ML20150D406

Final Response to FOIA Requests for Documents,Including 831105 Independent Assessment Program for Plant, Final Rept.Encl App a Documents Maintained Among PDR Files.App B Documents Totally Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 5)

ML20150D406
Person / Time
Site:	Comanche Peak
Issue date:	03/21/1988
From:	Grimsley D NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION & RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (ARM)
To:	Connor L DOC-SEARCH ASSOCIATES
References
FOIA-87-845, FOIA-88-58 NUDOCS 8803240175
Download: ML20150D406 (4)

Text

U S. NUCLE AR REGULATORY COMMISSION wc 50 a aim.i s t %. vet a < >

/ ~.w s.e FcrI A-F7-Sys

-- ais 3st 1rn IA-90-58 i I RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF MI"

I I ***'

INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST MAR g 1 ]ggg h*eea// '

\

oocati wusta si .eww.m a t CA;t S TE R g j g IV[s. MMH CO Mor' l PART l -RECORDS RELE ASED OR NOT LOCATED (See checaed bonesi _

No agency records subact to the roovest have been located No additoral agency records subrect to the request have been located Agency records subact to the rowest that are cant 4.ed in Append O.OSURE Certa.n nforn.eton in the reouesad record, is being wnbhold from pubhc d,scio.w re pu swant to t*e FOI A esewtons Ascnbed .n and for the ressor.: stated in Pari 11. sec-tons B. C. and D Any re5 eased sortons of the documeets for wNch nedy part of the record es being withheld are teing made svariab'e for pubi< inspecton and copy *g an the NRC PutAc Docurnent Room,1717 H Street. N W . WasNegton DC. in a folder under tNs FOIA number and reques'er rtame.

Comments 5 G%ager icToe. DMS% e ~ *

,ss a%+4 arconos

j_ 3

/* f M Ob 8803240175 880321 PDR FOIA CONNOR87-845 PDR NGC FOF.M 464 M n 19 01

e FR,EEDOM 'OF INFORM ATION ACT RESPONSE FC.A NUMBER (S) NDIk-87-6Y6/ N-M DATE PAQV 118- APPLICABLE FOIA EXEMPTIONS I Records subr*ct to the reqirest that are descnbed in the enclosed Appendeces ____ are t dr , withheld in their entirety or en part under FOtA Emernations and for the reasons set forth below pursuant to 5 U S C. 552tbl and 10 CFR 9 Stal of NRC F agulations i

1. The wthbeid eformation a pecretty classAed pursuant to Executivs sder 123% (EXEMPilON 11

2. The withheid information relates soiety to the eternal personnel rules and procedums of NRC. IEXEMPTION 21

3. The wthheld information is specifica8v esempted from public desciosure by statute indicated IEXEMPTION 31 Secten 141-145 of the Atomic Erwegy Act *Nch rec 5 tutt the Mclosure of Restricted Data or Forrnerfy Hest .cted Data 142 U.S C. 21612t661.

Section 147 of the Atormc Energy Act *Nch proNtwts t' e discbsu er of Unclass4 fed Sa reguards information 142 U S C. 216h

4. The wrthheld informaton e a trade secret se commercial or financel eformation that es beeg uthbeid for the ressorWsl edscated IEXEMPf 60N 4 The r?ormaton a considered to be coef dentel busmess lpropnetaM anformation The eformaton e cor side'ed to be propnetary enformation pursuant to 10 CFR 2.790(dl(1).

The eformaron was subemited and received m conf 4snce from a foreign source pursuant to 10 CFR 2 790td)(21.

5 The *rthheid eformaton consists of mteragency or otrassency eecords that s'e not availatae through escovery durmg litigaton. Osclosure of predecsonal infe+mation

• ould tend to mNtut the open and frar* enchange of ideas essentel to the debberatrve process Where records are wrthheld m thee entrety. the facts are mentncath X etertweed wth the edece.onal informaton. There also are no reees edirect inquiry eto t{e preoecesional process of the agency. #E N EMPTiON segregable factual portions because the release of the facts would perrest an G. The wthheM information is esempted from pubiec d4sclosve because ris disclosur e would result m a clearfy unwarranted irwasson of personal pn acy (EXEMPTION 61 7 The withheld information corersts of evestgatory records comoded for iae er forcement purposes and a being wrthbeid for the reasonist edicated CFMPTION h Declosure would eteriors wth an er forcement proceedeg because et could revesi the scope, dwecton, and focus of enforcement eHorts. and thus covid posetWy a%* them to take action to sheid poter tial wrong $oeg of a violation of NRC requwements from ensestgators (EREMPTION h An Doctosure *ovW constitute # un*stranted anvason of ce'sonal prwacy iEXEVPTION 7lCil The eformaton ccesets of na nes of etuduais and other r'ormaton the dsclosur e of *Nch would reveal identites of wf4eetal sou ces r (EXEMPTION 7tois PART ll C-DENYINO OFFICIALS Pursuaet to to CFR 9 9 and or 915 of the U.S Noser Regulatory Comrassen regulatons,it has been deterrmned that the mformaton weheid e ener"ct from producton or desciosure, and that its producton or dec!osure is contrary to the pubbc emerest. The persons respons,bie for the derdel are those officials contifed below as denymg officers and the Director.

Divison of Rules and Records. Offce of Adme>st'ation. for any derwats that may be appealed to the Eiecutw Dweetor for Operatens root DENYING OFFICIAL TITLE OFFICE RECORDS DENTED l APPELLATE OFFICIAL j SECattany EDo

\Ak e P M$N h k i

/ 31 I l

PART 110- APPEAL RIGHT5 The denial by each denying official identfied in Part 11.C may be appealed to the Appenaf e Officia: identified in that section. Any such appeal must be in writeg and must be made withen 30 days of receipt of this response. Appeals must be addefrssed as appropriate to the Esecutive Director for Operations or to the Secretary of the Commission, U S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washangton, DC 2C555, and should c'evy state on the envelope and in the letter that at es an "Appeal from an initial FOIA Deces on "

{

i Nac mone esa iron ri am U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION I FOlA RESPONSE CONTINUATION l

0 .

Re: FOI A- 87-845/F0l A-88-50 APPENDIX A RECORDS MAINTAINED AMONG POR FILES NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION

1. 11/5/83 "Independent Assessment Program for Comanche Peak Steam Electric, Sta tion, Final Report' TR-83090-01 (Draf t) Volumes 1 and 2 Dockets Nos. 50-445/446. ACN: 8311100079 2,

10/12/84 Errata and revised pages to "Independent Assessr.ent Program for Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, Final Report," 1R-83090-01, Docket Nos. 50-445/446.

ACN: 3411070049 3, 7/16/84 "Independent Assessment Program, Final Report (Phase 3)," TR-84042-01, (Draf t) Volumes 1-4, Docket Nos. 50-445/446. ACN: 8407310145 4,

11/20/84 Errata and revised pages to "Independent Assessment Program. Final Report (Phase 3)," Docket Nos.

50-445/446. ACN: 8411270334 5, 1/25/85 Ltr from N.h. Williams (CYNGA) to V. Noonan (USNRC),

Subj: Status of IAP Conclusions. Docket Nos.

50-445/446. ACN: b501300494 l l

6. 4/ 4/85 Ltr from N.H. Williams (CYNGA) to J. Beck (TUGCO),

Subj: Review Issues List - Independent Assessment Program All Phases, Docket Nos. 50-445/446.

ACN: 8504090007 l

i Re: F01 A- 87-845/F01 A-88-58 APPENDIX B RECORDS TOTALLY WITHHELD l 1

DESCRIPTION AND EXEMPTION NO. OF PG NUMBER DATE l

1. Undated (DRAFT) Comanche Peak SSER No. 5 48 (Includes 5520 Document Page which is attached because of date value (11/06/84) ,

EXEMPTION 5 j i

2 4/5/85 Note to Various Individuals from G. Bagchi 90 transmitting copy of 4/8/85 Draft of SSER #5 l which has Appendix 11 as separate document attached. EXEMPTION 5 O

e l

P i

- --. ._-. . . - -