ML17208A892

RCS Asymmetric Loads Evaluation,Numerical Results - Evaluation of C-E Fuel, App A,Nonproprietary Version

ML17208A892
Person / Time
Site:	Saint Lucie
Issue date:	07/31/1980
From:	ABB COMBUSTION ENGINEERING NUCLEAR FUEL (FORMERLY
To:
Shared Package
ML17208A891	List: L-80-263, Forwards RCS Asymmetric LOCA Load Evaluation, Revision 1, Including App B & Nonproprietary & Proprietary Versions of App A.Proprietary Version Withheld (Ref 10CFR2.790). Affidavit Encl ML17208A890 ML17208A892 ML17208A893
References
NUDOCS 8008120433
Download: ML17208A892 (46)

Text

APPENDIX. A NON-PROPRIETARY RG AS NNhYRIC I.ogpu EVALUATION ST.LUCIE 1 8008180 90ct(G4 "p 8~8]rgyyg 1 trol >

n W~ ggnCgmglYf KGQSTG~~ BXKHBX

I I

I I

I I

I

APPENDIX A NON PROPRIETARY RCS ASYMMETRIC LOADS EVALUATION NUMERICAL RESULTS EVALUATION OF CE FUEL Prepared by

.COMBUSTION ENGINEERING, INC.

for St. Lucie 1

July 31, 1980

APPENDIX A NUMERICAL RESULTS EYALUATION OF COMBUSTION ENGINEERING FUEL

Appendix A

TABLE A-1 14X14 SPACER GRID STRENGTllS AT ROON TEMPERATURE ONE SIDED

'HROUGH GRID

I I

l

Appendi.x A TILE A-2 rurL ASSEMBLY COMPONENT slRFssEs Maximum Stress ksi Co~monent End Fitting Castings End Fitting Posts Guide Tubes Fuel Rods Base Case Revised Model Ratio Allowable Stress

(~ksi Castings Posts Fuel Rods Guide Tube Pro er';ies Yield Strength Figure A-10 Strain Capability -

Figure A-14

I

Appendix A TABLE A-3 SPACER GRID INPACT LOADS Case Maximum Im act Loa~ds lh

• Peri heral Assemblies Interior Assemblies Iiax One-Sided Max Thru-Grid Max One-Sided Max Thru-Grid FPlB (l)

'PlB (2)

• Listed as Revised

'tiodel (Base Case}

(1) Full Power Inlet Break - Core Direction Perpendicular to Hot Legs (2) Full Power Inlet Break - Core Direction Parallel to Hot Legs S acer Grid Im act Stren th lb One Sided Thru-Grid

~Im act Load Ratios Revised hiodel Base Case)

Peripheral Assemblies One Sided Thru-Grid Interior Assemblies One Sided Thru-Gr id A.3

I

This Page Intentionally Blank A.4

I i

I

This Page Intentional~ly Blank A.5

FIGURE FUEL ASSEYiBLY LATERAL LOAD DEFLECTiON CURVE

I l

'I

FI GURE n-'2 FuE< nssE~oo cnTERnc ir~pncT t.ono vs.

iwj:Trnt. uTErle orspcnccr>ENT A.7

'IGURE A-3 FUEL ASSEMBLY FUNDPHENTAL FREQUENCY VS.

At3PLITUDE A.8

l k

FIGURE A-4 FUEL ASSEMBLY DAHF'ING RATIO VS." At1PLITUDE

FI GURE K-5 SPACER GRID APPROACH VELOCITY VS.

DROP HEIGHT

t k

II

~UR~6 HAXIYiUiMONE-SIDED SPACER GRID IMPACT LOAD DISTRIBUTION FULL POllER -INLET BREAK

P MAXIMUYiTHRU-GRID IYiPACT LOAD DISTRIBUTION FULL POlJER INLET BREA'.12

This Page Intentiona] ly Blank A.13

l, I

1 I

cu a

sst s

~ g pgfasII-I.~THM~CLE~DIVI~

sas s

Ca M Cs asst I

a ch cs M class s

~

a s

s

~

I I

I I

I I

I

~

~

a

~

s

~

~

~ a

- YIELD):S

>>is'I>>

a>>

FL

~Illli, isl aa II' s

1,I'l"

l',i

.i:i;.',I;,',.

REN T AUGUR E'l; lIHE NC

~4~O a

ssl I

I I

I I

I I

Ca at CS alt s I

I I

I I

I I

I I

I I

i I

I I

I I Ill v

c u cssssi I

I I

I I II I

I I

I I

I

~

~

~

~

~

I I

I I

s I

',lil l'-':

L'I.".;:.I TXOH jII 0

.l R

I l

l I

EI: A-.~'ll:j

',',',.l.I.!

LID iZI

l!}

IRCAA ER I"iP.

O,Y s

I I

I I

~

~ ~

a Sas I

s

>>-I

~

~

I I

a

'as Ct 'ld>>

~

i s

s 00.T 500(..'L'E)ATEO.- FEiIIPERAT aIIl; Ia a

-3. >>-:I s

a

~ isi 'a

'ii"'s:>>

saI'>>

>>Ilia 11>>

I'is

~

~ s

':l' a ~

~ '>>st s

I

~~>>

~

v~~I

~

~ ~~

~ I~

- -I

-= s-T s

s

~ ~

~ ~

I aa-t" s

I a

}-Il q a

I s

I s

ll" a

~ a 1

} J

's

~.}M

I

~--=>>I 0-

~I s

s s

s l

a

l;i s

Or s

s I

s l

s s

~

~

s I

I I's

-'I" I OII O19!

~ a

~ ls

\\

's a

~

~ ~

~ ~

a s

a 1 ~ '.

sa a

a ~

.;.'I:

s

~

~ a

I a ".

sl

.I a I

-I

, I1 sill!

s s

s}!

s I ~

sl

'F,;1':II a I1,,!i I!i: i",I 1 'I I

U)A iis

~'l sl si!'

I a'. ~

/cm I

, ~

a' i',ii

'i

>> I

-'I ji;I

,Is

} I':

e'jII a

a a

sis t>>l, i

I s

I

~

~

a ~

s s

~

1 s

a s

IP

~

~

0 4

v ao aoi s

SEMI LOGARITHMIC5 CYCI.ES X 70 DIVISIQAS KKVFFD. IO ESSKR CO.

<<aaocan u.ta 4

an an vcoe>

1 s

I s

~

I s

~

I I

i I

I 111 s

s

~

~

~

~

I I

s an ah v ao aoi l

l l

I I

I I

I II I

I I

I II

~

~

~

~

~

46 6210 4

an I

I I

I I

I

~

~

an V CO sol I

I I II I

I I

I I

I i ll I

I 111 j

I I

I an ca v oo aoe

~

I s

I i

I 1

I l

I s

Y.EEL

~

~

Iiii ilia illa 'l1:

iIi!

I.'iI'l' sli ',':

REH TH

Lt-I!}!

IGUR sais

~ 's ~

I!I ",.'.

s

's "s

ts F. 'UEt C

!!! I E~iA

>!Ij

!liiil i!I s

}'}

L'I})'ll l0 s

s i,lss

}i,;(

Nf) sil E,'o'":t' s, sl il I}

s ~

sl ~I 1

1.1 s! ~,

!11 i is s

sl,'l

!i 1

ERMA

-l ll I I

I!II

'CT.

'EF,'FsE

~ ~

1 Ii Il!'

'.ii!}

i.'!:}

ss<<"1 a ~

}

~

~

0-J s

s

. LJ.

..LJ.+

s s

s s

i'I 'I s 1!

'1

'ls s

I s<<

~ I

...LL.

s 1 I s"'i" ss sii s

IIIII

'I"i tiaitsi

's

'I T

~t 11

}I,';

l!ii Ii}:.}

si';:}

1!.

siss sss

!ii!

s ss I',.

n.

I Is s ~ s t.

'isi s';

I s

si ls, Mi 1

s I

~

s

]o'9}

I',

~ I

~ l

~ ~

sl s,

~ s

.1'h

's s

.;I s

1 ss j

~

1 1

I I

ijl.

s la I

~ ~

I Ii

~.. o iiss

~q (LE'Pil I Il!

I

'I

/

~ l I i!i tie

~ s i!!

, III 11 ~ k

~ s ~

is 1': }I!:"

y') s si si llll I

~

~

~I~

s

..I I

s l

s I

I

FIGURE A-ll 1

DISTt<IBUTIoN or-texIvut~ GuIDr TuBE sTRrss FULL POHER INLET BREAK l'PER END FITTING thAXIHUfh GUIDE TUBE STRESS KSI GRID 1

LOWER END FITTING

This Page Intentionally Blank A.17

OP W

Ch Ch V COO(

Ca>

Ct Ctl Ctt V Cl O i

i t

~

i i

i I I

I I

I I

I II

~

~

~

~

~

~

(Jpt

(}t1 t!}l !Ill ll !It i

!(II(:I:-.

OTA it!i I',II

l,:

Iti;.

k l,!t

I I'

1!

'I'!!!

"I.

,II

,;I I.

--'EL'oIIG t!I Itttt

I.:

,'it"I,U

~SE I-LOGAR( i HM(C S CYCLES ~70 IV(SI ih(S K E

((KUFSKL ((t KSSKR CO.

ttwx tent u.s.a.

Ctt 4t I.

I I

I

.:. -.~>> ll, i'A'-',1:,3.'GuAE!

t it!

'll, I,i I(. t.l Tl

('I

',!fj F

! I II ill}

'll!!

I!!,',!

I,I!

Ill!

Ii t II(

I

,.t,

'.t it',II GE Cth C

V eO(

I 1

i i i I I

I

(

I II I

I I

I I

I

~

~

I j.}

~ !

I

)

~ !I)(tl(

!i!'.!I!'.*.

ilI t(i:

I' I

}4}

FOR

!A

',"'I

"':!l ED!

46 6210 (t

Ctl I

I I

I I

I I

I M "ER Ct v COOI

(

I I

I I I

I I (I I

I I (I I

I I I I

~

~

i

~ (

1 - -.

~

t Ctt (t

I I

(

I th Ch V I

~

I I

I ti

~ ~

CO O ~

I l(

I I

~

~

~

RRAOrj(t }d}II VIP'E'RATukEiII-

~ I' OO':Tot hsooF::.'-'! I EL VATED-TEt1PERATU!IE I t

~ -)-

IT-l-l:::l :::I+I i i!!1!ilail::,".lti:

till.!:(! I(l I

I

~

I "t

~

~

I

~r

(

I I 'L t-

. }-I OI I

t(5

- U)

-(

i

~

~

I

~

.+I

~

I t!t' til t

-I r~(

('

I

~', 'ttt ll ~ 't t

1 i

~ (till i ~I'tt t't iiitt'tt't'It'ttt'ti Ct i t itiil~ ~ ll

~ t,

~ ~,

~tt I,I I I

t

~

t I

~

~

i

.I 1.-'gT9 lt( ~

I 1 i il',

Ii(

'I}'tj.

i('t II.'-'i I;(!

!:;I ilt'[',I

II l,ljo!

L~J l !ill

, il,l llli tl(l I!It I'!.f I(!t I

I I

~'ii 2't!

't

~

I

'it'.'

I! I l Qj (1

l 1,/

I,I II',I I'.!(

'Ig; I'.(i

!litlt;tt t(ii tit,

~ t ~i

~ll

~

I I

~

I

~ I i ~

t

... Li I

A.18

(I I'

~I

'I l

~

I

~l-l.oggPHMI~I.ES~l ISI~

s<<s t<<t t<<

lti ch 4s cl sD 1

I I

~

I 1

I I

I 1

t<<s 4

sti St<<4S Cs <<ts I I

I I

I I

I I II

~

1

~

~

I

~

cn o u soei I

I I I! I I

I I

I I

I I

~

~

~

1

~

I I

3 I

I I

I I

lit I

I I

I I

I I

4s sss <<ttl I

I I

I I I

I I

I I

I I

I I!

I I

I I

I I

I I

1 I

I I

s4 I

I I

I l

I 41 Cl <<SS<<4S<<

I 1 l l-I I

I I

~

~

Ill<<

is

,,t,,i 1

~

ij't!!!

t'I;i':

STR tiATE

~ ~ 1. ~ I,. l,.l

<<ji!:

~i'l r1ll I',

I,.t 1

P itl 1<<

1

.1,

<<1.

1<<t

" t.

Elm F,IGL!R AS

.B LI!7i'I l E

IC'!

ti

,N

'rl

."JJ

~ <<

.I P,L jll!

}II sll!

lilt Ii.

I,I'

<<1 I!I A T ij<<

'I

'! 1 I

<<.." -i-}

-AS'FU Illtl<<jiistilt ll il" 'l 1

"~

OF.-t CEi

!.l:

FOP, I'

..J-. '

....,l...

I

<EALED:-l

~

l I

~

l

~ <<

mJ I

~

1 I

1 i

1 i ~i T

LMM'. '-

I

~t'

• I jf<<js4<<<<j&t

~ ~ 1 It! <<<<+.I tiT TjlT l ii!lj'.1'll'tf'3'!TJ!!IIII;I!litt!

! I I Illlll Iliil!1st tt!:1st'I".11"

'I 't lsil ~

~

<<1 1O",

<<s

<<'t'1st l Its jlsj I l

~

! l l

I 1 I Its i I~T

~ I

<<Ll!

t!11

,Ij!I

)it i}i!

ssj!

j.'ll 1 <<l, tit!

i!lit!

t ~

i!;

1<<j l 1.

it,t

,I I"<<'t

~

I I ~

iII!

,I:.

sllll

}j!

~

1

<< ~;I 1 1 [

t 1, i!

l l:!!t'.;I tjji t." IS tl;: L11!.'t

'Hi'ce 4

11't:

N.

(E 4

~

~Iii tl ~ 1 jI!:

lil.'jt!

1!

s s

1<<

t' Itg2I l

I l, ~"

FB.'1'1

~

1 s

I i

1 1

A.19

V ll I

FIGURE R-1'ISTRIBUTION Or lNXIHUH GUIDE TUBE STRRIN FULL PO'HER INLET BREAK HAXIIIUI<GUIDE TUBE ELASTIC STRAIN Grid 1

~

4 nn

-I I

I

s Csf D

CSI CI V CO fO I sss s

I cu e

co n v ccseC s

f s

~

f s

s I

I I

I I I'I I I s

s

~

~

f KCCIFFCI.CCs CSSCR CO.

SsSOCSVCSOa.

M Os I

1 I

I s

I W W PR e v cofcsl s

s 1

s I

I I

I I II I

~

I I I

\\

~

I s

~

~

os v css el

~

I I

I I I

I 1 II I

I I

I I

I 1

I I

~

~

I I

I s

fsf I

Os f I Cs f

I I

I I

I 1

\\

V COs 1

1 I' I

s I

s I

~

1 1

YIELD".S sf I

1 ~ I s

REf'l

~

~ I

~ s t.t, lli

-V ""

si I

LLu'er IIGU 0)! F I sf

.;,,tl,'

I 1

ssi ti!Is.:'.

Il'j LED is:s 'l,'lj's'Ij""

~

tCOF"ST, I

~

~.-I 1 Ill CIIIts'I',

~ ~

t t'-

CT I I f

~ ! 'I,l ss I

I 1 iflifi if" "

II

~

1 s

1 s

I s

I 1

I II!IIIIIIIIIIII!Il is I

.-I- '.IH I'l-'I::sill':I-;I;-+I------+

'-,"-l-.l-s++-'

s l¹I wI 6

L Is s

v' f

1

~

~

~'

s

~

t ~

~

~ ii

'1ii)

~

sij s

~, j,I.I Iu'e'nce cin l

(:E 1 t

~

v)..j I 'I

-s,i s

1 I

O22 I

1

~

~

~

~

I I

1

~

I

I I