NRC Generic Letter 1977-02: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 3: Line 3:
| issue date = 08/04/1977
| issue date = 08/04/1977
| title = NRC Generic Letter 1977-002: Nuclear Plant Fire Protection Functional Responsibilites, Administrative Controls and Quality Assurance
| title = NRC Generic Letter 1977-002: Nuclear Plant Fire Protection Functional Responsibilites, Administrative Controls and Quality Assurance
| author name = Reid R W
| author name = Reid R
| author affiliation = NRC/NRR
| author affiliation = NRC/NRR
| addressee name = Cahill W J
| addressee name = Cahill W
| addressee affiliation = Consolidated Edison Co of New York, Inc
| addressee affiliation = Consolidated Edison Co of New York, Inc
| docket =  
| docket =  
Line 14: Line 14:
| page count = 23
| page count = 23
}}
}}
{{#Wiki_filter:WAugust 4, 1977Dockets Nos.: 50-350-247and 50-286DISTRIBUTION:Docket File (3NRC PDR (3)L PDR (3)RReidRIngramPEricksonTCarterTWambachAttorney, OELDOI&E (5)DEisenhutTBAbernathyJRBuchananACRS (16)Gray File (3)Consolidated Edison Companyof New York, Inc.ATTN: Mr. William 3. Cahill, Jr.Vice President4 Irving PlaceNew York, flew York 10003Gentlemen:RE: INDIAN POINT UNITS NOS. 1, 2. AND 3We are enclosing for your infonaation and use a copy of*Nuclear Plant Fire Protection Functional Responsibilities,Administrative Controls and Quality Assurance.* This document ispresently being used by the HRC as supplemental guidance for thereview of the organizational and adfvninistrative aspects of the fireprotection evaluation of your facility.By letter dated July 15, 1977, you indicated your intention todevelop no fire protection Technical Specifications for IndianPoint Unit No. I because it was shutdown and defueled. Ie, there-fore, request that you propose fire protection Technical Specifi-cations for Indian Point Unit No. 1 appropriate to Its presentshutdown defueled condition. A fire originating in Unit No. 1could have serious consequences at the operating units because oftheir close proximity to Unit No. 1.Sincerely,Robert W. Reid, ChiefOperating Reactors Branch #4Division of Operating ReactorsEnclosuresNuclear Plant Fire ProtectionFunctional Responsibilities,Administrative Controlsand Quality Assurancef1'u1Abpva~- jORB#4:DOMJORB#l ~~ >3TO*URNAMK.. Prickso m(?Wnbach~ ...--- ---*qkR OM318 (9-76) XRCMv 0240 *U:9. OVxNMUKNT rpRtip.NO OFFICEZ 1676-626424AT*j 8/i/7~J /k 781)T7_ ___________I_____.>
{{#Wiki_filter:W
Consolidated Edison Companyof New York, Inc.cc: Mrs. Kay Winter, LibrarianHendrick Hudson Free Library31 Albany Post RoadMontrose, New York 10548Leonard M. Trosten, EsquireLeBoeuf, Lamb, Leiby & MacRae1757 N Street, N. W.Washington, D. C. 20036Anthony Z. RoismanBerlin Roisman &1025 lAth Street,Washington, D. C., EsquireKesslerN.W., 5th Floor20005Paul S. Shemrin, Esq.Assistant Attorney GeneralState of New YorkDepartment of LawTwo World Trade CenterNew York, New York 10047Sarah Chasis, Esq.Richard M. Hall, Esquire15 West 44th StreetNew York, New York 10036Director, Technical DevelopmentProgramsState of New York Energy OfficeAgency Building 2Empire State PlazaAlbany, New York 12223Admiral Paul EarlyPower Authority ofof New York10 Columbus CircleNew York, New York(IP-3)the State10019 I *:~ .-NUCLEAR PLANT FIRE PROTECTION FUNCTIONAL RESPONSIBILITIES, ADMINISTRATIVECONTROLS AND QUALITY ASSURANCEThe functional responsibilities, administrative controls, and qualityassurance related to nuclear power plant fire protection programs have asignificant role in preventing and fighting fires. Because these controlsrepresent a significant portion of the licensee's fire protection programand are subject to periodic reviews by NRC inspectors, it is necessary tohave a common understanding between applicant/licensees, NRC reviewers,and NRC inspectors as to what constitutes adequate delineation of respon-sibilities, administrative controls and quality assurance and how theseresponsibilities and activities should be conducted. Therefore, supple-mentary guidance on these controls is desirable.Appendix A to Branch Technical Position 9.5-1 and Regulatory Guide 1.120provide overall guidance related to functional responsibilities, admin-istrative controls, and quality assurance. The discussion in the Attach-ments provides supplemental guidance on specific functional responsibilities,administrative controls, and quality assurance necessary to assure aneffective fire protection program. The table below correlates each subjectfor which supplemental guidance is provided with the respective section(s)of Appendix A and Regulatory Guide 1.120.REGULATORYSUBJECT APPENDIX A GUIDE 1.1201. Fire Protection A.1, B, C C.1, C.2, C.3Organization2. Fire Brigade A.l(d), B.5 C.1(4), C.2eTraining3. Control of B.2, B.3(c) C.2.b, C.2.c(3)Combustibles4. Control of Ignition B.3(a) C.2.c(1)Sources5. Fire Fighting A.l(d), B.1, 4, 5 C.la(4), (5),Procedures C.2.a, d, e.6. Quality AssuranceC.C.3 I-2-This supplementary guidance is to be given to utilities and is beingdistributed to NRC fire protection program reviewers and NRC Officeof Inspection and Enforcement.The licensee should provide the description of fire protection functionalresponsibilities and administrative controls in a fire protection planwhich describes his organization and its qualifications, fire brigadetraining, the controls over combustibles and ignition sources, methodsfor assuring the availability of the fire protection systems and equip-ment; procedures for fighting fires, fire watch, and quality assuranceprovisions for the fire protection program. The plan should alsoidentify the plant procedures that implement the plan. The plan will befiled with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission and the plant proceduresshould be available to NRC Inspectors and at the plant site.
                                                                              DISTRIBUTION:
                                      August 4, 1977                          Docket File (3 NRC PDR (3)
                              50-3                                          L PDR (3)
      Dockets Nos.:
                              50-247                                        RReid and 50-286                                            RIngram PErickson TCarter TWambach Consolidated Edison Company                                      Attorney, OELD
                of New York, Inc.


Attachment No. 1FIRE PROTECTION ORGANIZATION1.0 The organizational responsibilities and lines of communication per-taining to fire protection should be defined between the variouspositions through the use of organizational charts and functionaldescriptions of each position's responsibilities. As a minimum thepositions/organizations responsible for the following should bedesignated:a. The upper level offsite management position which has managementresponsibility for the formulation, implementation, and assess-ment of the effectiveness of the nuclear plant fire protectionprogram.b. The offsite management position(s) directly responsible for(1) formulating, implemenring, and periodically assessing theeffectiveness of the fire protection program for the licensee'snuclear power plant including fire drills and training con-ducted by the fire brigade and plant personnel. The resultsof these assessments should be reported to the upper levelmanagement position responsible for fire protection withrecommendations for improvements or corrective actions asdeemed necessary.(2) Using the following NFPA Publications for guidance to dev-elop the fire protection program:No. 4 -"Organization for Fire Services"No. 4A -'Organization of a Fire Department"No. 6 -"Industrial Fire Loss Prevention"No. 7 -"Management of Fire Emergencies"No. 8 -"Management Responsibilities for Effects ofFire on Operations"No. 27 -"Private Fire Brigades"c. The onsite management position responsible for the overalladministration of the plant operations and emergency plans whichinclude the fire protection and prevention program and whichprovides a single point of control and contact for all contingencies.
OI&E (5)
            ATTN: Mr. William 3. Cahill, Jr.                                 DEisenhut Vice President                                        TBAbernathy
            4 Irving Place JRBuchanan New York, flew York 10003 ACRS (16)
                                                                              Gray File (3)
            Gentlemen:
            RE:      INDIAN POINT UNITS NOS. 1, 2. AND 3 We are enclosing for your infonaation and use a copy of
            *Nuclear Plant Fire Protection Functional Responsibilities, Administrative Controls and Quality Assurance.* This document is presently being used by the HRC as supplemental guidance for the review of the organizational and adfvninistrative aspects of the fire protection evaluation of your facility.


' -2d. The onsite position(s) which:(1) implements periodic inspections to: minimize the amountof combustibles in safety related areas; determine theeffectiveness of housekeeping practices; assure the avail-ability and acceptable condition of all fire protectionsystems/equipment, emergency breathing apparatus, emergencylighting, communication equipment, fire stops, penetrationseals and fire retardant coatings; and assures prompt andeffective corrective actions are taken to correct conditionsadverse to fire protection and preclude their recurrence.(2) is responsible for the fire fighting training for operatingplant personnel and the plant's fire brigade; design andselection of equipment; periodic inspection and testing offire protection systems and equipment in accordance withestablished procedures and evaluate test results and deter-mine the acceptability of the systems under test.(3) assists in the critique of all fire drills to determinehow well the training objectives have been met.(4) reviews and evaluates proposed work activities to identifypotential transient fire loads.(5) implements a program for indoctrination of all plantcontractor personnel in appropriate administrative pro-cedures which implement the fire protection program, .and the emergency procedures relative to fire protection.(6) implements a program for instruction of personnel on theproper handling of accidental events such as leaks orspills of flammable materials that are related to fireprotection.e. The onsite position responsible for fire protection qualityassurance.This position should be responsible for assuring the effectiveimplementation of the fire protection program by planned in-spections and scheduled audits. He should assure and verifythat results of these inspections or audits are promptly re-ported to cognizant management personnel.
By letter dated July 15, 1977, you indicated your intention to develop no fire protection Technical Specifications for Indian Point Unit No. I because it was shutdown and defueled. Ie, there- fore, request that you propose fire protection Technical Specifi- cations for Indian Point Unit No. 1 appropriate to Its present shutdown defueled condition. A fire originating in Unit No. 1 could have serious consequences at the operating units because of their close proximity to Unit No. 1.


3f. The positions which are part of the plant fire brigade(1) The plant fire brigade positions should be responsible forfighting fires. The authority and responsibility of eachfire brigade position relative to fire protection shouldbe clearly defined.(2) The responsibilities of each fire brigade position shouldcorrespond with the actions required by the fire fightingprocedures.(3) The responsibilities of the fire brigade members undernormal plant conditions, should not conflict with theirresponsibilities during a fire emergency.(4) The minimum number of trained fire brigade members avail-able onsite for each operating shift should be consistentwith the activities required to combat the most significantfire. The size of 'te fire brigade should be based uponthe functions required to fight fires with adequate allow-ance for injuries.(5) The recommendations for organization, training, and equip-ment of "PRIVATE FIRE BRIGADES" as specified in NFPANo. 27-1975, including the applicable NFPA publicationslisted in the Appendix to NFPA No. 27, are consideredappropriate criteria for organizing, training, and operatinga plant fire brigade.2.0 Qualificationsa. The position responsible for formulation and implementationof the Fire Protection Program should have, within his organ-ization, or as a consultant, a Fire Protection Engineer who is agraduate of an engineering curriculum of accepted standing and whoshall have completed not-less than six years of engineeringattainment indicative of growth in engineering competency andachievement, three of which shall have been in responsiblecharge of fire protection engineering work. These requirementsare the eligibility requirements as a Member in the Societyof Fire Protection Engineers.
Sincerely, Robert W. Reid, Chief Operating Reactors Branch #4 Division of Operating Reactors Enclosures Nuclear Plant Fire Protection Functional Responsibilities, Administrative Controls                                                                  f1'u 1 A
                and Quality Assurance bpva~-  jORB#4:DOMJORB#l                ~~        >3T O
        *URNAMK.. Prickso                m(?Wnbach~                            ...---              --- *
.>  OM318 qkR        (9-76) XRCMv
                        8/i/0240~J
                            7        /k    781)T7_
                                                *U:9. OVxNMUKNT rpRtip.NO OFFICEZ___________I_____
                                                                                      1676-626424AT*j


4b. The fire brigade members qualifications should include satis-factory completion of a physical examination for performingstrenuous activity, and of the fire brigade traininadescribed inAttachment No. 2.c. The personnel responsible for the maintenance and testing of theFire Protection Systems should be qualified by training andexperience for such work.d. The personnel responsible for the training of the fire brigadeshould be qualified by training and experience for such work.
Consolidated Edison Company of New York, Inc.


ALs.'hment No. 2FIRE BRIGADi TRAININGThe training program should assure that the capability to fight potentialfires is established and maintained. The program should consist of aninitial classroom instruction program followed by periodic classroomretraining , practice in fire fighting and fire drills:1.0 Classroom Instructiona. The initial classroom instruction should include:(1) Identification of the fire hazards and associated typesof fires that could occur in the plant, and an identi-fication of the location of such hazards.(2) Identification of the location of fire fighting equip-ment for each fire area, and familiarization with layoutof the plant including access and egress routes to-eacharea.(3) The proper use of available fire fighting equipment, andthe correct method of fighting each type of fire. Thetypes of fires covered should include electrical fires,fires in cables and cable trays, hydrogen fires, flam-mable liquid, waste/debris fires, and record file fires.(4) Indoctrination of the plant fire fighting plan withspecific coverage of each individual's responsibilities.(5) The proper use of communication, lighting, ventilationand emergency breathing equipment.(6) The direction and coordination of the fire fightingactivities (fire brigade leaders only).(7) The toxic characteristics of expected products ofcombustion.(8) The proper method for fighting fires inside buildingsand tunnels.(9) Detailed review of fire fighting procedures and procedurechanges.(10) Review of latest plant modifications and changes in firefighting plans.
cc: Mrs. Kay Winter, Librarian Hendrick Hudson Free Library
    31 Albany Post Road Montrose, New York 10548 Leonard M. Trosten, Esquire LeBoeuf, Lamb, Leiby & MacRae
    1757 N Street, N. W.


*;2b. The instruction should be provided by qualified individualsknowledgeable, experienced, and suitably trained in fightingthe types of fires that could occur in the plant and in usingthe types of equipment available in the nuclear power plant.Members of the "Fire Protection Staff" and Fire Brigade Leadersmay conduct this training.c. Instruction should be provided to all fire brigade membersand fire brigade leaders.d. Regular planned meetings held every 3 months should repeatthe classroom instruction program over a two year period.2.0 PracticePractice sessions should be held for fire brigade members on theproper method of fighting various types of fires of similar mag-nitude, complexity, and difficulty as those which could occur ina nuclear power plant. These session: should provide brigade memberswith experience in actual fire extinguishment and the use of em-ergency breathing apparatus under strenuous conditions. Thesepractice sessions should be provided at regular intervals but notto exceed 1 year for each fire brigade member.3.0 Drills that thefire brigade drills should be performed in tne Plait%. -- .fire brigade can practice as a team. Drills should include thefollowing:a. Assessment of fire alarm effectiveness, time required to notifyand assembly fire brigade, and selection, placement and use ofequipment.b. Assess each brigade member's knowledge of his role in the firefighting strategy for the area assumed to contain the fire.Assess the brigade members conformance with established plantfire fighting procedures and use of fire fighting equipment,including self-contained emergency breathing apparatus, communi-cation equipment, and ventilation equipment, to the extentpracticable.
Washington, D. C. 20036 Anthony Z. Roisman , Esquire Berlin Roisman & Kessler
    1025 lAth Street, N.W., 5th Floor Washington, D. C. 20005 Paul S. Shemrin, Esq.


3c. The simulated use of fire fighting equipment required to copewith the situation and type of fire selected for the drill.The area and type of fire chosen for the drill should be variedsuch that brigade members are trained in fighting fires in allsafety related areas containing significant fire hazards. Thesituation selected should simulate the size and arrangementof a fire which could reasonably occur in the area selected,allowing for fire development due to the time required to re-spond, to obtain equipment, and organize for the fire, assumingloss of automatic suppression capability.d. Assessment of brigade leader's direction of the fire fightingeffort, as to thoroughness, accuracy, and effectiveness.e. The drills should be performed at regular intervals but notto exceed 3 months for each fire brigade. At least one drillper year should be performed on a "back shift" for each firebrigade. A sufficient number of these drills, not less than onefor each fire brigade per year, shall be unannounced, to de-termine the fire readiness of the plant fire brigade leader,brigade, fire protection systems and equipment.f. The drills should be pre-planned to establish the trainingobjectives of the drill. The drills should be critiqued todetermine how well the training objectives have been met.Unannounced drills should have their critiques performed bymembers of the management staff responsible for plant safetyand security. At three year intervals, drills should be critiquedby qualified individuals independent of the utility's staff.4.0 Records, Records of training provided to each fire brigade member includingdrill critiques should be maintained to assure that each memberreceives training in all parts of the training program. Theserecords of training should be available for review.
Assistant Attorney General State of New York Department of Law Two World Trade Center New York, New York    10047 Sarah Chasis, Esq.


" Attachment No. 3CONTROL OF CU;IBUSTIBLESAdministrative controls should be established to minimize the amount ofcombustibles that a safety related area may be exposed to. These con-trols should be established to govern:a. the handling of and limitation on the use of combustibles,flammable and explosive hazards such as flammable gases andliquids, HEPA and charcoal filters, dry unused ion exchangeresins or other combustible supplies in safety related areas,and to assure that these items are not stored in safety relatedareas.b. the transient fire loads during maintenance and modificationssuch as combustible and flammable liquids, wood and plasticproducts, spilled oil, oil drums, and other combustible mater-ials in buildings containing safety related systems or equip-ment. This control should require an in-plant review of pro-posed work activities to identify potential transient fireloads. The onsite staff member designated the responsibilityfor reviewing work activities for potential transient fireloads should specify the required additional fire protectionin the work activity procedure.When the transient fire load causes the total fire load toexceed the capabilities of existing suppression systems andequipment, additional portable suppression equipment shouldbe brought into the area.c. the removal of all waste, debris, scrap, rags, oil spills, orother combustibles resulting from the work activity, in thearea following completion of the activity, or at the end ofeach work shift, whichever is sooner.d. periodic inspection for accumulation of combustibles.e. all wood used in safety related areas to assure that itis treated with flame retardant.
Richard M. Hall, Esquire
    15 West 44th Street New York, New York 10036 Director, Technical Development Programs State of New York Energy Office Agency Building 2 Empire State Plaza Albany, New York    12223 Admiral Paul Early (IP-3)
    Power Authority of the State of New York
    10 Columbus Circle New York, New York 10019


Attachment No. 4CONTROL OF IGNITION SOURCES1.0 Administrative ControlsAdministrative controls should be instituted to protect safety-related equipment.from fire damage or loss resulting from workinvolving ignition sources, such as welding, cutting, grinding, oropen flame work; administrative controls should prohibit the use ofopen flame or combustion smoke for leak testing and controlsshould prohibit smoking and other ignition sources in certainareas.2.0 Control of Weldina, Cutting, Grinding, and Open Flame Worka. Al' cutting, welding, grinding or open-flame work shouldoe authorized by the responsible foreman or supervisorthrough a work pernmiL. The responsible foreman or supervisorshould have received a basic industrial fire fighting and fireprevention course covering anticipated fires, such as elec-trical fires, fires in cables and cable trays, hydrogen fires,hydrocarbon fires, solvent fires, waste/debris fires, and re-cord file fires.b. Before issuing the permit, the responsible foreman or super-visor should physically survey the area where the work is tobe performed and establish that the following precautions havebeen accomplished:(1) All moveable combustible material below and within a 35foot radius of the cutting, welding, grinding, or openflame work has been removed. (See NFPA 518)(2) All immovable combustible material below and within a 35foot radius has been thoroughly protected by asbestoscurtains, metal guards, or flameproof covers, and fireextinguishers, hose, or other firefighting equipment areprovided at the work site. (See NFPA 518)(3) A fire watch trained and equipped to prevent and combatfires is present throughout any operations in which thereis potential for fire Jtat mign t ge mfiff safety.related equipment. A ire watcn s ou be proided wherecutting, welding, grinding or open flame is performedabove or within a radius of 35 feet of any open cables,flammable liquids, scaffold boards, paper, rags, orother objects on the same elevation of the work or ifcombustible materials are below the work area whereopenings exist. A fire watch should be provided for all
I *
"-I2cutting, welding, grinding, and open flame work in theControl Room, Cable Spreading Room, Diesel GeneratorRooms, and other safety related areas that contain sig-nificant amount of cable or flammable liquids. (SeeNFPA 51B)The fire watch sould remain on the work site while workis performed and remain in the area for at least 30 min-utes after the work is completed to check for smolderingfires.(4) All equipment to be used is in a safe, working condition.Oxyacetylene equipment is checked for leaks before beingmoved to the work area.c. The signature concurrence of a member of the plant's managementor a quality control inspector certified to make this concurrenceshould be obtained whenever the supervisor or foreman determinesthat a fire watch is not required.3.0 Leak TestingAdministrative procedures should be established to prohibit the useof open flame or combustion smoke for leak testing. Work ordersfor leak testing should require the concurrence of the shift engineerto verify that the leak test method is acceptable and would notpresent a potential ignition source.4.0 Smoking and Ignition Source RestrictionSmoking should be prohibited in safety related areas, except where"smoking permitted" areas have been specifically designated by aresponsible member of plant management and in areas containing flammableor potentially explosive materials or atmospheres that present ahazard to safety related equipment. These areas should be identi-fied with "No Smoking" signs.
              :~                          . -
    NUCLEAR PLANT FIRE PROTECTION FUNCTIONAL RESPONSIBILITIES, ADMINISTRATIVE
    CONTROLS AND QUALITY ASSURANCE
    The functional responsibilities, administrative controls, and quality assurance related to nuclear power plant fire protection programs have a significant role in preventing and fighting fires. Because these controls represent a significant portion of the licensee's fire protection program to and are subject to periodic reviews by NRC inspectors, it is necessary have a common understanding between applicant/licensees, NRC  reviewers, and NRC inspectors as to what constitutes adequate delineation of respon- sibilities, administrative controls and quality assurance and how these responsibilities and activities should be conducted. Therefore, supple- mentary guidance on these controls is desirable.


.Attachment No. 5FIRE FIGHTING PROCEDURESfire fighting procedures should be established to cover such items asnotification of a fire, fire emergency procedures, and coordination offire fighting activities with Ofprocedureidentify_ing pa. Actions to be taken by individual discovering the fire, suchas, notification of control room, attempt to extinguish fire,and actuation of local fire suppression systems.b. Actions to be taken by the control room operator and the needfor brigade assistance upon report of a fire or receipt ofalarm on control room annunciator panel, such as: announcinglocation of fire over PA system, sounding fire alarms andnotifying the shift supervisor and the fire brigade leader ofthe type, size, and location of the fire.c. Actions to be taken by the fire brigade after notification bythe control room operator of a fire, including: location toassemble; directions given by fire brigade leader; and responsi-bilities of brigade members such as selection of fire fightingequipment and transportation to fire location, selection ofprotective equipment, use of fire suppression systems operatinginstructions, and use of preplanned strategies for fightingfires in specific areas.d. The strategies established for fighting fires in all safety-related areas and areas presenting a hazard to safety-relatedequipment. As a minimum the following subjects should becovered:(1) Identification of combustibles in each plant zone coveredby the specific fire fighting procedures.(2) Fire extinguishants best suited for controlling the firesassociated with the combustible loadings in that zone andthe nearest location of these extinguishants.(3) Most favorable direction from which to attack a fire ineach area, in view of the ventilation direction, accesshallways, stairs and doors which are most likely to befire-free, and the best station or elevation for fightingthe fire. A specific identification system shall designateall hallways, stairs, doors, fire equipment and systemcontrol locations, and other items described in the firefighting procedures. This identification should be used
Appendix A to Branch Technical Position 9.5-1 and Regulatory Guide 1.120
2in the procedures and the corresponding plant items shouldbe prominently marked so that they can be recognized indim light. All access and egress routes that involvelocked doors should be specifically identified in theprocedure with the appropriate precautions and methodsfor access specified.(4) Designation of plant systems that should be managed toreduce the damage potential during a local fire; locationof local and remote-controls for such management (e.g.,any hydraulic or electrical systems in the zone coveredby the specific fire fighting procedure that couldincrease the hazards in the area because of overpres-surization or electrical hazards).(5) Designation of vital heat-sensitive system componentsthat should be kept cool while fighting a local fire.Critical equipment which are particularly hazardouscombustible sources should be designated to receivecooling.(6) Organization of fire fighting brigades and the assignmentof special duties according to job title so that all firefighting functions are covered by any complete shift per-sonnel complement. These duties should include commandcontrol of the brigade, fire hose laying, applying theextinguishant to the fire, advancing support supplies tothe fire scene, communication with the control room,coordination with outside fire departments.(7) Identification radiological and toxic hazards in firezones.(8) Ventilation system operation that assures desired plantpressure distribution when the ventilation flow ismodified for fire containment or smoke clearing operations.(9) Operations requiring control room and shift engineercoordination or authorization.(10) Instructions for plant operators and general plant per-sonnel during fire.e. The validity of the preplanning strategies should be tested byappropriate full-dress drills to check the logic of thestrategy, the adequacy of the equipment, personnel under-standing, and to uncover unforeseen problems.
    provide overall guidance related to functional responsibilities, admin- istrative controls, and quality assurance. The discussion in the Attach- ments provides supplemental guidance on specific functional responsibilities, administrative controls, and quality assurance necessary to assure an effective fire protection program. The table below correlates each subject for which supplemental guidance is provided with the respective section(s)
    of Appendix A and Regulatory Guide 1.120.


If. Actions to be taken by Plant Superintendent and his staff, andSecurity Guards after notification of a fire.g. Actions to be taken that will coordinate fire fighting activitieswith offsite fire departments, including: identification ofindividual responsible for assessing situation and calling inoutside fire department assistance when needed; identificationof individual who will direct fire fighting activities whenaided by offsite fire fighting assistance; provisions forincluding offsite fire fighting organizations in fire brigadedrills at least once per year; and provisions for trainingoffsite fire department personnel in basic radiation principles,typical radiation hazards, and precautions to be taken in afire involving radioactive materials in the plant. The pro-cedures should also describe the offsite fire department'sresources and estimated response time by the offsite firedepartment to provide assistance to the station.
REGULATORY
    SUBJECT                        APPENDIX A                GUIDE 1.120
    1. Fire Protection              A.1, B, C                C.1, C.2, C.3 Organization
      2. Fire Brigade                A.l(d), B.5              C.1(4), C.2e Training
      3. Control of                 B.2, B.3(c)              C.2.b, C.2.c(3)
          Combustibles
      4. Control of Ignition        B.3(a)                    C.2.c(1)
          Sources
      5. Fire Fighting              A.l(d), B.1, 4, 5          C.la(4), (5),
          Procedures                                            C.2.a, d, e.


Attachment No. 6QUALITY ASSURANCEThe quality assurance (QA) program should assure that the requirementsfor design, procurement, installation, testing, and administrativecontrols for the fire protection program for safety related areasapproved by NRC are satisfied. The Quality Assurance provisions forfire protection should apply to activities performed after the effectivedate of the adoption of said provisions. The QA program should be underthe management control of the QA organization. This control consists of(1) formulating and/or verifying that the fire protection QA programincorporates suitable requirements and is acceptable to the managementresponsible for fire protection and (2) verifying the effectiveness ofthe QA program for fire protection through review, surveillance, arndaudits. Performance of other QA program functions for meeting the fireprotection program requirements may be performed by personnel outside ofthe QA organization. The QA program for fire protection should be partof the overall plant QA program. These QA criteria apply to those itemswithin the scope of the fire protection program, such as fire protectionsystems, emergency lighting, communication and emergency breathingapparatus as well as the fire protection requirements of applicablesafety related equipment.Applicants/licensees can meet the fire protection quality assurance (QA)program criteria of Appendix A to BTP 9.5-1 or Regulatdry Guide 1.120by either:1) implementing those fire protection QA criteria as part of their QAprogram under 10 CFR Part 50 Appendix B, where such a commitmentis made, it is not necessary to submit a detailed description of thefire protection QA program or its implementation for NRC review; or2) providing for NRC review a description of the fire protection QAprogram and the measures for implementing the program. Supplementalguidance is provided below on acceptable measures for implementingeach of the fire protection QA program criteria of Appendix A toBTP 9.5-1 or Regulatory Guide 1.120.1.0 Design Control and Procurement Document Control -Measures shouldbe established to assure that the applicable guidelines of theRegulatory Guide 1.120 or approved NRC alternatives are included indesign and procurement documents and that deviations therefrom arecontrolled. These measures should assure that:a. Design and procurement document changes, including field changesand design deviations are subject to the same level of controls,reviews, and approvals that were applicable to the originaldocument.
6. Quality Assurance           C.                       C.3


2b. Quality standards are specified in the design documents such asappropriate fire-protection codes and standards, and deviationsand changes from these quality standards are controlled.c. New designs and plant modifications, including fire protectionsystems, are reviewed by qualified personnel to assure inclusionof appropriate fire protection requirements. These reviewsshould include items such as:(1) Design reviews to verify adequacy of wiring isolation andcable separation criteria.(2) Design reviews to verify appropriate requirements for roomisolation (sealing penetrations, floors, and other firebarriers)..d. A review and concurrence of the adequacy of fire protectionrequirements and quality requirements stated in procurementdocuments are performed and documented by qualified personnel.This review should determine that fire protection requirementsand quality requirements are correctly stated, inspectable andcontrollable; there are adequate acceptance and rejectioncriteria; and-the procurement document has been prepared, re-viewed, ,nd approved in accordance with QA program requirements.2.0 Instructions, Procedures, and Drawing -Inspections, tests, admin-istrative controls, fire drills, and training that govern the fireprotection program should be prescribed by documented instructions,procedures or drawings and should be accomplished in accordancewith these documents. The following provisions should be included.a. Indoctrination and training programs for fire prevention andfire fighting are implemented in accordance with documentedprocedures.b. Activities such as design, installation, inspection, test,maintenance, and modification of fire protection systems areprescribed and accomplished in accordance with documented in-structions, procedures, and drawings.c. Instructions and procedures for design installation, inspec-tion, test, maintenance, modification and administrative controlsare reviewed to assure that proper inclusion of fire protectionrequirements, such as precautions, control of ignition sourcesand combustibles, provisions for backup fire protection of theactivity requires disabling a fire protection system, and re-striction on material substitution unless specifically permittedby design and confirmed by design review.I~iVF
I
3d. The installation or application of penetration seals and fireretardant coatings is performed by trained personnel usingapproved procedures.3.0 Control of Purchased Material, Equipment, and Services -Measuresshall be established to assure that purchased material, equipmentand services conform to the procurement documents. These measuresshould include:a. Provisions, as appropriate, for source evaluation and selection,objective evidence of quality furnished by the contractor,inspections at suppliers, or receiving inspections.b. Source or receiving inspection, as a minimum, for those itemswhose quality cannot be verified after installation.4.0 Inspection -A program for independent inspection of activitiesaffecting fire protection should be established and executed by, orfor, the organization performing the activity to verify conformances.o documented installation drawings and test procedures foraccomplishing activities. This program should include:a. Inspections of (1) installation, maintenance and modification offire protection systems; and (2) emergency lighting and communica-tion equipment to assure conformance to design and installationrequirements.b. Inspection of penetration seals and fire retardant coatinginstallations to verify the activity is satisfactorily completed.c. Inspections of cable routing to verify conformance with designrequirements.d. Inspections to verify that appropriate requirements for roomisolation (sealing penetrations, floors, and other fire barriers)are accomplished during construction.e. Measures to assure that inspection personnel are independent fromthe individuals performing the activity being inspected and areknowledgeable in the design and installation requirements for fireprotection.f. Inspection procedures, instructions, and check lists which providefor the following:(1) Identification of characteristics and activities to beinspected(2) Identification of the individuals or groups responsible forperforming the inspection operation(3) Acceptance and rejection criteria
                                    -2- This supplementary guidance is to be given to utilities and is being distributed to NRC fire protection program reviewers and NRC Office of Inspection and Enforcement.
4(4) A description of the method of inspection(5) Recording evidence of completing and verifying a manu-facturing, inspection or test operation(6) Recording inspector or data recorder and the results ofthe inspection operationg. Periodic inspections of fire protection systems, emergency breathingand auxiliary equipment, emergency lighting, and communication equip-ment to assure the acceptable condition of these items.i Periodic inspection of materials subject to degradation such as firestops, seals, and fire retardant coatings to assure these items havenot deteriorated or been damaged.5.0 Test and Test Control -A test program should be established andimplemented to ensure that testing is performed and verified byinspectioa and audit to demonstrate conformance with design andsystem readiness requirements. The tests should be performed inaccordance with written test procedures; test results should beproperly evaluated and acted on. The test program should includethe following: -a. Installation Testing -Following construction, modification, repairor replacement, sufficient testing is performed to demonstrate thatfire protection systems, emergency lighting and communication equip-ment will perform satisfactorily in service and that design criteriaare met. Written test procedures for installation tests incorporatethe requirements and acceptance limits contained in applicabledesign documents.b. Periodic testing -The schedules and methods for periodic testingare developed and documented. Fire protection equipment, emergencylighting, and communication equipment are tested periodically toassure that the equipment will properly function and continue tomeet the design criteria.c. Programs are established for QA/QC to verify testing of fireprotection systems and to verify that test personnel are effectivelytrained.d. Test results are documented, evaluated, and their acceptabilitydetermined by a qualified responsible individual or gro4p.6.0 Inspection, Test, and Operating Status -Measures should be establishedto provide for the identification of items that have satisfactorilypassed required tests and inspections. These measures should includeprovisions for:a. Identification by means of tags, labels, or similar temporarymarkings to indicate completion of required inspections andtests, and operating status.


57.0 Nonconforming Items -Measures should be established to control itemsthat do not conform to specified requirements to prevent inadvertentuse of installation. These measures should include provisions toassure that:a. Nonconforming, inoperative, or malfunctioning fire protectionsystems, emergency lighting, and communication equipment areappropriately tagged or labelled.b. The identification, documentation, segregation, review dis-position, and notification to the affected organization ofnonconforming materials, parts, components, or services areprocedurally controlled.c. Documentation identifies the nonconforming item, describes thenonconformance and the disposition of the nonconforming itemand includes signature approval of the disposition.d. Provisions are established identifying those individuals orgroups delegated the responsibility and authority for thedisposition and approval of nonconforming items.8.0 Corrective Action -Measures shall be established to ensure that con-ditions adverse to fire protection such as failures, malfunctions,deficiencies, deviations, defective components, uncontrolled combus-tible material and nonconformances are promptly identified, reportedand corrected. These measures should assure:a. Procedures are established for evaluation of conditions adverseto fire protection (such as nonconformance, failures, mal-functions, deficiencies, deviations, and defective materialand equipment) to determine the necessary corrective action.b. In the case of significant or repetitive conditions adverseto fire protection, including fire incidents, the cause ofthe conditions is determined and analyzed, and prompt correctiveactions are taken to preclude recurrence. The cause of thecondition and the corrective action taken are promptly reportedto cognizant leveis of management for review and assessment.9.0 Records -Records should be prepared and maintained to furnishevidence that the criteria enumerated above are being met foractivities affecting the fire protection program. The followingprovisions should be included:a. Records are identifiable and retrievable and should demonstrateconformance to fire protection requirements. The records should
The licensee should provide the description of fire protection functional responsibilities and administrative controls in a fire protection plan which describes his organization and its qualifications, fire brigade training, the controls over combustibles and ignition sources, methods for assuring the availability of the fire protection systems and equip- ment; procedures for fighting fires, fire watch, and quality assurance provisions for the fire protection program. The plan should also identify the plant procedures that implement the plan. The plan will be filed with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission and the plant procedures should be available to NRC Inspectors and at the plant site.
6include results of inspections, tests, reviews, and audits; non-conformance and corrective action reports; construction, maintenanceand modification records; and certified manufacturers' data.b. Record retention requirements are established.lo.0Audits -Audits should be conducted and documented to verify compliancewith the fire protection program, including design and procurementdocuments, instructions, procedures, and drawings, and inspection andtest activities. The following provisions should be included:a. Audits are periodically performed to verify compliance with theadministrative controls and implementation of quality assurancecriteria including design and procurement, instructions, proceduresand drawings and inspection and test activities. These audits areperformed by QA personnel in accordance with preestablished writtenprocedures or check lists and conducted by trained personnel nothaving direct responsibilities in the areas being audited.b. Audit results are documented and then reviewed with managementhaving responsibility in the area audited.c. Followup action is taken by responsible management to correct thedeficiencies revealed by the audit.d. Audits are annually performed to provide an overall assessmentof conformance to fire protection requirements.


}}
Attachment No. 1 FIRE PROTECTION ORGANIZATION
                                                            communication per-
1.0 The organizational responsibilities and lines of              the various be defined  between taining to fire protection should                          and    functional positions through the use of    organizational  charts responsibilities.      As  a  minimum the descriptions of each position's                                should    be positions/organizations responsible for the following designated:
                                                          which has management a. The upper level offsite management position                    and assess- responsibility for the formulation,    implementation, nuclear  plant  fire    protection ment of the effectiveness of the program.
 
responsible for b. The offsite management position(s) directly assessing the
        (1) formulating, implemenring, and periodically program    for the licensee's effectiveness of the fire protection drills    and    training con- nuclear power plant including fire plant  personnel.        The results ducted by the fire brigade and                                  level be reported    to  the    upper of these assessments should                                    with management position  responsible  for  fire  protection actions as recommendations for improvements or corrective deemed necessary.
 
guidance to dev-
          (2) Using the following NFPA Publications for elop the fire protection program:
                No. 4    -  "Organization for Fire Services"
                No. 4A  -  'Organization of a Fire Department"
                No. 6    -  "Industrial Fire Loss Prevention"
                No. 7    -  "Management of Fire Emergencies"
                No. 8    - "Management Responsibilities for Effects of Fire on Operations"
                No. 27    - "Private Fire Brigades"
                                                          for the overall c. The onsite management position responsible administration of the plant operations    and  emergency plans which include the fire protection    and  prevention  program and which control  and  contact    for all contingencies.
 
provides a single point    of
 
'-
                                    2 which:
d. The onsite position(s)
                                                  to: minimize the amount
  (1) implements periodic inspections                areas; determine the of combustibles in safety related      practices; assure the avail- effectiveness of housekeeping              of all fire protection ability and acceptable condition      breathing apparatus, emergency systems/equipment, emergency                  fire stops, penetration lighting, communication equipment, and assures prompt and seals and fire retardant        coatings;
                      corrective  actions    are taken to correct conditions effective                          and preclude their recurrence.
 
adverse to fire protection operating fire fighting training for
    (2) is responsible for the    the  plant's    fire  brigade;  design  and personnel  and plant                                      inspection and testing of selection of equipment; periodic                                with fire protection systems and  and equipment in accordance    and  deter- evaluate test results established procedures                systems under test.
 
mine the acceptability of the of all fire drills to determine
    (3) assists in the critiqueobjectives have been met.
 
how well the training identify proposed work activities to
    (4) reviews and evaluatesfire loads.
 
potential transient indoctrination of all plantpro-
    (5) implements a program for                        administrative contractor personnel in appropriatefire  protection  program, .
            cedures which implement the relative to fire protection.
 
and the emergency procedures on the for instruction of personnel
      (6) implements a programaccidental                            leaks  or events  such as proper handling of                    that are related to    fire spills of flammable materials protection.
 
for fire protection quality e. The onsite position responsible assurance.
 
for assuring the effective This position should be responsibleprotection program by planned in- of  the  fire implementation                            He should assure and verify spections and scheduled audits.            or audits are promptly re- that results of these inspections      personnel.
 
ported to cognizant management
 
3 f. The positions which are part of the plant fire brigade
        (1) The plant fire brigade positions should be responsible for fighting fires. The authority and responsibility of each fire brigade position relative to fire protection should be clearly defined.
 
(2) The responsibilities of each fire brigade position should correspond with the actions required by the fire fighting procedures.
 
(3) The responsibilities of the fire brigade members under normal plant conditions, should not conflict with their responsibilities during a fire emergency.
 
(4) The minimum number of trained fire brigade members avail- able onsite for each operating shift should be consistent with the activities required to combat the most significant fire. The size of 'tefire brigade should be based upon the functions required to fight fires with adequate allow- ance for injuries.
 
(5) The recommendations for organization, training, and equip- ment of "PRIVATE FIRE BRIGADES" as specified in NFPA
            No. 27-1975, including the applicable NFPA publications listed in the Appendix to NFPA No. 27, are considered appropriate criteria for organizing, training, and operating a plant fire brigade.
 
2.0 Qualifications a. The position responsible for formulation and implementation of the Fire Protection Program should have, within his organ- ization, or as a consultant, a Fire Protection Engineer who is a graduate of an engineering curriculum of accepted standing and who shall have completed not-less than six years of engineering attainment indicative of growth in engineering competency and achievement, three of which shall have been in responsible charge of fire protection engineering work. These requirements are the eligibility requirements as a Member in the Society of Fire Protection Engineers.
 
4 b. The fire brigade members qualifications should include satis- factory completion of a physical examination for performing strenuous activity, and of the fire brigade traininadescribed in Attachment No. 2.
 
c. The personnel responsible for the maintenance and testing of the Fire Protection Systems should be qualified by training and experience for such work.
 
d. The personnel responsible for the training of the fire brigade should be qualified by training and experience for such work.
 
ALs.'hment No. 2 FIRE BRIGADi TRAINING
                                                                      to fight potential assure that the capability The training program should                      The program    should  consist of an and maintained.                              classroom fires is established                    program followed by periodic initial classroom instruction fire fighting and fire drills:
retraining , practice in
1.0  Classroom Instruction instruction should include:
      a. The initial classroom types fire hazards and associated
          (1) Identification of the                  in the plant,    and an identi- of fires that could occur of such hazards.
 
fication of the      location equip- location of fire fighting
          (2) Identification of the                and familiarization    with layout ment for each fire area,                and egress routes  to-each of the plant including access area.
 
and use of  available    fire fighting equipment,
          (3)      The    proper                                                The each type of fire.
 
the correct method of fighting include electrical fires, types of fires covered should trays, hydrogen fires, flam- fires in cables and cable fires, and record file fires.
 
mable liquid, waste/debris fire fighting plan with
            (4)      Indoctrination of the plantindividual's responsibilities.
 
specific coverage of each lighting, ventilation
            (5) The proper use of communication, and emergency breathing equipment.
 
of the fire fighting
            (6)      The direction and coordination leaders only).
                      activities (fire brigade of expected products of
              (7)    The toxic characteristics combustion.
 
fighting fires inside buildings
              (8) The proper method for and tunnels.
 
procedures and procedure
              (9)    Detailed review of fire fighting changes.
 
and changes in fire
            (10)      Review of latest plant modifications fighting plans.
 
*;
                                              2 qualified individuals should be provided by                      in fighting b. The instruction experienced,            and suitably trained and in using knowledgeable,                  could occur in the plant the types of fires that available in the nuclear power plant.
 
the types of equipment                                                  Leaders
                              "Fire  Protection    Staff" and Fire Brigade Members of the may conduct this training.
 
brigade members should    be  provided to all fire c. Instruction and fire brigade leaders.
 
repeat planned  meetings    held every 3 months should year  period.
 
d. Regular                              program over a two the classroom instruction
2.0    Practice                                                                    on the should    be  held  for fire brigade members          mag- Practice sessions fighting    various  types of fires of similar  occur  in proper method      of                          as those which could and  difficulty                            brigade  members nitude, complexity,              These  session:    should provide          of em- a nuclear power      plant.                                      the  use fire extinguishment and with experience in actual            under strenuous conditions.
 
These but not ergency    breathing  apparatus                at  regular  intervals be  provided practice sessions should    each fire brigade member.
 
to exceed 1 year for that the
3.0 Drills in tne Plait%. -- .
          fire brigade drills should asbe aperformed team.    Drills  should include the fire brigade can practice following:
                                                                        required to notify of  fire  alarm  effectiveness, time                and use of a. Assessment                            and selection, placement and assembly fire brigade, equipment.
 
his role in the fire Assess  each  brigade    member's knowledge of    to contain the fire.
 
b.                          for  the area assumed strategy                                                    plant fighting the  brigade    members    conformance with established equipment, Assess                          and use of fire fighting fire fighting procedures emergency breathing apparatus, communi- including self-contained and  ventilation    equipment, to the extent cation equipment, practicable.
 
3 c. The simulated use of fire fighting equipment required to cope with the situation and type of fire selected for the drill.
 
The area and type of fire chosen for the drill should be varied such that brigade members are trained in fighting fires in all safety related areas containing significant fire hazards. The situation selected should simulate the size and arrangement of a fire which could reasonably occur in the area selected, allowing for fire development due to the time required to re- spond, to obtain equipment, and organize for the fire, assuming loss of automatic suppression capability.
 
d. Assessment of brigade leader's direction of the fire fighting effort, as to thoroughness, accuracy, and effectiveness.
 
e. The drills should be performed at regular intervals but not to exceed 3 months for each fire brigade. At least one drill per year should be performed on a "back shift" for each fire brigade. A sufficient number of these drills, not less than one for each fire brigade per year, shall be unannounced, to de- termine the fire readiness of the plant fire brigade leader, brigade, fire protection systems and equipment.
 
f. The drills should be pre-planned to establish the training objectives of the drill. The drills should be critiqued to determine how well the training objectives have been met.
 
Unannounced drills should have their critiques performed by members of the management staff responsible for plant safety and security. At three year intervals, drills should be critiqued by qualified individuals independent of the utility's staff.
 
4.0 Records
  , Records of training provided to each fire brigade member including drill critiques should be maintained to assure that each member receives training in all parts of the training program. These records of training should be available for review.
 
" Attachment No. 3 CONTROL OF CU;IBUSTIBLES
                                                            minimize the amount of controls    should be established to            to. These con- Administrative                    related area may be exposed combustibles    that  a  safety to govern:
trols should be established combustibles, limitation on the use of a. the handling of and              hazards such as    flammable  gases and and  explosive                                    exchange flammable                          filters, dry unused ion liquids, HEPA and charcoal supplies in safety related areas, resins or other combustible                                  safety related to  assure  that  these  items are not stored in and areas.
 
and modifications the  transient    fire  loads during maintenance        and plastic b.                                  flammable liquids, wood such as combustible and                                combustible mater- spilled  oil,  oil drums, and other systems or equip- products,                            safety related ials in buildings containingrequire an in-plant review of pro- ment. This control shouldidentify potential transient fire posed work activities to member designated the responsibility loads. The onsite staff                for potential transient fire for  reviewing    work  activities                    fire  protection required additional loads should specify the in the work activity procedure.
 
to transient    fire  load  causes the total fire load and When the                                                  systems of existing suppression exceed the capabilities                suppression  equipment    should additional    portable equipment, be brought into the area.
 
rags, oil spills, or the  removal  of  all  waste, debris, scrap,                    in the c.                                        from the work activity, other combustibles resulting    of the activity, or    at  the  end of area following completion is sooner.
 
each work shift, whichever for accumulation of combustibles.
 
d. periodic inspection that it wood  used  in  safety  related areas to assure e. all is treated with flame retardant.
 
Attachment No. 4 CONTROL OF IGNITION SOURCES
1.0 Administrative Controls Administrative controls should be instituted to protect safety- related equipment.from fire damage or loss resulting from work involving ignition sources, such as welding, cutting, grinding, or open flame work; administrative controls should prohibit the use of open flame or combustion smoke for leak testing and controls should prohibit smoking and other ignition sources in certain areas.
 
2.0 Control of Weldina, Cutting, Grinding, and Open Flame Work a.  Al' cutting, welding, grinding or open-flame work should oe authorized by the responsible foreman or supervisor through a work pernmiL. The responsible foreman or supervisor should have received a basic industrial fire fighting and fire prevention course covering anticipated fires, such as elec- trical fires, fires in cables and cable trays, hydrogen fires, hydrocarbon fires, solvent fires, waste/debris fires, and re- cord file fires.
 
b.    Before issuing the permit, the responsible foreman or super- visor should physically survey the area where the work is to be performed and establish that the following precautions have been accomplished:
          (1) All moveable combustible material below and within a 35 foot radius of the cutting, welding, grinding, or open flame work has been removed. (See NFPA 518)
          (2) All immovable combustible material below and within a 35 foot radius has been thoroughly protected by asbestos curtains, metal guards, or flameproof covers, and fire extinguishers, hose, or other firefighting equipment are provided at the work site. (See NFPA 518)
          (3) A fire watch trained and equipped to prevent and combat fires is present throughout any operations in which there is potential for fire Jtat mignt mfiff ge safety.
 
related equipment. A ire watcn s ou      be proided where cutting, welding, grinding or open flame is performed above or within a radius of 35 feet of any open cables, flammable liquids, scaffold boards, paper, rags, or other objects on the same elevation of the work or if combustible materials are below the work area where openings exist. A fire watch should be provided for all
 
"-I
                                    2 cutting, welding, grinding, and open flame work in the Control Room, Cable Spreading Room, Diesel Generator Rooms, and other safety related areas that contain sig- nificant amount of cable or flammable liquids. (See NFPA 51B)
              The fire watch sould remain on the work site while work is performed and remain in the area for at least 30 min- utes after the work is completed to check for smoldering fires.
 
(4) All equipment to be used is in a safe, working condition.
 
Oxyacetylene equipment is checked for leaks before being moved to the work area.
 
c. The signature concurrence of a member of the plant's management or a quality control inspector certified to make this concurrence should be obtained whenever the supervisor or foreman determines that a fire watch is not required.
 
3.0 Leak Testing Administrative procedures should be established to prohibit the use of open flame or combustion smoke for leak testing. Work orders for leak testing should require the concurrence of the shift engineer to verify that the leak test method is acceptable and would not present a potential ignition source.
 
4.0 Smoking and Ignition Source Restriction Smoking should be prohibited in safety related areas, except where
    "smoking permitted" areas have been specifically designated by a responsible member of plant management and in areas containing flammable or potentially explosive materials or atmospheres that present a hazard to safety related equipment. These areas should be identi- fied with "No Smoking" signs.
 
5 Attachment No.
 
.
                              FIRE FIGHTING PROCEDURES
                                                                            such items as should  be  established to cover coordination of fire fighting procedures                                          and of  a fire,  fire emergency procedures, notification activities with Of fire fighting procedureidentify_
  ing p                                                                          fire, such the to  be  taken  by individual discovering        extinguish    fire, a.    Actions                    control    room, attempt    to of as, notification                fire suppression systems.
 
and actuation of local                                                  the need by  the  control  room operator and          of taken                                        receipt b. Actions to beassistance upon report of a fire oras: announcing for brigade                                            such room annunciator panel,                          and alarm on control over PA system, sounding fire alarms                          of location of fire                                                      leader supervisor      and  the fire brigade notifying the shift location of the fire.
 
the type, size, and                                                            by by  the  fire  brigade after notification location    to c.    Actions to be taken                of a fire, including:
                the control    room  operator                          leader;    and responsi- given    by  fire brigade                    fighting assemble; directions members such as selection of fire bilities of brigade                                            selection of transportation      to fire location, systems operating equipment and                  use of fire suppression for fighting protective equipment,                          strategies use of preplanned instructions, and areas.
 
fires in specific in all safety- established      for fighting firesto safety-related d. The strategies and areas presenting a hazard                        should be related areas                    the following subjects equipment.      As  a minimum covered:
                                                                            plant zone covered of  combustibles in each
                  (1) Identification fire fighting procedures.
 
by the specific the fires suited for controlling
                  (2) Fire extinguishants best                        in that zone and with    the  combustible loadings associated                  of these extinguishants.
 
the nearest location a fire in direction    from which to attack            access
                    (3) Most favorable view of the ventilation direction, to be each  area,  in                                most  likely doors which are hallways, stairs andbest station or elevation for fighting fire-free, and the                                          shall designate identification system and system the fire.      A  specific doors, fire equipment in the fire all hallways, stairs,      and other items described control locations,                                                be used This  identification should fighting procedures.
 
2 plant items should in the procedures and the corresponding be recognized in be prominently marked so that they can            that involve dim light. All access and egress routes    identified    in the locked doors should be specifically                and  methods procedure with the appropriate      precautions for access specified.
 
should be managed to
  (4) Designation of plant systems that a local fire; location reduce the damage potential during management (e.g.,
        of local and remote-controls for such the zone covered systems    in any hydraulic or electrical                    that could by the specific fire fighting procedure of overpres- increase the hazards    in the  area  because surization or electrical hazards).
                                                  system components
  (5) Designation of vital heat-sensitive              a local fire.
 
that should be kept cool    while    fighting which  are  particularly    hazardous Critical equipment                                to  receive combustible sources  should  be  designated cooling.
 
and the assignment
  (6) Organization of fire fighting brigades    title  so that all fire of special duties according    to  job complete shift per- fighting functions are covered by any          include command sonnel complement. These duties should            applying the control of the brigade, fire hose      laying, support    supplies to extinguishant to the fire, advancing          control room, the fire scene, communication with the coordination with  outside  fire  departments.
 
toxic hazards in fire
  (7) Identification radiological and zones.
 
assures desired plant
    (8) Ventilation system operation that                    flow is pressure distribution when the ventilation    clearing  operations.
 
modified for fire containment or smoke and shift engineer
    (9) Operations requiring control room coordination or authorization.
 
and general plant per-
  (10) Instructions for plant operators sonnel during fire.
 
strategies should be tested by e. The validity of the preplanning check the logic of the appropriate full-dress drills to                personnel under- strategy, the adequacy of the equipment, problems.
 
standing, and to uncover unforeseen
 
I
                                                                        and Superintendent and his staff, f. Actions to be taken by Plant                a fire.
 
notification of Security Guards after activities to be  taken that  will coordinate fire fighting          of g. Actions                              including: identification in with offsite fire departments,  assessing situation    and calling individual responsible for                              identification assistance when needed;
    outside fire department            fire fighting  activities  when of individual who will direct assistance; provisions for aided by offsite fire fighting        organizations in fire brigade including offsite fire fighting and provisions for training year;
    drills at least once per                in basic radiation principles, department  personnel                            in a offsite fire                    and precautions to be taken typical  radiation  hazards,                                The pro- involving  radioactive    materials in the plant.
 
fire                              the offsite fire department's cedures should also describe response time by the offsite fire resources and estimated                to the station.
 
department to provide assistance
 
Attachment No. 6 QUALITY ASSURANCE
The quality assurance (QA) program should assure that the requirements for design, procurement, installation, testing, and administrative controls for the fire protection program for safety related areas approved by NRC are satisfied. The Quality Assurance provisions for fire protection should apply to activities performed after the effective date of the adoption of said provisions. The QA program should be under the management control of the QA organization. This control consists of
(1) formulating and/or verifying that the fire protection QA program incorporates suitable requirements and is acceptable to the management responsible for fire protection and (2) verifying the effectiveness of the QA program for fire protection through review, surveillance, arnd audits. Performance of other QA program functions for meeting the fire protection program requirements may be performed by personnel outside of the QA organization. The QA program for fire protection should be part of the overall plant QA program. These QA criteria apply to those items within the scope of the fire protection program, such as fire protection systems, emergency lighting, communication and emergency breathing apparatus as well as the fire protection requirements of applicable safety related equipment.
 
Applicants/licensees can meet the fire protection quality assurance (QA)
program criteria of Appendix A to BTP 9.5-1 or Regulatdry Guide 1.120
by either:
1) implementing those fire protection QA criteria as part of their QA
    program under 10 CFR Part 50 Appendix B, where such a commitment is made, it is not necessary to submit a detailed description of the fire protection QA program or its implementation for NRC review; or
2) providing for NRC review a description of the fire protection QA
    program and the measures for implementing the program. Supplemental guidance is provided below on acceptable measures for implementing each of the fire protection QA program criteria of Appendix A to BTP 9.5-1 or Regulatory Guide 1.120.
 
1.0  Design Control and Procurement Document Control - Measures should be established to assure that the applicable guidelines of the Regulatory Guide 1.120 or approved NRC alternatives are included in design and procurement documents and that deviations therefrom are controlled. These measures should assure that:
    a. Design and procurement document changes, including field changes and design deviations are subject to the same level of controls, reviews, and approvals that were applicable to the original document.
 
2 b. Quality standards are specified in the design documents such as appropriate fire-protection codes and standards, and deviations and changes from these quality standards are controlled.
 
c. New designs and plant modifications, including fire protection systems, are reviewed by qualified personnel to assure inclusion of appropriate fire protection requirements. These reviews should include items such as:
        (1) Design reviews to verify adequacy of wiring isolation and cable separation criteria.
 
(2) Design reviews to verify appropriate requirements for room isolation (sealing penetrations, floors, and other fire barriers)..
    d. A review and concurrence of the adequacy of fire protection requirements and quality requirements stated in procurement documents are performed and documented by qualified personnel.
 
This review should determine that fire protection requirements and quality requirements are correctly stated, inspectable and controllable; there are adequate acceptance and rejection criteria; and-the procurement document has been prepared, re- viewed, ,nd approved in accordance with QA program requirements.
 
2.0 Instructions, Procedures, and Drawing - Inspections, tests, admin- istrative controls, fire drills, and training that govern the fire protection program should be prescribed by documented instructions, procedures or drawings and should be accomplished in accordance with these documents. The following provisions should be included.
 
a. Indoctrination and training programs for fire prevention and fire fighting are implemented in accordance with documented procedures.
 
b. Activities such as design, installation, inspection, test, maintenance, and modification of fire protection systems are prescribed and accomplished in accordance with documented in- structions, procedures, and drawings.
 
c. Instructions and procedures for design installation, inspec- tion, test, maintenance, modification and administrative controls are reviewed to assure that proper inclusion of fire protection requirements, such as precautions, control of ignition sources and combustibles, provisions for backup fire protection of the activity requires disabling a fire protection system, and re- striction on material substitution unless specifically permitted  I
        by design and confirmed by design review.
 
~i VF
 
3 seals and fire d. The installation or application of penetration        personnel  using retardant coatings    is performed  by  trained approved procedures.
 
and Services - Measures
3.0  Control of Purchased Material, Equipment,              material, equipment shall be established to assure that purchased                These measures and services conform to the procurement      documents.
 
should include:
                                                      evaluation and selection, a. Provisions, as appropriate, for source by the contractor, objective evidence of quality furnished inspections at suppliers,  or  receiving    inspections.
 
a minimum, for those items b. Source or receiving inspection, as whose quality cannot be verified after installation.
 
of activities
4.0  Inspection - A program for independent inspectionand executed by, or affecting fire protection should be establishedto verify conformance for, the organization performing the activitytest procedures for s.o documented installation drawings and should include:
      accomplishing activities. This program and modification of a. Inspections of (1) installation, maintenancelighting and communica- fire protection systems; and (2) emergency    design and installation tion equipment to assure conformance to requirements.
 
retardant coating b.    Inspection of penetration seals and fire satisfactorily completed.
 
installations to verify the    activity  is with design c.    Inspections of cable routing to verify conformance requirements.
 
requirements for room d.    Inspections to verify that appropriate        and other fire barriers)
              isolation (sealing  penetrations,  floors, are accomplished during construction.
 
are independent from e.    Measures to assure that inspection personnel  being  inspected and are the individuals performing the    activity requirements for fire knowledgeable in the design and installation protection.
 
check lists which provide f.    Inspection procedures, instructions, and for the following:
                                                                activities to be
              (1) Identification of characteristics and inspected responsible for
              (2) Identification of the individuals or groups performing the inspection operation
              (3) Acceptance and rejection criteria
 
4 the method of inspection
          (4) A description of a manu- of completing and verifying
          (5) Recording evidence                test operation facturing, inspection or results of Recording  inspector    or data recorder and the
          (6)
                  the inspection operation emergency breathing inspections  of  fire protection systems, communication equip- g. Periodic                          emergency lighting, and and auxiliary equipment,              condition of these items.
 
ment to assure the acceptable degradation such as fire Periodic    inspection  of materials subject toto assure these items have i                                              coatings stops, seals, and fire retardant damaged.
 
not deteriorated or been established and and  Test  Control  -  A test program should be and verified by
5.0 Test                                testing is performed implemented to ensure that                                  with design and and audit  to  demonstrate conformance be performed in inspectioa                              The tests should system readiness requirements.procedures; test results should be test accordance with written acted on. The test program should include properly evaluated    and the following:      -
                                                                                        repair Testing    -  Following  construction, modification,          that demonstrate a.    Installation                      testing is performed to or replacement, sufficientemergency lighting and communication equip- fire protection systems,                  in service and that design criteria ment will    perform  satisfactorily                                  incorporate for installation tests are met. Written test procedureslimits contained in applicable the requirements and acceptance design documents.
 
for periodic testing The schedules and methods b. Periodic testing -                        Fire  protection equipment, emergency documented.                                            to are developed    and                equipment are tested periodically to lighting, and communication                                  and continue will properly function assure that the equipment meet the design criteria.
 
of fire for QA/QC to verify testing are effectively c. Programs are established            verify that  test  personnel protection systems and to trained.
 
are  documented,    evaluated, and their acceptability results                                                  gro4p.
 
d.    Test                              responsible individual or determined by a qualified should be established Operating Status - Measureshave satisfactorily
  6.0 Inspection, Test, and                        of items  that to provide for the identificationinspections.    These measures should include passed    required  tests  and provisions for:
                                                                                temporary of tags, labels, or similar a. Identification by means                    of required    inspections  and markings to indicate completion tests, and operating status.
 
5 to control items Nonconforming      Items  - Measures should be established      prevent  inadvertent
7.0                                                requirements to that do not conform to specified                  should include provisions to use of installation. These measures assure that:
                                                  or malfunctioning fire      protection a. Nonconforming, inoperative,                and  communication  equipment are systems, emergency lighting, labelled.
 
appropriately tagged or review dis- The    identification,      documentation, segregation,                  of b.                                        to the affected organization position, and notificationparts, components, or services are nonconforming materials, procedurally controlled.
 
describes the identifies    the nonconforming item, c. Documentation                                        of the nonconforming item nonconformance and the disposition          of the disposition.
 
and includes signature approval or are    established    identifying those individuals    the d. Provisions                                          and authority for groups delegated the responsibility of nonconforming items.
 
disposition and approval that con- Action  -  Measures    shall be established to ensure
  8.0 Corrective                                                            malfunctions, protection such as failures, ditions adverse to fire            defective components,      uncontrolled    combus- deficiencies,      deviations,                                                reported are promptly identified, tible material and nonconformances        should assure:
        and corrected. These measures adverse for evaluation of conditionsmal- a. Procedures are established            as nonconformance,      failures, to fire protection (such deviations, and defective material functions, deficiencies,              the necessary corrective action.
 
and equipment) to determine adverse or repetitive conditions b. In the case of significant                  fire incidents,    the  cause  of to  fire  protection,      including                                  corrective and analyzed, and prompt the conditions is determined                            The cause of the are  taken    to  preclude recurrence. are promptly reported actions                                action taken condition and the corrective                  for review and assessment.
 
to cognizant leveis of management to furnish be prepared and maintained
    9.0 Records - Records should enumerated above are being met for evidence that the criteria                                        The following affecting    the  fire protection program.
 
activities provisions should be included:
                                                                                    demonstrate and retrievable and should              should a. Records are identifiable                      requirements.    The  records conformance    to  fire  protection
 
6 include results of inspections, tests, reviews, and audits; non- conformance and corrective action reports; construction, maintenance and modification records; and certified manufacturers' data.
 
b.  Record retention requirements are established.
 
lo.0Audits - Audits should be conducted and documented to verify compliance with the fire protection program, including design and procurement documents, instructions, procedures, and drawings, and inspection and test activities. The following provisions should be included:
    a.  Audits are periodically performed to verify compliance with the administrative controls and implementation of quality assurance criteria including design and procurement, instructions, procedures and drawings and inspection and test activities. These audits are performed by QA personnel in accordance with preestablished written procedures or check lists and conducted by trained personnel not having direct responsibilities in the areas being audited.
 
b.  Audit results are documented and then reviewed with management having responsibility in the area audited.
 
c.  Followup action is taken by responsible management to correct the deficiencies revealed by the audit.
 
d.  Audits are annually performed to provide an overall assessment of conformance to fire protection requirements.}}


{{GL-Nav}}
{{GL-Nav}}

Latest revision as of 01:59, 24 November 2019

NRC Generic Letter 1977-002: Nuclear Plant Fire Protection Functional Responsibilites, Administrative Controls and Quality Assurance
ML031280293
Person / Time
Issue date: 08/04/1977
From: Reid R
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To: William Cahill
Consolidated Edison Co of New York
References
GL-77-002
Download: ML031280293 (23)


W

DISTRIBUTION:

August 4, 1977 Docket File (3 NRC PDR (3)

50-3 L PDR (3)

Dockets Nos.:

50-247 RReid and 50-286 RIngram PErickson TCarter TWambach Consolidated Edison Company Attorney, OELD

of New York, Inc.

OI&E (5)

ATTN: Mr. William 3. Cahill, Jr. DEisenhut Vice President TBAbernathy

4 Irving Place JRBuchanan New York, flew York 10003 ACRS (16)

Gray File (3)

Gentlemen:

RE: INDIAN POINT UNITS NOS. 1, 2. AND 3 We are enclosing for your infonaation and use a copy of

  • Nuclear Plant Fire Protection Functional Responsibilities, Administrative Controls and Quality Assurance.* This document is presently being used by the HRC as supplemental guidance for the review of the organizational and adfvninistrative aspects of the fire protection evaluation of your facility.

By letter dated July 15, 1977, you indicated your intention to develop no fire protection Technical Specifications for Indian Point Unit No. I because it was shutdown and defueled. Ie, there- fore, request that you propose fire protection Technical Specifi- cations for Indian Point Unit No. 1 appropriate to Its present shutdown defueled condition. A fire originating in Unit No. 1 could have serious consequences at the operating units because of their close proximity to Unit No. 1.

Sincerely, Robert W. Reid, Chief Operating Reactors Branch #4 Division of Operating Reactors Enclosures Nuclear Plant Fire Protection Functional Responsibilities, Administrative Controls f1'u 1 A

and Quality Assurance bpva~- jORB#4:DOMJORB#l ~~ >3T O

  • URNAMK.. Prickso m(?Wnbach~ ...--- --- *

.> OM318 qkR (9-76) XRCMv

8/i/0240~J

7 /k 781)T7_

  • U:9. OVxNMUKNT rpRtip.NO OFFICEZ___________I_____

1676-626424AT*j

Consolidated Edison Company of New York, Inc.

cc: Mrs. Kay Winter, Librarian Hendrick Hudson Free Library

31 Albany Post Road Montrose, New York 10548 Leonard M. Trosten, Esquire LeBoeuf, Lamb, Leiby & MacRae

1757 N Street, N. W.

Washington, D. C. 20036 Anthony Z. Roisman , Esquire Berlin Roisman & Kessler

1025 lAth Street, N.W., 5th Floor Washington, D. C. 20005 Paul S. Shemrin, Esq.

Assistant Attorney General State of New York Department of Law Two World Trade Center New York, New York 10047 Sarah Chasis, Esq.

Richard M. Hall, Esquire

15 West 44th Street New York, New York 10036 Director, Technical Development Programs State of New York Energy Office Agency Building 2 Empire State Plaza Albany, New York 12223 Admiral Paul Early (IP-3)

Power Authority of the State of New York

10 Columbus Circle New York, New York 10019

I *

~ . -

NUCLEAR PLANT FIRE PROTECTION FUNCTIONAL RESPONSIBILITIES, ADMINISTRATIVE

CONTROLS AND QUALITY ASSURANCE

The functional responsibilities, administrative controls, and quality assurance related to nuclear power plant fire protection programs have a significant role in preventing and fighting fires. Because these controls represent a significant portion of the licensee's fire protection program to and are subject to periodic reviews by NRC inspectors, it is necessary have a common understanding between applicant/licensees, NRC reviewers, and NRC inspectors as to what constitutes adequate delineation of respon- sibilities, administrative controls and quality assurance and how these responsibilities and activities should be conducted. Therefore, supple- mentary guidance on these controls is desirable.

Appendix A to Branch Technical Position 9.5-1 and Regulatory Guide 1.120

provide overall guidance related to functional responsibilities, admin- istrative controls, and quality assurance. The discussion in the Attach- ments provides supplemental guidance on specific functional responsibilities, administrative controls, and quality assurance necessary to assure an effective fire protection program. The table below correlates each subject for which supplemental guidance is provided with the respective section(s)

of Appendix A and Regulatory Guide 1.120.

REGULATORY

SUBJECT APPENDIX A GUIDE 1.120

1. Fire Protection A.1, B, C C.1, C.2, C.3 Organization

2. Fire Brigade A.l(d), B.5 C.1(4), C.2e Training

3. Control of B.2, B.3(c) C.2.b, C.2.c(3)

Combustibles

4. Control of Ignition B.3(a) C.2.c(1)

Sources

5. Fire Fighting A.l(d), B.1, 4, 5 C.la(4), (5),

Procedures C.2.a, d, e.

6. Quality Assurance C. C.3

I

-2- This supplementary guidance is to be given to utilities and is being distributed to NRC fire protection program reviewers and NRC Office of Inspection and Enforcement.

The licensee should provide the description of fire protection functional responsibilities and administrative controls in a fire protection plan which describes his organization and its qualifications, fire brigade training, the controls over combustibles and ignition sources, methods for assuring the availability of the fire protection systems and equip- ment; procedures for fighting fires, fire watch, and quality assurance provisions for the fire protection program. The plan should also identify the plant procedures that implement the plan. The plan will be filed with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission and the plant procedures should be available to NRC Inspectors and at the plant site.

Attachment No. 1 FIRE PROTECTION ORGANIZATION

communication per-

1.0 The organizational responsibilities and lines of the various be defined between taining to fire protection should and functional positions through the use of organizational charts responsibilities. As a minimum the descriptions of each position's should be positions/organizations responsible for the following designated:

which has management a. The upper level offsite management position and assess- responsibility for the formulation, implementation, nuclear plant fire protection ment of the effectiveness of the program.

responsible for b. The offsite management position(s) directly assessing the

(1) formulating, implemenring, and periodically program for the licensee's effectiveness of the fire protection drills and training con- nuclear power plant including fire plant personnel. The results ducted by the fire brigade and level be reported to the upper of these assessments should with management position responsible for fire protection actions as recommendations for improvements or corrective deemed necessary.

guidance to dev-

(2) Using the following NFPA Publications for elop the fire protection program:

No. 4 - "Organization for Fire Services"

No. 4A - 'Organization of a Fire Department"

No. 6 - "Industrial Fire Loss Prevention"

No. 7 - "Management of Fire Emergencies"

No. 8 - "Management Responsibilities for Effects of Fire on Operations"

No. 27 - "Private Fire Brigades"

for the overall c. The onsite management position responsible administration of the plant operations and emergency plans which include the fire protection and prevention program and which control and contact for all contingencies.

provides a single point of

'-

2 which:

d. The onsite position(s)

to: minimize the amount

(1) implements periodic inspections areas; determine the of combustibles in safety related practices; assure the avail- effectiveness of housekeeping of all fire protection ability and acceptable condition breathing apparatus, emergency systems/equipment, emergency fire stops, penetration lighting, communication equipment, and assures prompt and seals and fire retardant coatings;

corrective actions are taken to correct conditions effective and preclude their recurrence.

adverse to fire protection operating fire fighting training for

(2) is responsible for the the plant's fire brigade; design and personnel and plant inspection and testing of selection of equipment; periodic with fire protection systems and and equipment in accordance and deter- evaluate test results established procedures systems under test.

mine the acceptability of the of all fire drills to determine

(3) assists in the critiqueobjectives have been met.

how well the training identify proposed work activities to

(4) reviews and evaluatesfire loads.

potential transient indoctrination of all plantpro-

(5) implements a program for administrative contractor personnel in appropriatefire protection program, .

cedures which implement the relative to fire protection.

and the emergency procedures on the for instruction of personnel

(6) implements a programaccidental leaks or events such as proper handling of that are related to fire spills of flammable materials protection.

for fire protection quality e. The onsite position responsible assurance.

for assuring the effective This position should be responsibleprotection program by planned in- of the fire implementation He should assure and verify spections and scheduled audits. or audits are promptly re- that results of these inspections personnel.

ported to cognizant management

3 f. The positions which are part of the plant fire brigade

(1) The plant fire brigade positions should be responsible for fighting fires. The authority and responsibility of each fire brigade position relative to fire protection should be clearly defined.

(2) The responsibilities of each fire brigade position should correspond with the actions required by the fire fighting procedures.

(3) The responsibilities of the fire brigade members under normal plant conditions, should not conflict with their responsibilities during a fire emergency.

(4) The minimum number of trained fire brigade members avail- able onsite for each operating shift should be consistent with the activities required to combat the most significant fire. The size of 'tefire brigade should be based upon the functions required to fight fires with adequate allow- ance for injuries.

(5) The recommendations for organization, training, and equip- ment of "PRIVATE FIRE BRIGADES" as specified in NFPA

No. 27-1975, including the applicable NFPA publications listed in the Appendix to NFPA No. 27, are considered appropriate criteria for organizing, training, and operating a plant fire brigade.

2.0 Qualifications a. The position responsible for formulation and implementation of the Fire Protection Program should have, within his organ- ization, or as a consultant, a Fire Protection Engineer who is a graduate of an engineering curriculum of accepted standing and who shall have completed not-less than six years of engineering attainment indicative of growth in engineering competency and achievement, three of which shall have been in responsible charge of fire protection engineering work. These requirements are the eligibility requirements as a Member in the Society of Fire Protection Engineers.

4 b. The fire brigade members qualifications should include satis- factory completion of a physical examination for performing strenuous activity, and of the fire brigade traininadescribed in Attachment No. 2.

c. The personnel responsible for the maintenance and testing of the Fire Protection Systems should be qualified by training and experience for such work.

d. The personnel responsible for the training of the fire brigade should be qualified by training and experience for such work.

ALs.'hment No. 2 FIRE BRIGADi TRAINING

to fight potential assure that the capability The training program should The program should consist of an and maintained. classroom fires is established program followed by periodic initial classroom instruction fire fighting and fire drills:

retraining , practice in

1.0 Classroom Instruction instruction should include:

a. The initial classroom types fire hazards and associated

(1) Identification of the in the plant, and an identi- of fires that could occur of such hazards.

fication of the location equip- location of fire fighting

(2) Identification of the and familiarization with layout ment for each fire area, and egress routes to-each of the plant including access area.

and use of available fire fighting equipment,

(3) The proper The each type of fire.

the correct method of fighting include electrical fires, types of fires covered should trays, hydrogen fires, flam- fires in cables and cable fires, and record file fires.

mable liquid, waste/debris fire fighting plan with

(4) Indoctrination of the plantindividual's responsibilities.

specific coverage of each lighting, ventilation

(5) The proper use of communication, and emergency breathing equipment.

of the fire fighting

(6) The direction and coordination leaders only).

activities (fire brigade of expected products of

(7) The toxic characteristics combustion.

fighting fires inside buildings

(8) The proper method for and tunnels.

procedures and procedure

(9) Detailed review of fire fighting changes.

and changes in fire

(10) Review of latest plant modifications fighting plans.

2 qualified individuals should be provided by in fighting b. The instruction experienced, and suitably trained and in using knowledgeable, could occur in the plant the types of fires that available in the nuclear power plant.

the types of equipment Leaders

"Fire Protection Staff" and Fire Brigade Members of the may conduct this training.

brigade members should be provided to all fire c. Instruction and fire brigade leaders.

repeat planned meetings held every 3 months should year period.

d. Regular program over a two the classroom instruction

2.0 Practice on the should be held for fire brigade members mag- Practice sessions fighting various types of fires of similar occur in proper method of as those which could and difficulty brigade members nitude, complexity, These session: should provide of em- a nuclear power plant. the use fire extinguishment and with experience in actual under strenuous conditions.

These but not ergency breathing apparatus at regular intervals be provided practice sessions should each fire brigade member.

to exceed 1 year for that the

3.0 Drills in tne Plait%. -- .

fire brigade drills should asbe aperformed team. Drills should include the fire brigade can practice following:

required to notify of fire alarm effectiveness, time and use of a. Assessment and selection, placement and assembly fire brigade, equipment.

his role in the fire Assess each brigade member's knowledge of to contain the fire.

b. for the area assumed strategy plant fighting the brigade members conformance with established equipment, Assess and use of fire fighting fire fighting procedures emergency breathing apparatus, communi- including self-contained and ventilation equipment, to the extent cation equipment, practicable.

3 c. The simulated use of fire fighting equipment required to cope with the situation and type of fire selected for the drill.

The area and type of fire chosen for the drill should be varied such that brigade members are trained in fighting fires in all safety related areas containing significant fire hazards. The situation selected should simulate the size and arrangement of a fire which could reasonably occur in the area selected, allowing for fire development due to the time required to re- spond, to obtain equipment, and organize for the fire, assuming loss of automatic suppression capability.

d. Assessment of brigade leader's direction of the fire fighting effort, as to thoroughness, accuracy, and effectiveness.

e. The drills should be performed at regular intervals but not to exceed 3 months for each fire brigade. At least one drill per year should be performed on a "back shift" for each fire brigade. A sufficient number of these drills, not less than one for each fire brigade per year, shall be unannounced, to de- termine the fire readiness of the plant fire brigade leader, brigade, fire protection systems and equipment.

f. The drills should be pre-planned to establish the training objectives of the drill. The drills should be critiqued to determine how well the training objectives have been met.

Unannounced drills should have their critiques performed by members of the management staff responsible for plant safety and security. At three year intervals, drills should be critiqued by qualified individuals independent of the utility's staff.

4.0 Records

, Records of training provided to each fire brigade member including drill critiques should be maintained to assure that each member receives training in all parts of the training program. These records of training should be available for review.

" Attachment No. 3 CONTROL OF CU;IBUSTIBLES

minimize the amount of controls should be established to to. These con- Administrative related area may be exposed combustibles that a safety to govern:

trols should be established combustibles, limitation on the use of a. the handling of and hazards such as flammable gases and and explosive exchange flammable filters, dry unused ion liquids, HEPA and charcoal supplies in safety related areas, resins or other combustible safety related to assure that these items are not stored in and areas.

and modifications the transient fire loads during maintenance and plastic b. flammable liquids, wood such as combustible and combustible mater- spilled oil, oil drums, and other systems or equip- products, safety related ials in buildings containingrequire an in-plant review of pro- ment. This control shouldidentify potential transient fire posed work activities to member designated the responsibility loads. The onsite staff for potential transient fire for reviewing work activities fire protection required additional loads should specify the in the work activity procedure.

to transient fire load causes the total fire load and When the systems of existing suppression exceed the capabilities suppression equipment should additional portable equipment, be brought into the area.

rags, oil spills, or the removal of all waste, debris, scrap, in the c. from the work activity, other combustibles resulting of the activity, or at the end of area following completion is sooner.

each work shift, whichever for accumulation of combustibles.

d. periodic inspection that it wood used in safety related areas to assure e. all is treated with flame retardant.

Attachment No. 4 CONTROL OF IGNITION SOURCES

1.0 Administrative Controls Administrative controls should be instituted to protect safety- related equipment.from fire damage or loss resulting from work involving ignition sources, such as welding, cutting, grinding, or open flame work; administrative controls should prohibit the use of open flame or combustion smoke for leak testing and controls should prohibit smoking and other ignition sources in certain areas.

2.0 Control of Weldina, Cutting, Grinding, and Open Flame Work a. Al' cutting, welding, grinding or open-flame work should oe authorized by the responsible foreman or supervisor through a work pernmiL. The responsible foreman or supervisor should have received a basic industrial fire fighting and fire prevention course covering anticipated fires, such as elec- trical fires, fires in cables and cable trays, hydrogen fires, hydrocarbon fires, solvent fires, waste/debris fires, and re- cord file fires.

b. Before issuing the permit, the responsible foreman or super- visor should physically survey the area where the work is to be performed and establish that the following precautions have been accomplished:

(1) All moveable combustible material below and within a 35 foot radius of the cutting, welding, grinding, or open flame work has been removed. (See NFPA 518)

(2) All immovable combustible material below and within a 35 foot radius has been thoroughly protected by asbestos curtains, metal guards, or flameproof covers, and fire extinguishers, hose, or other firefighting equipment are provided at the work site. (See NFPA 518)

(3) A fire watch trained and equipped to prevent and combat fires is present throughout any operations in which there is potential for fire Jtat mignt mfiff ge safety.

related equipment. A ire watcn s ou be proided where cutting, welding, grinding or open flame is performed above or within a radius of 35 feet of any open cables, flammable liquids, scaffold boards, paper, rags, or other objects on the same elevation of the work or if combustible materials are below the work area where openings exist. A fire watch should be provided for all

"-I

2 cutting, welding, grinding, and open flame work in the Control Room, Cable Spreading Room, Diesel Generator Rooms, and other safety related areas that contain sig- nificant amount of cable or flammable liquids. (See NFPA 51B)

The fire watch sould remain on the work site while work is performed and remain in the area for at least 30 min- utes after the work is completed to check for smoldering fires.

(4) All equipment to be used is in a safe, working condition.

Oxyacetylene equipment is checked for leaks before being moved to the work area.

c. The signature concurrence of a member of the plant's management or a quality control inspector certified to make this concurrence should be obtained whenever the supervisor or foreman determines that a fire watch is not required.

3.0 Leak Testing Administrative procedures should be established to prohibit the use of open flame or combustion smoke for leak testing. Work orders for leak testing should require the concurrence of the shift engineer to verify that the leak test method is acceptable and would not present a potential ignition source.

4.0 Smoking and Ignition Source Restriction Smoking should be prohibited in safety related areas, except where

"smoking permitted" areas have been specifically designated by a responsible member of plant management and in areas containing flammable or potentially explosive materials or atmospheres that present a hazard to safety related equipment. These areas should be identi- fied with "No Smoking" signs.

5 Attachment No.

.

FIRE FIGHTING PROCEDURES

such items as should be established to cover coordination of fire fighting procedures and of a fire, fire emergency procedures, notification activities with Of fire fighting procedureidentify_

ing p fire, such the to be taken by individual discovering extinguish fire, a. Actions control room, attempt to of as, notification fire suppression systems.

and actuation of local the need by the control room operator and of taken receipt b. Actions to beassistance upon report of a fire oras: announcing for brigade such room annunciator panel, and alarm on control over PA system, sounding fire alarms of location of fire leader supervisor and the fire brigade notifying the shift location of the fire.

the type, size, and by by the fire brigade after notification location to c. Actions to be taken of a fire, including:

the control room operator leader; and responsi- given by fire brigade fighting assemble; directions members such as selection of fire bilities of brigade selection of transportation to fire location, systems operating equipment and use of fire suppression for fighting protective equipment, strategies use of preplanned instructions, and areas.

fires in specific in all safety- established for fighting firesto safety-related d. The strategies and areas presenting a hazard should be related areas the following subjects equipment. As a minimum covered:

plant zone covered of combustibles in each

(1) Identification fire fighting procedures.

by the specific the fires suited for controlling

(2) Fire extinguishants best in that zone and with the combustible loadings associated of these extinguishants.

the nearest location a fire in direction from which to attack access

(3) Most favorable view of the ventilation direction, to be each area, in most likely doors which are hallways, stairs andbest station or elevation for fighting fire-free, and the shall designate identification system and system the fire. A specific doors, fire equipment in the fire all hallways, stairs, and other items described control locations, be used This identification should fighting procedures.

2 plant items should in the procedures and the corresponding be recognized in be prominently marked so that they can that involve dim light. All access and egress routes identified in the locked doors should be specifically and methods procedure with the appropriate precautions for access specified.

should be managed to

(4) Designation of plant systems that a local fire; location reduce the damage potential during management (e.g.,

of local and remote-controls for such the zone covered systems in any hydraulic or electrical that could by the specific fire fighting procedure of overpres- increase the hazards in the area because surization or electrical hazards).

system components

(5) Designation of vital heat-sensitive a local fire.

that should be kept cool while fighting which are particularly hazardous Critical equipment to receive combustible sources should be designated cooling.

and the assignment

(6) Organization of fire fighting brigades title so that all fire of special duties according to job complete shift per- fighting functions are covered by any include command sonnel complement. These duties should applying the control of the brigade, fire hose laying, support supplies to extinguishant to the fire, advancing control room, the fire scene, communication with the coordination with outside fire departments.

toxic hazards in fire

(7) Identification radiological and zones.

assures desired plant

(8) Ventilation system operation that flow is pressure distribution when the ventilation clearing operations.

modified for fire containment or smoke and shift engineer

(9) Operations requiring control room coordination or authorization.

and general plant per-

(10) Instructions for plant operators sonnel during fire.

strategies should be tested by e. The validity of the preplanning check the logic of the appropriate full-dress drills to personnel under- strategy, the adequacy of the equipment, problems.

standing, and to uncover unforeseen

I

and Superintendent and his staff, f. Actions to be taken by Plant a fire.

notification of Security Guards after activities to be taken that will coordinate fire fighting of g. Actions including: identification in with offsite fire departments, assessing situation and calling individual responsible for identification assistance when needed;

outside fire department fire fighting activities when of individual who will direct assistance; provisions for aided by offsite fire fighting organizations in fire brigade including offsite fire fighting and provisions for training year;

drills at least once per in basic radiation principles, department personnel in a offsite fire and precautions to be taken typical radiation hazards, The pro- involving radioactive materials in the plant.

fire the offsite fire department's cedures should also describe response time by the offsite fire resources and estimated to the station.

department to provide assistance

Attachment No. 6 QUALITY ASSURANCE

The quality assurance (QA) program should assure that the requirements for design, procurement, installation, testing, and administrative controls for the fire protection program for safety related areas approved by NRC are satisfied. The Quality Assurance provisions for fire protection should apply to activities performed after the effective date of the adoption of said provisions. The QA program should be under the management control of the QA organization. This control consists of

(1) formulating and/or verifying that the fire protection QA program incorporates suitable requirements and is acceptable to the management responsible for fire protection and (2) verifying the effectiveness of the QA program for fire protection through review, surveillance, arnd audits. Performance of other QA program functions for meeting the fire protection program requirements may be performed by personnel outside of the QA organization. The QA program for fire protection should be part of the overall plant QA program. These QA criteria apply to those items within the scope of the fire protection program, such as fire protection systems, emergency lighting, communication and emergency breathing apparatus as well as the fire protection requirements of applicable safety related equipment.

Applicants/licensees can meet the fire protection quality assurance (QA)

program criteria of Appendix A to BTP 9.5-1 or Regulatdry Guide 1.120

by either:

1) implementing those fire protection QA criteria as part of their QA

program under 10 CFR Part 50 Appendix B, where such a commitment is made, it is not necessary to submit a detailed description of the fire protection QA program or its implementation for NRC review; or

2) providing for NRC review a description of the fire protection QA

program and the measures for implementing the program. Supplemental guidance is provided below on acceptable measures for implementing each of the fire protection QA program criteria of Appendix A to BTP 9.5-1 or Regulatory Guide 1.120.

1.0 Design Control and Procurement Document Control - Measures should be established to assure that the applicable guidelines of the Regulatory Guide 1.120 or approved NRC alternatives are included in design and procurement documents and that deviations therefrom are controlled. These measures should assure that:

a. Design and procurement document changes, including field changes and design deviations are subject to the same level of controls, reviews, and approvals that were applicable to the original document.

2 b. Quality standards are specified in the design documents such as appropriate fire-protection codes and standards, and deviations and changes from these quality standards are controlled.

c. New designs and plant modifications, including fire protection systems, are reviewed by qualified personnel to assure inclusion of appropriate fire protection requirements. These reviews should include items such as:

(1) Design reviews to verify adequacy of wiring isolation and cable separation criteria.

(2) Design reviews to verify appropriate requirements for room isolation (sealing penetrations, floors, and other fire barriers)..

d. A review and concurrence of the adequacy of fire protection requirements and quality requirements stated in procurement documents are performed and documented by qualified personnel.

This review should determine that fire protection requirements and quality requirements are correctly stated, inspectable and controllable; there are adequate acceptance and rejection criteria; and-the procurement document has been prepared, re- viewed, ,nd approved in accordance with QA program requirements.

2.0 Instructions, Procedures, and Drawing - Inspections, tests, admin- istrative controls, fire drills, and training that govern the fire protection program should be prescribed by documented instructions, procedures or drawings and should be accomplished in accordance with these documents. The following provisions should be included.

a. Indoctrination and training programs for fire prevention and fire fighting are implemented in accordance with documented procedures.

b. Activities such as design, installation, inspection, test, maintenance, and modification of fire protection systems are prescribed and accomplished in accordance with documented in- structions, procedures, and drawings.

c. Instructions and procedures for design installation, inspec- tion, test, maintenance, modification and administrative controls are reviewed to assure that proper inclusion of fire protection requirements, such as precautions, control of ignition sources and combustibles, provisions for backup fire protection of the activity requires disabling a fire protection system, and re- striction on material substitution unless specifically permitted I

by design and confirmed by design review.

~i VF

3 seals and fire d. The installation or application of penetration personnel using retardant coatings is performed by trained approved procedures.

and Services - Measures

3.0 Control of Purchased Material, Equipment, material, equipment shall be established to assure that purchased These measures and services conform to the procurement documents.

should include:

evaluation and selection, a. Provisions, as appropriate, for source by the contractor, objective evidence of quality furnished inspections at suppliers, or receiving inspections.

a minimum, for those items b. Source or receiving inspection, as whose quality cannot be verified after installation.

of activities

4.0 Inspection - A program for independent inspectionand executed by, or affecting fire protection should be establishedto verify conformance for, the organization performing the activitytest procedures for s.o documented installation drawings and should include:

accomplishing activities. This program and modification of a. Inspections of (1) installation, maintenancelighting and communica- fire protection systems; and (2) emergency design and installation tion equipment to assure conformance to requirements.

retardant coating b. Inspection of penetration seals and fire satisfactorily completed.

installations to verify the activity is with design c. Inspections of cable routing to verify conformance requirements.

requirements for room d. Inspections to verify that appropriate and other fire barriers)

isolation (sealing penetrations, floors, are accomplished during construction.

are independent from e. Measures to assure that inspection personnel being inspected and are the individuals performing the activity requirements for fire knowledgeable in the design and installation protection.

check lists which provide f. Inspection procedures, instructions, and for the following:

activities to be

(1) Identification of characteristics and inspected responsible for

(2) Identification of the individuals or groups performing the inspection operation

(3) Acceptance and rejection criteria

4 the method of inspection

(4) A description of a manu- of completing and verifying

(5) Recording evidence test operation facturing, inspection or results of Recording inspector or data recorder and the

(6)

the inspection operation emergency breathing inspections of fire protection systems, communication equip- g. Periodic emergency lighting, and and auxiliary equipment, condition of these items.

ment to assure the acceptable degradation such as fire Periodic inspection of materials subject toto assure these items have i coatings stops, seals, and fire retardant damaged.

not deteriorated or been established and and Test Control - A test program should be and verified by

5.0 Test testing is performed implemented to ensure that with design and and audit to demonstrate conformance be performed in inspectioa The tests should system readiness requirements.procedures; test results should be test accordance with written acted on. The test program should include properly evaluated and the following: -

repair Testing - Following construction, modification, that demonstrate a. Installation testing is performed to or replacement, sufficientemergency lighting and communication equip- fire protection systems, in service and that design criteria ment will perform satisfactorily incorporate for installation tests are met. Written test procedureslimits contained in applicable the requirements and acceptance design documents.

for periodic testing The schedules and methods b. Periodic testing - Fire protection equipment, emergency documented. to are developed and equipment are tested periodically to lighting, and communication and continue will properly function assure that the equipment meet the design criteria.

of fire for QA/QC to verify testing are effectively c. Programs are established verify that test personnel protection systems and to trained.

are documented, evaluated, and their acceptability results gro4p.

d. Test responsible individual or determined by a qualified should be established Operating Status - Measureshave satisfactorily

6.0 Inspection, Test, and of items that to provide for the identificationinspections. These measures should include passed required tests and provisions for:

temporary of tags, labels, or similar a. Identification by means of required inspections and markings to indicate completion tests, and operating status.

5 to control items Nonconforming Items - Measures should be established prevent inadvertent

7.0 requirements to that do not conform to specified should include provisions to use of installation. These measures assure that:

or malfunctioning fire protection a. Nonconforming, inoperative, and communication equipment are systems, emergency lighting, labelled.

appropriately tagged or review dis- The identification, documentation, segregation, of b. to the affected organization position, and notificationparts, components, or services are nonconforming materials, procedurally controlled.

describes the identifies the nonconforming item, c. Documentation of the nonconforming item nonconformance and the disposition of the disposition.

and includes signature approval or are established identifying those individuals the d. Provisions and authority for groups delegated the responsibility of nonconforming items.

disposition and approval that con- Action - Measures shall be established to ensure

8.0 Corrective malfunctions, protection such as failures, ditions adverse to fire defective components, uncontrolled combus- deficiencies, deviations, reported are promptly identified, tible material and nonconformances should assure:

and corrected. These measures adverse for evaluation of conditionsmal- a. Procedures are established as nonconformance, failures, to fire protection (such deviations, and defective material functions, deficiencies, the necessary corrective action.

and equipment) to determine adverse or repetitive conditions b. In the case of significant fire incidents, the cause of to fire protection, including corrective and analyzed, and prompt the conditions is determined The cause of the are taken to preclude recurrence. are promptly reported actions action taken condition and the corrective for review and assessment.

to cognizant leveis of management to furnish be prepared and maintained

9.0 Records - Records should enumerated above are being met for evidence that the criteria The following affecting the fire protection program.

activities provisions should be included:

demonstrate and retrievable and should should a. Records are identifiable requirements. The records conformance to fire protection

6 include results of inspections, tests, reviews, and audits; non- conformance and corrective action reports; construction, maintenance and modification records; and certified manufacturers' data.

b. Record retention requirements are established.

lo.0Audits - Audits should be conducted and documented to verify compliance with the fire protection program, including design and procurement documents, instructions, procedures, and drawings, and inspection and test activities. The following provisions should be included:

a. Audits are periodically performed to verify compliance with the administrative controls and implementation of quality assurance criteria including design and procurement, instructions, procedures and drawings and inspection and test activities. These audits are performed by QA personnel in accordance with preestablished written procedures or check lists and conducted by trained personnel not having direct responsibilities in the areas being audited.

b. Audit results are documented and then reviewed with management having responsibility in the area audited.

c. Followup action is taken by responsible management to correct the deficiencies revealed by the audit.

d. Audits are annually performed to provide an overall assessment of conformance to fire protection requirements.

Template:GL-Nav