRC/SECY
To:
References
Download: ML21264A172 (1)
v • d • e


Text

Radium Part II: Try ing to Close Pandoras Box

U nt il 1 9 4 5, r a dium w a s t he be s t-know n r a dioa c t ive ma t e r ia l. I t w a s w ide ly found in c ons ume r a nd me dic a l pr oduc t s. A nd, a s w e s a w in Pa r t I of t his s e r ie s, it be c a me not or ious for fa t a lly s ic ke ning r a dium w a t c h-dia l pa int e r s in t he 1920s. Wit h fe w e x c e pt ions, ove r s ig ht of public a nd workplace safety for radium was mostly a state r e s pons ibilit y, a nd t he fe de r a l g ove r nme nt s r ole w a s limit e d t o s uc h is s ue s a s pr e ve nt ing fa ls e a dve r t is ing a nd r e g ula t ing ma il s hipme nt s.

A t t ha t t ime, r a diois ot ope s c a me fr om jus t t w o limit e d s our c e s. T he y w e r e pa ins t a king ly is ola t e d fr om natural ores, as was radium, or created in s mall batches in particle accelerators. Thes e accelerators fire be a m s of e le c t r ons, pr ot ons a nd ot her pa rt icles a t element s t o crea t e ra dioa ct ive is ot opes. Toda y t he pr oduc t s of t he s e t w o pr oc e s s e s a r e c a lle d N A R M s hort for Nat urally-Oc c ur r ing a nd A c c e le r a t or-Pr oduc e d R a dioa c t ive M a t e r ia l.

Sc ie nt is t s w or king on fis s ion a nd t he M a nha t t a n Pr oje c t disc ove r e d ne w r a dioa c t ive is ot ope s w it h int e r e s t ing pr ope r t ie s. T he y s oon be c a me w ide ly a va ila ble t o s c ie nt is t s, w ho found ma ny us e s for t he s e pr oduc t s, fr om me dic a l t o ba s ic r e s e a r c h. T he y w e r e unde r fe de r a l c ont r ol a nd s oon e c lips e d t he s ma ll a m ount s of r adium a nd ot he r N A R M t ha t e x is t e d be for e t he w a r. C old-Wa r s e c ur it y c onc e r ns de ma nde d fe de r a l c ont r ol of nuc le a r t e c hnolog y a nd t his ne w r a dioa c t ive ma t e r ia l.

St ill, t he 1946 At omic E ne r g y Ac t a voide d int r uding on s t a t e a ut hor it y ove r N AR M. I t foc us e d t he At omic E ne r g y C ommis s ion s ove r s ig ht on fis s iona ble ma t e r ia l s uc h a s ur a nium a nd t hor ium a nd r e a c t or-pr oduc e d is ot ope s. T he A E C c ont r olle d t he va s t ma jor it y of r a dioa c t ive ma t e r ia l.

T his divis ion of pow e r didn t dis t ur b e x is t ing s t a t e a ut hor it y but ma de litt le t e c hnic a l s e ns e. A n is ot ope pr oduc e d in a r e a c t or w ould be ide nt ic a l t o one found in na t ur e or pr oduc e d in a n a c c e le r a t or.

Moreover, s t a t e overs ig ht wa s uneven.

R a dium ha d los t it s lus t e r a nd fa lle n int o dis us e. Sa fe r r e a c t or-pr oduc e d is ot ope s a nd s our c e s w it h s hor t e r ha lf-live s mos t ly r e pla c e d r a dium for me dic a l us e s. R a dium c ons ume r pr oduc t s dis a ppe a r e d fr om s t or e s by t he 1970s. B ut pr oduc t s ma de w it h r a dium dur ing it s he yda y (s e e Pa r t I ) r e t a in t he ir ha z a r d for a long t ime.

So, fr om t ime t o t ime, r epor t s w ould e me r g e of pr oduc t s found in s ome one s a t t ic or offic e, or c ont a mina t ion found in a building. T his pr ompt e d t he Public H e a lt h Se r vic e t o la unc h a pr og r a m t o c olle c t a nd s a fe ly dis pos e of old r a dium s our c e s.

B e g inning in t he la t e 1 9 6 0 s, s t a t e r a dia t ion c ont r ol offic e r s c a lle d for le g is la t ion t o g ive t he AE C a nd la t e r t he N R C t he pow e r t o r e g ula t e r a dium a nd ot he r N AR M. I n 1985 t he N R C a s ke d t o be g ive n a ut hor it y ove r N A R M w a s t e dis pos a l, but C ong r e s s t ook no a c t ion. T he s t a t us quo r e ma ine d, in pa rt due t o diffic ult ie s C ong r e s s ha d de c iding on t he fe de r a l a g e nc y be s t s uit e d t o r e g ula t e r a dium a nd ove r s e e c le a nup.

L it t le c ha ng e d unt il t he 1990s w he n t e r r or is m pr ovide d a ne w dime ns ion of c onc e r n. E x pe r t s w or r ie d t ha t unt r a c ke d or s t ole n r a dioa c t ive s our c e s, inc luding r a dium, c ould be us e d in dir t y bombs. B e t w e e n 1998 a nd 2003, a s pa r t of t he U. S. de le g a t ion t o t he I nt e r na t iona l At omic E ne r g y Ag e nc y, t he N R C w or ke d w it h me mbe r na t ions on a c ode of c onduc t for r a dioa c t ive s our c e s. T o limit t he pot e nt ial for ma lic ious a c t s, t he c ode a ppe a le d t o e a c h c ount r y t o de ve lop a na t iona l s ys t e m of r e g ula t ion for a lis t of r a dioa c t ive s our c e s r a dium a mong t he m.

I n t he w a ke of 9/11, s uppor t for t he I AE A c ode g a ine d mome nt um. C ong r e s s inc lude d a pr ovis ion in t he 2 0 0 5 E ne r g y Polic y A c t g iving N R C ove r s ig ht of r a dium a nd ot he r s our c e s of N A R M. A c ons e ns us for fe de r a l r e g ula t ion e me r g e d only w he n na t iona l s e c ur it y is s ue s joine d long-s t a nding he a lt h c onc e r ns.

B y Thoma s We lloc k, NR C H is t or ia n

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML21264A172&oldid=3746358"