ML21124A031

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Summary of the Environmental Site Audit Related to the Review of the Subsequent License Renewal Application (EPID Number: L-2020-SLE-0002)
ML21124A031
Person / Time
Site: Point Beach  NextEra Energy icon.png
Issue date: 05/11/2021
From: Phyllis Clark
NRC/NMSS/DREFS/ELRB
To: Strope M
Point Beach
Clark, P.M, NMSS/REFS/ELRB, 301-415-6447
References
EPID L-2020-SLE-0002
Download: ML21124A031 (8)


Text

May 11, 2021 Mr. Michael Strope NextEra Energy Point Beach, LLC 6610 Nuclear Road Two Rivers, WI 54241

SUBJECT:

POINT BEACH NUCLEAR PLANT, UNIT NOS. 1 AND 2 -

SUMMARY

OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL REMOTE AUDIT RELATED TO THE REVIEW OF THE SUBSEQUENT LICENSE RENEWAL APPLICATION (EPID NUMBER: L-2020-SLE-0002)

A review team consisting of staff from the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC or the staff) participated in a remote audit during the week April 5, 2021, for Point Beach Nuclear Plant, Unit Nos. 1 and 2 (Point Beach), as part of the subsequent license renewal application environmental review. The goal of the audit was to gather information to ensure that the environmental requirements for subsequent license renewal, as codified in Title 10 of the Code of Federal Regulations Part 51, were met. A letter dated November 19, 2020 (Agencywide Documents Access and Management System (ADAMS) Accession No. ML21070A207) was sent containing an audit plan.

An entrance meeting was held on March 5, 2021, to introduce participants and discuss audit logistics. During the remainder of the site audit, the NRC staff participated in smaller groups (breakout sessions) with NextEra Energy Point Beach, LLC (NextEra) representatives to address the audit needs identified in the audit plan. The enclosure to this letter provides a list of representatives from the NRC and NextEra who participated in the audit.

At the conclusion of the audit, the NRC staff summarized the status of the review with NextEra representatives during the exit meeting. Many of the NRCs questions identified in the audit plan or during the audit were answered through the conduct of the audit. Those that were answered but would be needed to be used in the site-specific Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement will be submitted (a) as supplement to the application, (b) as responses to requests for additional information (RAI), or (c) as responses to requests for confirmation of information. Below is the list of the supplemental items that will be provided by the applicant:

1. Table 3.3-12 PBN Annual Emissions Calculator Results, 2014 - 2019
2. Circulating Water Plans and Sections Intake Well Drawing (File No. 68251, Microfilm No. 019613, Revision No. 11 03-03-14)
3. Point Beach Intake Crib Drawing (File No. PB00509, Microfilm No. PB00509, Revision No. 5 09-03-20)
4. Application for Reissuance of Wisconsin Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (WPDES) Permit Number WI-0000957-08 (December 18, 2020)
5. Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) Voluntary Protection Programs (VPP) Compressed Reapproval Process (CRP) Evaluation Report (September 2019)
6. OSHA Letter to NEPB dated March 4, 2020

M. Strope 7. 2020 Water Withdrawal Report

8. Wisconsin Department of Administration Letter to NextEra Energy, Inc. dated March 26, 2021, Wisconsin Coastal Management Program: Point Beach Consultation
9. Wetland Delineation Report, NextEra Energy Point Beach Energy Center Wetland Delineation, Manitowoc County, Wisconsin (September 18, 2020)
10. Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (WDNR) Form 3300-77A Well Construction Report, Wisconsin Unique Well Number YG332 (September 13, 2011)
11. Impingement Mortality and Entrainment Characterization Study, Point Beach Nuclear Plant (August 2007)
12. NEPB Letter NPL 2018-0008 to WDNR dated January 23, 2018, Review of Source Waterbody Status and Entrainment Characterization Study Report
13. Updated Site Conceptual Model, NextEra Energy Resources, LLC, Point Beach Nuclear Plant (January 2017)

While the NRC staff did not identify any significant environmental issues during this audit, the staff indicated that the environmental review was ongoing and that any additional information necessary to support the review would be formally requested via the RAI process, during the course of the review. Persons who do not have access to ADAMS or who encounter problems in accessing the documents located in ADAMS should contact the NRC's Public Document Room staff at 800-397-4209 (or 301-415-4737) or via e-mail at pdr.resource@nrc.gov.

If you have any questions, please contact me via e-mail at Phyllis.Clark@nrc.gov.

Sincerely,

/RA/

Phyllis M. Clark, Project Manager Environmental Review License Renewal Branch Division of Rulemaking, Environmental, and Financial Support Office of Nuclear Material Safety and Safeguards Docket Nos. 50-266 and 50-301

Enclosure:

List of Participants cc: Listserv

M. Strope

SUBJECT:

POINT BEACH NUCLEAR PLANT, UNIT NOS. 1 AND 2 -

SUMMARY

OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL SITE AUDIT RELATED TO THE REVIEW OF THE SUBSEQUENT LICENSE RENEWAL APPLICATION (EPID NUMBER: L-2020-SLE-0002)

DATE: May 11, 2021 Distribution:

PUBLIC Listserv RidsNrrPMPointBeach Resource NMSS_REFS_ELRB Distribution PClark, NMSS/REFS JWachutka, OGC SImboden, NMSS/REFS TJones, OGC PDoub, NMSS/REFS SBurnell, HQ OPA DBarnhurst, NMSS/REFS DMcIntyre, HQ OPA DPalmrose, NMSS/REFS VMitlyng, RIII OPA RElliott, NMSS/REFS PChandrathil, RIII OPA BRogers, NRR/DNRL ABarker, RIII RGLO LGibson, NRR/DNRL HLogaras, RIII RGLS JDozier, NRR/DRA KMorgan-Butler, EDO-NMSS WRautzen, NRR/DRA DAdams, OCA RHaskell, NRR/DORL CWolf, OCA NSalgado, NRR/DORL THartman, RIII/SRI William.Maher@fpl.com VPetrella, RIII/RI Steve.Franzone@fpl.com MYoung, OGC Richard.Orthen@fpl.com See Next Page for Additional Distribution ADAMS Accession No.: ML21124A031 *concurred via email OFFICE PM:ERLRB:REFS LA:REFS BC:ERLRB:REFS PM:ERLRB:REFS NAME PClark* AWalker-Smith* RElliott PClark DATE 05/03/2021 05/04/2021 05/0/2021 05/11 /2021 OFFICE RECORD COPY

DISTRIBUTION (additional names):

adanto@jps.net elizabeth.ward@sierraclub.org adavie110@yahoo.com envfish@gmail.com agpgbgdg@gmail.com eric.newgent@prevea.com ajrags04@gmail.com fullercogm@gmail.com alfred.c.meyer@gmail.com gawd0@yahoo.com amysails61@gmail.com gbuckley@two-rivers.org andrewbenson93@gmail.com Gizmoschlies@gmail.com anglersplus@yahoo.com gleannah57@yahoo.com annin7777@gmail.com globalbeatnik@yahoo.com a-rogers@charter.net greenwoodsart@msn.com atbehrma@wisc.edu guerillawordfare@yahoo.com avery10man@gmail.com hamtrilogy@gmail.com barryrcramer@gmail.com hartjes@tds.net bflanagan54@gmail.com helgaleenas@yahoo.com bmehor@lsol.net info@psrwisconsin.org bmrj.harvey@gmail.com Jamesbarbeau1989@yahoo.com bosolds@lisco.com janboudart1@gmail.com briankopetsky22@outlook.com japple51@gmail.com bruhgerr@isu.edu jeanne184490@gmail.com bud.rhoden@gmail.com jimbol1@sbcglobal.net budsielaff@sbcglobal.net jodyslocum@gmail.com campcowboy@hotmail.com joemeyer@amerytel.net cdrjack@outlook.com johnko929@sbcglobal.net charlannef@gmail.com jokawi@gmail.com charlesrobertcarpenter@gmail.com joy2me4you@yahoo.com christalone@charter.net jyarbro2003@yahoo.com cmgerva@gmail.com k.hasselman@yahoo.com cuzzinhuey@yahoo.com kcwaak@gmail.com danbuttry@gmail.com kdraska@new.rr.com david.c.schwab@gmail.com kevin@beyondnuclear.org dawnw3296@yahoo.com kevinjkoenig8@gmail.com dbldis4me@gmail.com kevinofthelake@yahoo.com dbruechert@gmail.com kidvillebill@gmail.com dcgehrkegb@gmail.com kinetic.ki.bill@gmail.com deannelorene@comcast.net kristinwomack@yahoo.com dennisboyer1949@gmail.com Ladhanka@yahoo.com dgreenwood8118@gmail.com lartro3l@gmail.com dhg5746@gmail.com lienaume@wwt.net dkevers@charter.net linco64@outlook.com dschaber@athenet.net Ljeffery101@yahoo.com dschaber@athenet.net m.mk@juno.com dsheley@tm.net markloup@earthlink.net dshifdy@aol.com markmuhich0@gmail.com duboislj@gmail.com mcge.nettie@gmail.com duckling@uwalumni.com mealsvig@gmail.com earthsayge@yahoo.com merciert@hotmail.com ecoguy2@netzero.net mimbck@yahoo.com eleanor@dwightcentral.com msbit@charter.net eleclair@yahoo.com neis@neis.org

noheaecs@gmail.com earlmeshigaud@hannahville.org nubits2@hotmail.com marlon.whiteeagle@ho-chunk.com nukewatch1@lakeland.ws Bquackenbush@ho-chunk.com owensjoh@gmail.com louis.taylor@lco-nsn.gov pamrichard35@gmail.com brian.bisonette@lco-nsn.gov patrickm@lsol.net jwildcatsr@ldftribe.com patrushkadarling@aol.com ldfthpo@ldftribe.com pennybernardschaber@athenet.net tribalchair@ltbbodawa-nsn.gov rcarbino@wisc.edu MWiatrolik@LTBBODAWA-NSN.GOV rconnour@hfmhealth.org Bob.Peters@glt-nsn.gov rderuyter@frontier.com mbpi_thpo@glt-nsn.gov recubejim@yahoo.com chairman@mitw.org reed.hardy@gmail.com dgrignon@mitw.org Rep.Sortwell@legis.wisconsin.gov dlankford@miamination.com rivethyl1@gmail.com dhunter@miamination.com robert@slaughterfreechicago.com jstuck@nhbpi.com robotengineer@msn.com Douglas.Taylor@nhbpi.com rodscheuer@charter.net thill7@oneidanation.org roggepann@gmail.com sdanfor3@oneidanation.org rousu@frontier.com cethel.oto@gmail.com sally.lq1@gmail.com rhonda.oto@gmail.com saschellin@gmail.com matthew.wesaw@pokagonband-nsn.gov satyavayu@gmail.com matthew.bussler@pokagonband-nsn.gov scottawillems@yahoo.com cosettewahwassuck@pbpnation.org sdkrause429@gmail.com thomaswabmum@pbpnation.org shahlawerner@yahoo.com Richard.Peterson@redcliff-nsn.gov sidingwen@yahoo.com marvin.defoe@redcliff-nsn.gov Singinghorse40@hotmail.com robert.vanzile@scc-nsn.gov skazz999W@hotmail.com adam.vanzile@scc-nsn.gov skent@kentcom.com susanl@stcroixtribalcenter.com sndrcch@yahoo.com wandam@stcroixojibwe-nsn.gov Sommerraen@gmail.com shannon.holsey@mohican-nsn.gov sst-horton@hotmail.com nathan.allison@mohican-nsn.gov sunlightrising@gmail.com tori.kitcheyan@winnebagotribe.com susan@hitoshapirolaw.com sunshie.bear@winnebagotribe.com tdiegel@milwpc.com tfwebs@msn.com tjjessessky@gmail.com Totogaticlake@gmail.com w_jensen@att.net warrenba@msn.com ziibiisanlittlerivers@yahoo.com MikeW@badriver-nsn.gov THPO@badriver-nsn.gov rbarrett@potawatomi.org kelli.mosteller@potawatomi.org Ned.DanielsJr@fcpotawatomi-nsn.gov Michael.LaRonge@FCPotawatomi-nsn.gov andy.werk@ftbelknap.org mblackwolf@ftbelknap.org tyderyien@hannahville.org

LIST OF PARTICIPANTS POINT BEACH NUCLEAR PLANT, UNIT NOS. 1 AND 2 SUBSEQUENT LICENSE RENEWAL APPLICATION REVIEW ENVIRONMENTAL IN-OFFICE AUDIT April 5-8, 2021 The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) environmental audit team members and their assignments are shown in the table below.

NRC Discipline Team Members Environmental Review Supervisor Robert Elliott, NRC/NMSS Environmental Project Manager Phyllis Clark, NRC/NMSS Replacement Power Alternatives Robert Hoffman, NRC/NMSS Caroline Hsu, NRC/NMSS Land Use and Visual Resources Peyton Doub, NRC/NMSS Meteorology, Air Quality, and Noise Nancy Martinez, NRC/NMSS Geologic Environment Kevin Folk, NRC/NMSS Daniel Barnhurst, NRC/NMSS Water Resource - Groundwater Lifeng Guo, NRC/NMSS Kevin Folk, NRC/NMSS Water Resource - Surface Water Nancy Martinez, NRC/NMSS Caroline Hsu, NRC/NMSS Terrestrial Resource Peyton Doub, NRC/NMSS Aquatic Resource Briana Grange, NRC/NMSS Section 7 Consultation with FWS Briana Grange, NRC/NMSS Section 7 Consultation with NMFS for ESA and Briana Grange, NRC/NMSS EFH Historic and Cultural Resources (Section 106 Nancy Martinez, NRC/NMSS Consultation) Robert Hoffman, NRC/NMSS Socioeconomics Jeffrey Rikhoff, NRC/NMSS Human Health Donald Palmrose, NRC/NMSS Microbiological Hazards Donald Palmrose, NRC/NMSS Phyllis Clark, NRC/NMSS Postulated Accidents Jerry Dozier, NRR/DRA Environmental Justice Jeffrey Rikhoff, NRC/NMSS Waste Management Phyllis Clark, NRC/NMSS Spent Nuclear Fuel Phyllis Clark, NRC/NMSS Fuel Cycle Phyllis Clark, NRC/NMSS Terminating Power Plant Operations and Kevin Folk, NRC/NMSS Decommissioning Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Climate Nancy Martinez, NRC/NMSS Change Kevin Folk, NRC/NMSS Cumulative Impacts Robert Hoffman, NRC/NMSS Severe Accident Mitigation Alternatives Jerry Dozier, NRC/NRR Enclosure

NextEra Energy Point Beach, LLC (NextEra)

Discipline Team Members PBN - SAMA Mahmoud Heiba, Bill Maher, Rick Orthen, Brenda Scherwinski, Anil Julka PBN - Human Health and Microbial Hazards Sophia Bartels, Andrew Watry, Brenda Scherwinski, Bill Maher, Rick Orthen, Bob Wolfe, Jim McGough PBN - Historic and Cultural Resources Richard Estabrook, Sophia Bartels, Andrew Watry, Brenda Scherwinski, Rick Orthen, Bill Maher, Ron Burris PBN - Air Quality & Noise Sophia Bartels, Andrew Watry, Brenda Scherwinski, Sara Dussich, Bill Maher, Rick Orthen PBN - Surface Water Sophia Bartels, Andrew Watry, Brenda Scherwinski, Sara Dussich, Bill Maher, Rick Orthen, Jason Wiesner PBN - Alternatives and Cumulative Impacts Sophia Bartels, Andrew Watry, Brenda Scherwinski, Sara Dussich, Bill Maher, Rick Orthen PBN - Land Use and Visual Resources Sophia Bartels, Andrew Watry, David Gil, Brenda Scherwinski, Sara Dussich, Bill Maher, Rick Orthen PBN - Groundwater Resources Sophia Bartels, Brenda Scherwinski, Rick Orthen, Trevor Petermann PBN - Waste Management Gene Leclair Sophia Bartels, Brenda Scherwinski, Rick Orthen, Ron Olson, Jason Wiesner PBN - Ecology (Terrestrial, Aquatic, Special Sophia Bartels, Brenda Scherwinski, Rick Status Species & Habitats) Orthen, Jason Wiesner, Hannah Marsico PBN - SLR Licensing Manager Steve Franzone PBN - SLR Licensing Director Bill Maher PBN - SLR Environmental Licensing Lead Rick Orthen PBN Contractor Support - ENERCON Discipline Team Members PBN - SAMA Neil Johnson, Tom Slavonic, Rachel Turney-Work, Brandon Wesbury, Rick Anoba, James Wicks PBN - Human Health and Microbial Hazards Tom Slavonic, Rachel Turney-Work, Mary Hoganson, Brandon Wesbury PBN - Historic and Cultural Resources Gary Eddington, Kim Stapleton, Tom Slavonic, Rachel Turney-Work, Brandon Wesbury PBN - Air Quality & Noise Jerry Riggs, Anu Gaur, Tom Slavonic, Rachel Turney-Work, Brandon Wesbury, James Wicks PBN - Surface Water Stacy Burgess, Tom Slavonic, Rachel Turney-Work, Brandon Wesbury, James Wicks, Anu Gaur PBN - Alternatives and Cumulative Impacts Kim Stapleton, Mary Hoganson, Tom Slavonic, Rachel Turney-Work, Brandon Wesbury, Fred Woolridge, James Wicks PBN - Land Use and Visual Resources Kim Stapleton, Fred Woolridge, Erica McLamb, Tom Slavonic, Rachel Turney-Work, Brandon Wesbury PBN - Groundwater Resources Stacy Burgess, Tom Slavonic, Rachel Turney-Work, Brandon Wesbury, James Wicks PBN - Waste Management Stacy Burgess, Fred Woolridge, Mary Hoganson, Tom Slavonic, Rachel Turney-Work, Brandon Wesbury PBN - Ecology (Terrestrial, Aquatic, Special Erica McLamb, Tom Slavonic, Rachel Status Species & Habitats) Turney-Work, Brandon Wesbury