ML19331B092
| ML19331B092 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Midland |
| Issue date: | 11/05/1976 |
| From: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19331B085 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8007250787 | |
| Download: ML19331B092 (17) | |
Text
.
~
,U UNITED-STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE'THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of
)
)
CONSUMERS PONER COMPANY
)
)
Docket Nos. 50-329 (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2
)
50-330 GILDERT S.
KEELEY TESTIMONY CORRECTIONS The following corrections should be made in the written testimony of Gilbert S.
Keeley filed in this pro-
'ceeding on November 5, 1976:
1.
In Line 19 on page I-3, delete " grade".
2.
In Line 20 on page I-3, delete " grade".
3.
In Line 7 on page I-5, change "it" to "them".
4.
In Line 9 of the third paragraph on page II-1, change " Exhibit 1" to " Exhibit 4".
5.
In Line 2 on page II-2, change "6 (e) " to "6 (f) ".
6.
In Line 1 on page IV-1, change " Exhibit 16" to
(
" Exhibit 17".
1 7.
In Line 24 on page IV-3, change "7%" to "7 1/4%".
8.
In Line 15 on page IV-4, delete "and" after " fuel" and insert "and insurance" after " taxes".
9.
In Line 18 on page IV-4, add " Nuclear insurance costs were escalated at 4 1/2% per year." at end of the Line after " case".
8007250 7 h
m
. 10.
In Line 22 on page IV-4, add "through the remaining life of the Midland Plant." after "them"; delete "for 34 years".
11.
In Line 5 of item 8 on page IV-4, change " Exhibit 15" to " Exhibit 16".
12.
In Line 2 on page IV-5, add "and insurance" after
" tax"; change " rate" to " rates"; change "was" to "were".
13.
In Line 6 on page IV-5, change " Exhibit 18" to
" Exhibit 19".
14.
In Line 5 on page IV-6, change " suspension" to.
" continuation".
15.
In Line 8 on page IV-6, change " Exhibit 19" to
" Exhibit 20".
16.
In Line 20 on page IV-7, change " Exhibit 20' to
" Exhibit 21".
~
17.
In Line 1 on page IV-8, change " Exhibits 21 and 22" to " Exhibits 22 and 23".
18.
In Line 13 on page IV-8, change "2.66" to "2.73".
t 19.
In Line 15 on page IV-8, change "2,59" to "2.66".
20.
In Line 17 on page IV-8, change "one" to "the".
21.
In the first column of item 4 of Exhibit 6C, page 1, add " Containment" after " Penetrating".
22.
In the first column of item 5 of Exhibit 6C, page 1, change " Motor" to " Motion".
23.
In the fourth column of items 35, 38 and 40 on Exhibit 6C, page 4, change " Exhibit 7A" to " Exhibit 6A".
, ~,
. 24.
In the first column of Exhibit 17 under Item 6A, change "1,061,600" to "1,061,000".
25.
In the first column of Exhibit 17 under Item 6B, change "1,265,500" to "1,270,000".
26.
In the first column of Exhibit 17 under Item 95, change "1,323,000" to "1,231,000".
27.
In the first column of Exhibit 17 under Item 10A, change "6,230,000" to "6,374,000".
28.
In the first column of Exhibit 17 under Item 10B, change "767,000" to "775,000".
29.
In the first column of Exhibit 17 under Item llA, change "3,372,000" to "3,462,000".
-30.
In the first column of Exhibit 17 under Item llB, change "1,10 8,000 " to "1,120,000".
31.
In the second column of Exhibit 17 under Item 6A, change "1,063,700" to "1,062,000".
32.
In the second column of Exhibit 17 under Item 6B, change "1,268,500" to "1,272,000".
33.
.In the second column of Exhibit 17 u'nder Item 9B, t
change "1,323,000" to "1,231,000".
34.
In the second column of Exhibit 17 under Item 10B, change "766,000" to "774,000".
35.
In the second column of Exhibit 17 under Item llB, change "1,050,000" to "1,119,000".
36.
In the third column of Exhibit 17 under Item 6A, change "1,120,000" to "1,119,000".
37.
In the third column of Exhibit 17 under Item 6B,
. change "1,336,200" to "1,340,000".
38.
In the third column of Exhibit 17 under Item 9B, change "1,420,000" to "1,322,000".
39.
In the third column of Exhibit 17. under Item 10B, change "820,000" to "828,000".
40.
In the third column of Exhibit 17 under Item 11B, change "1,193,000" to "1,205,000".
41.
In the fourth column of Exhibit 17 under Item 6A, change "1,063,500" to "1,063,000".
42.
In the fourth column of Exhibit 17 under Item 6B, change "1,271,700" to "1,273,000".
43.
In the fourth column of Exhibit 17 under Item 9B, change "1,323,000" to "1,231,000".
44.
In the fourth column of Exhibit 17 under Item 10B, change "760,000" to "768,000".
45.
In the fourth column of Exhibit 17 under Item llB,
~
change "1,101,000" to "1,112,000".
46.
In the fifth column of Exhibit 17 under Item 6A, change "1,158,400" to "1,158,000".
t 47.
In the fifth column of Exhibit 17 under Item 6B, chr.ge ~1,:35,000" to "1,387,000".
48.
In the fif th column of Exhibit 17 under Item 9B, change "1,488,000" to "1,385,000".
49.
In the fifth column of Exhibit 17 under Item 10B, change "850,000" to "859,000".
50.
In the fifth column of Exhibit 17 under Item llB, change "1,242,000" to "1,253,000".
n 51.
In the first column of Exhibit 20 under " Midland Plant - Operation & Maintenance" change "502" to "410".
52.
In the first column of Exhibit 20 under " Midland Plant - Total Generation Cost" change "3,421" to "3,329".
53.
In the second column of Exhibit 20 under " Midland Plant - Operation & Maintenance" change "502" to "410".
54.
In the second column of Exhibit 20 under " Midland Plant - Total Generation Cost" change "3,333" to "3,241".
55.
In the third column of Exhibit 20 under " Midland P1 nt - Operation & Maintenance" change "530" to "432".
56.
In the third column of Exhibit 20 under " Midland Plant - Total Generation Cost" change "3,646" to "3,548".
57..
In the fourth column of Exhibit 20 under " Midland f
Plant - Operation & Maintenance" change "502" to "410".
58.
In the fourth column of Exhibit 20 under " Midland Plant - Total Generation Cost" change "3,238" to "3,146".
59.
In the fifth column of Exhibit 20 under " Midland Plant - Operation & Maintenance" change
""49" to "446".
- 60.
In the fif th column of Exhibit 20 under " Midland Plant - Total Generation Cost" change "3,795" to "3,692".
61.
In the first column of Exhibit 20 under " Alternative -
Capital Cost" ch ange "1,0 61. 6 " to "1,0 61. 0 ".
62.
In the first column of Exhibit 20 under " Alternative -
Taxes & Insurance" change "495.0" to "503.0"..
63.
In the first column of Exhibit 20 under " Alternative -
Fuel" change "6,230.0" to "6,374.0".
64.
In the first column of Exhibit 20 under " Alternative -
Total Generation Cost" change "8,720.1" to "8,871.5".
65.
In the second colunn of Exhibit 20 under " Alternative -
Capital Cost" change "1,063.7" to "1,062.0".
66.
Ir. 9.s sacer.i
- 02_
- ....
- l Inhi__
- :: u n '._ ; '.t.I:crn.._ -
Taxes & Insurance" change "496.0" to "504.0".
67.
In the second column of Exhibit 20 under " Alternative -
Total Generation Cost" change "8,851.2" to "8,857.5".
68.
In :he third column of Exhibit 20 under " Alternative -
Capital Ccst" change "1,120.4" to "1,119.0".
(
69.
In the third column of Exhibit 20 under " Alternative -
Taxes'& Insurance" change "522.0" to "530.C".
70.
In the third column of Exhibit 20 under " Alternative -
Total Generation Cost" change "9,435.4" to "9,442.0".
71.
In the fourth column of Exhibit 20 under " Alternative -
Capital Cost" change '1,0 6 3. 6" to "1,0 6 3. 0 ".
72.
In the fourth column of Exhibit 20 under " Alternative -
Taxes & Insurance" change "496.0" to "504.0".
n.
73.
In the fourth column of Exhibit 20 under " Alternative -
Total Generation Cost" change "8,804.1" to "8,811.5".
74.
In the'fifth column of Exhibit 20 under " Alternative -
Capital Cost" change "1,158.4" to "1,158.0".
75.
In the fifth column of Exhibit 20 under " Alternative -
Taxes & Insurance" change "543.0" to "5??.0".
76.
In the fifth column of Exhibit 20 under " Alternative -
Total Generation Cost" change "9,800.7" to "9,809.3".
77.
In the first column'of Exhibit 21 under " Midland Plant - Operation & Maintenance" change "502" to "410".
78.
In the first column of Exhibit 21 under " Midland Plant - Total Generation Cost" change "3,421" to "3,329".
79.
In the second column of Exhibit 21 under " Midland Plant - Operation & Maintenance" change "502" to "410".
80.
In the second column of Exhibit 21 under " Midland Plant - Tctal Generatien Cost" chapg'e "3,333" to "3,241".
81.
In the third column of Exhibit 21 under ""idland Plant - Operation & Maintenance" change "530" to "432".
82.
In the third column of Exhibit 21 under "Hidland Plant - Total Generation Cost" change "3,646" to "3,548".
. 83.
In the fourth column of Exhibit 21 under " Midland Plant - Operation & Maintenance" change "502" to "410".
84.
In the fourth column of Exhibit 21 under " Midland Plant - Total Generation Cost" change "3,238" to "3,146".
85.
In the fif th column of Exhibit 21 under " Midland Plant - Operation & Maintenance" change "549" to "446".
88.
In the fifth column of Exhibit 21 under " Midland Plant - Total Generation Cost" change "3,795" to "3,692".
87.
In the first column of Exhibit 21 under " Alternative -
Capital Cost" change "1,265.5" to "1,270.0".
88.
In the first colunn of Exhibit 21 under " Alternative -
Taxes Insurance" change "590" to "602".
89.
In the first col'hmn of Exhibit 21 under." Alternative -
Fuel" change "3,372" to "3,462".
90.
In the first column of Exhibit 21 under " Alternative -
(
Total Generation Cost" change "6,407" to "6,513.5" 91.
In the second column of Exhibit 21 under " Alternative -
Capital Cost" change "1,268.5" to "1,272.0".
92.
In the second column of Exhibit 21 under " Alternative -
Taxes & Insurance" change "534" to "603".
93.
In the second column..of Exhibit 21 under " Alternative -
Total Generation Cost" change "6,475" to "6,547.5".
4 94.
In the third column of Exhibit 21 under " Alternative -
capital Cost" ch ange "1,3 3 6. 2 " to "1,3 4 0 ".
95.
In the third
'olumn of Exhibit 21 under " Alternative -
Taxes & Insurance" change "623" to "635".
96.
In the third column of Exhibit 21 under " Alternative -
Total Generation Cost" change "6,861.2" to "6,877.0".
97.
In the fourth column of Exhibit 21 under " Alternative -
Capital Cost" change "1,271.7" to "1,273".
98.
In the fourth column of Exhibit 21 under " Alternative -
Taxes & Insurance" change "593" to "604".
99.
In the fourth column of Exhibit 21 under " Alternative -
Total Generation Cost" change "6,533.2" to "6,545.5".
100.
In the fif th column of Exhibit 21 under " Alternative -
Capital Cost" change "1,385.0" to "1,387.0".
101.
In the fif th column of Exhibit 21 under " Alternative -
Taxes & Insurance" change "646" to "657".
102.
In the fifth column of Exhibit 21 under " Alternative -
Total Generation Cost" change "7,091.3" to "7104.3".
In the first column of Exhibit 22 pn' der " Alternative" 103.
change "8,720.1" to "8,871.5".
104.
In the first column of Exhibit 22 under " Midland" change "3,421" to "3,329".
105.
In the first column of Exhibit 22 under " Ratio" change "2.55" to "2.66" in both cases.
106.
In the second column of Exhibit 22 under " Assuming Continuation - Alternative" change "8,851.2" to "8,857.5".
r n 107.
In the second column of Exhibit 22 under " Assuming Continuation - Midland" change "3,333" to "3,241".
108.
In the second column of Exhibit 22 under " Assuming Continuation - Ratio" change "2. 66 " to "2. 73 ".
109.
In the third colurn of Exhibit 22 under " Assuming Continuation - Alternative" change "8,804.1" to "8,811.5".
110.
In the third colunn of Exhibit 22 under " Assuming Continuation - Midland" change "3,238" to "3,146".
111.
In the third column of Exhibit 22 under " Assuming Continuation - Ratio" change "2.72" to "2. 80".
112.
In the second column of Exhibit 22 under " Assuming suspension" change "9,435.4" to "9,442".
113.
II. the second column of Exhibit 22 under " Assuming Suspension" change "3,646" to "3,548".
114.
In the second c".'umn of Exhibit 22 under " Assuming Suspension - Rat'lo" change " Ratio-2.59" to
" Ratio =2.66".
115.
In the third column of Exhibit 22 under " Assuming f
Suspension" change "9,800.7" to "9,809.3".
116.
In the third column of Exhibit 22 under " Assuming l
Suspension" change "3,795" to "3,692".
l 117.
In the third column of Exi.ih! t 22 under " Assuming i
Suspension - Ratio" change " Ratio-2.58" to
" Ratio =2.66".
118.
In the first column of Exhibit 23 under " Alternative" change "6.407" to "6,513.5".
_ ~.
-m
. 119.
In the first column of Exhibit 23 under " Midland" change "3,421" to "3,329".
120.
In the first column of Exhibit 23 under " Ratio" change "1.87" to "1.95" in both cases.
121.
In the second column of Exhibit 23 under " Assuming Continuation - Alternative" change "6,475" to "6,547.5".
122.
In the second column of Exhibit 23 under " Assuming Continuation - Midland" change "3,333" to "3,241".
123.
In the second column of Exhibit 23 under " Assuming Continuation - Ratio" change "1.94" to "2.02".
124 In the third column of Exhibit 23 under " Assuming Continuation - Alternative" change "6,533.2" to "6,545.5".
12f.
In the third column of Exhibit 23 under " Assuming Continuation - Midland" change "3,238" to "3,146".
126.
In the third column of Exhibit 23 under " Assuming Continuation - Ratio" change "2.02" to "2.08".
i 127.
In the second column of Exhibit 23 u'nder " Assuming i
l Suspension" change "6,861.2" to "6,877".
128.
In the second column of Exhibit 23 under " Assuming Suspension" change "3,646" to "3,548".
129.
In the secon? cclumn of Exhibit 23 under " Assuming Suscension - Ratio" change " Ratio-l.88" to
" Ratio =1.94".
130.
In the third column of Exhibit 23 under " Assuming
. Suspension" change "7,091.3" to "7,104.3".
. 131.
In the third column of Exhibit 23 under " Assuming Suspension" change "3,79t" to "3,692".
132.
In the third column of Exhibit 23 under " Assuming Suspension - Ratio" change " Ratio-l.87" to
" Ratio =1.92".
In order to facilitate understanding of the changes numbered 24 through 132, revised Exhibits Numbered 17, 20, 21, 22, and 23 have been prepared which include these changes and' have been attached to this list.
d7
)/
e7 d/
7 n1 1
e/
' p9 t
t n
a 0) 0 0) 410) 0 00 0 0 0
0 0
0 0
0
)
i z( uo 00 0
00 7)73 0
0 00 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 b
l (St P/ n6 c,0, 0,
0,0 1,7, 0,
0 0,0, 0,
0, 0,
0, 0,
0, 0,
0, 0
3 i
0, 7,
0, h
1 5
5 0
60 9
01 2
5 2
5 4
9 6
3 x
n/o7 33 1
46 3 6 5
7 53 8
8 2
8 8
5 5
E o9i/
5$
1
(
1 1
7 1,3, 3,
9 3,
2, 8
9, 2,
5 d
t2
.(
(
(
nnc1
'l 1 1
1 7
3 1
aOi b
n:e A
t o sr nP o
C deun i
t t
n n
0)
'0 0
0
)
00 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0,% 460) a?oT 00 0
0 7275 0
0 00 C
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 lCTn/
0,0, 0,
0 l
1,4, 0,
0 0, C, 0,
0, 0,
0, 0,
0, 0,
0, 3
P/
0, 7,
0, 1
5 4
1 1
60 1
33 9
5 0
1 3 8 3
2 n/o/
90 3
66 1
6 0
4 67 2
7 4
3 7 6 5
1 8
o9i9 55 1
(
1 1
1 8
0,2, 8
0, 8
2, 1,
7 3,
1, d
t
(
(
(
nnco 11 1
1 6
3 1
aOuT b
r A
tsno C
de d7 nT e/
t p5 n
ri 0) 0 0) a7uo 00 0
00 M 3 M )5 0
)
00 0
0 0
0 0 0 0
0 2i 0
0 00 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 l 7St 0, 0, 0,
0,0 0, 9, 0,
0 0,0, 0,
0, 0,
0, 0,
0, 0,
0, 0
3 P/
0, 7,
0, 90 6
7 9 2 3
8 0
5 1 n6 8
s 8
65
)
s n/o(
72 15
$7 2 6 5'
5 14 9
3 8
2 2
2 6
0
'0 e5i/
4$
1
(
1 1
6 1,3, 5
3, 0
3, 9,
8 7,
2, d
t 2
(
(
(
0 nnc1 11 1
1 6
3 3
0, aOu b
ri r 1
A t c s r nF o
C tu r
D d
i e
x t
u i
n n
r o
i c
t t
to n
n 0) 0 0) 648) 0
)
00 0
0 0 0 0
0 0
0 t
t nT oT 00 0
00 c185 0
0 00 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 A
n 1TcT 0,0 0,
0,0 0,5, 0,
0 0,0, 0,
0, 0,
0, 0,
0, 0,
0, 3
t e
P/
n/
0,
) 0, 7,
0, o
m 1
1 0
68 6
22
, 0 0
1 2
4 7
9 i
(/)
t_
n n/ o/
02 57 1
6 7
0 67 5
7 4
3 7
7 0
1 l
o o$i5 5$
1
(
1 1
7 0,2 7
1, 8
I d
d t
(
(
(
2, 2,
7 4,
1, n
nnco
'l 1 1
1 6
3 1
a aOuT b
r l
A A
ts d
n e
o t
C tu r
l t
6 0) 0 0) 006) 0
)
00 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 a
7 00 0
00 0005 0
0 00 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 E
n /
0, 0, 0,
0,0, 0,6, 0
0 3
0, 0
0,0, 0,
0, 0,
0, 0,
0, 0,
0, otl 7,
0, d n/
2 6
6 60 9
10 1
8 0
1 4
5 2
0 nap 1 5 3
57 1
6 2
67 6
5 4
3 7
7 6
2 al3 44 1
(
1 1
0,2, 6
2, 8
2, 3,
7 4,
1, bP
(
(
(
A n
O 11 1
1 6
3 1
E
)
)
r r
u u
f t
[
l n
1 u
o a
4 s
0 t
l e
0 2
ud P
c h.
ti t
i w
e t
a n
l iv
)
A tt i
l oP e i nr I
l b
a t
m s
i a
(
(
i s
i t
e s
t m t
r so s
o nn
,o h
c t
t x
l c
o l
eNl r
P eI ox o
e s
o E
a a
t a
r e
u r
t cn o
c o
c.
l r
i i ut u b
)
edn nT C
n C
a so o.
t r tdM r
t aF m
er 1
f na t
a 0
ni o
i D l
i u
c f nl s
e I s oaf t
d f e o
iip o
r d n
n n
n 1
nt
- n o
e t
t s t
e o
e e
cPo h
nd ou n
0 Dd C
t a i
t o i
o l b
eo F
0 ie t
n t
nc t
ne o
t utt ptt t
t 6
rt t l
n ie s
l x x
n n
t f Sossf xt af a
a 1
i o nn a
o a c n
mt i
ia ia t
o o
l ot o Et oo o
o (l n ina t
C Mn e
!T o
MT o
L
/wrc i
s d f Cc nC C
C ao d
i i
O dd o
dd f
p p
o t
ee nt ae t n o
ooc n
et p
n d n a h t )i ip ru aunru aonu n
o t C a
o nu nn nn ul Dotl oCol o
s a
r C i us t
aa t
ae k
l !
r t a l
i na C
i a i o nru rtA t
n n
n n
c iV adt oV LLV t
P rur ua o
o u
nI a
no a
no i
c d
t eac l J n.
s r
eri wooc C
r o
l oc l
oc r
?
no rt 1b e eol r
u t1 u oCti e i r P
in P
in e
h eg et1 uc uCl u o P
l
- 4c P
v o
p t u t i t i t
- p u,t tl cCa F
ea t
AI rur T
O ie o
s n
n e a
I-l lbme v
l cv o
l h
ouoe l nl tl na tl ru as x
t ndl renl t
x ont auin n
nupa n u pn o
c una nuaa I
ia fwc nht s d
d eee aees m
o ees l
I mupn i
r e
tC tCCaG oFCC n
n l
o t
l hPt i a
aFO!
rFOI iFOI l
c l
l o
o g
a a
c t
w a
r d
d t
t n
l.
l I.
u...
1 o
o..
i t
. 1.
1 l..
i PA P
A I
tADC 0
D CAD 1
r 4
M HA1 AAD AAE s
e 1
2 3
4 5 6 7
8 9
0 1
Se 1
1
- I
. Analysis II Exhibit 20 Coat to Complete and Operate Midland Vs Cost of Abandoning tiidland and Installing and Operating Alternative Capacity (Iov Sulphur Coal)
(141111ons)*
To Complete at 12/1/76
' To Co nplete at 5/1/77 To Conplete at 9/1/77 Assuming Suspension Assuming Suspension Assu. ting Continuatisn of Construction Assuming Continuation of Construction -
of Construction at 12/1/76 of Construction at 12/1/76 ff!DIAID PIAIT*
Midland to-go Capital Cost 1,258 1,170 1.337 1,075 1,385 Taxes 768 768 835 768 883 Fuel 8k0 8k0 889 640 922 Operation & Maintenance 410 410 432 410 446 tiuclear Insurance 53 53 55 53 56
)
Total Generation Cost 3.32' 3,2h1 3,548 3,11 6 3,692 4
Abandon at 12/-1/76 Abandon at 5/1/77 Abandon at 9/1/77 i
Assuming Guspension Assuming Suspension Assuming Continuation of Construction Assuming Continuation of Construction of Construction at 12/1/76 of Construction at 12/1/76 A!Er;!<.l ATIVE8 Cipital Cost 1,061.0 1,062.0 1,119.0 1,063 0 1.158.o Stlvageable Material (61.3)
(68.9)
(72.3)
(75.3)
(81.h)
Dov Dual Purpose Cost (70.8)
(92.8)
(90.4)
(109.0)
(108.1) lteimbursement Cancellation Cost of Material 66.7 68.9 70.9 45.4 47.7 asui Cubcontracts Hinus Sal-vage Ve.lue (!!et of !! umber 2A-28)**
Site lh'storation Cost 80.3 100.8 82.0 131.0 82.8
+
Purchasing Power and/or 661.0 775 0 596.0 829.0 582.0 Lifferential Power Cost Taxes & Insurance 503 504 530 504 51 9 Fusi 6,374 6,272.0 6,923.o 6,173 0 7,284.0 Operation & l'.aintenance 272.0 270.0 298.0 264.0 310.0 liuclear Fuel Cost ik.h (13.5)
(ib.2)
.(13.6)
(14.7)
(Net or number 3 + 3B -3C)**
Total ceneration Cost 8,871.5 8,857.5 9,442 8,811 5 9,809.3 eCJcts are stated in fbture value dollars as or the dc.ta rnd column 5 e 6/1/82.
of commercial operation af Midland Unit 2, ie, columns 1, 2 and 4 e 3/1/81, Column 3 e 12/1/81 oeFrom Exhibit 17.
t Analysis II 1.xhibit 21 Cost to Complete and Operate Midlard Vs Cost of Abandoainc Midland and Installing and Operating Alternative capacity (High Sulphur Coal)
(Millions)
To Comolete at 12/1/76 To complete at 5/1/77 ToCompleteat9/1/77 Assuming Continuation Assuming Suspension Assuming Continuation Assuming Suspension i
of Construction of Construction at of Construction of Construction at j
12/1/76 12/1/T6 MIDIAND PLANT l
l Midland'to-go Capital Cost 1,258 1,170 1,337 1,075 1,385 Taxts 768 763 835 768 883 ruel Bl o 67 0 BS)
Bf.0 922 i
Optration & Maintenance 410 410 432 410 446 Nacicar Insurance 53 53 55 53 56 J
Total Generation Cost 3,329 3,241 3,54S 3,146 3,692 Abandon at 12/1/76 Abandon at 5/1/77 Abandon at 9/1/77 Assuming Continuation Assuming Suspension Assuming Continuatic Assuming Suspension of Construction of Construction at of Construction of Construction at 12/1/76 12/1/77 ALTER'IATIVE l
C2pital Cost 1,270.0 1,272.0 1,340.0 1,273.0 1,387.0 Salvaceable Miterial (613)
(68.9)
(72 3)
(75 3)
(81.4) l Dov Dual Purpose Cost (TO.8)
(92.8)
(90.4)
(109.0)
(108.1) l Reimbursement f
C;ncellation Cost of Material 66.7 68.9 70 9 45.4 47 7 end Subcontracts Minus Sal-i v:ge Value (Net of Number j
2A-2D)**
Site Restoration Cost
.J0.3 100.8 82 131.0 82.8 PurchasedPowerand/or Differential Power Cost 661 ~
755 5%
829 582
)
Taxca & Insurance 602 603 635 604 657 Fuel 3,462 3,407 3,760 3,353 3,956 l
Operation & Maintenance 518 516 570 506 5)6 Nucitar Fuel Cost (Net of number 3 + 3B - 3c)**
(14.4)
(15 5)
(14.2)
(13.6)
(14.7)
Total ceneration Cost 6,513.5 6,547.5 6,877 6,545.5 7,104.3 Cats are sta+ d in future value dollera as of the date of coasnercial operation of Midland Unit 2, i.e., columns 1, 2 and 4 e 3/1/81, column 3 e 12/1/81 and column 5. 6/1/82
- fFrom Exhibit 17.
I
^
~
E:chibit 22 Analysis III Abanden=ent Ratic of Generatic: Cest of Midland with Cec-eration ecs: cf an alter ative Generating Facility (I.cv Sulphur Coal) 12/1/76 5/1/77 g/1/77 Assu=i=g Continuatien Assu=ing Contin'.m ic:
Alternative 8,871.5 8,857.5 8,811.5 Midland.
3,329 3,241 3,146 Ratio = 2.66 Ratio = 2.73 Ratio = 2.80 Ass"-ing Suspensic:
Assu=ing Suspensien 9,W2 9,809.3 3, M,
3,692 Ratio = 2.66' Ratio : 2.66 Ratio : 2.66 o
9 i
l I
{
a e
-ew e.
+a
, we
~---~#---
e
.~
e v
-,-,w
- e.,,
,,r, e--,
m-,-,e
~
a -
4 4
hhdbit 23 Analysis III Abandc=ent E=:ic of Generatic: Cost of Midland 'Jith Generatic: Cest of an Alternatite Generating Facility (High 5:1;hur Ccal) i 12/1/76 5/1/77 9/1/77 Assu=ing C:stinuatic Assu=ing Cc=:i =:ic:
Alter==:ite 6,513.5 6,sh7.5 6,545.5
!cd1=i 3,329 e
3,241 3,140 htio = 195 Ratio = 2.02 Ratio = 2.08 Asst-d:g S sge: sic:
Asst =ing Su pensic 6.87/
7,104.3 3,M Soon Ratio = 195 Ratio = 194 Ratic 1 92 O
e e
e e
a
,.